TC wrote:Where did I ever say it was easy? I didn't, You and I both know it is not, but neither is flying the space shuttle or playing in the NBA, NFL or PGA... but they get paid to do it... THEY GET PAID... that means they are professional refs... they are not Pastors who ref the local high school games. IF they can not handle it GET OUT... QUIT.. BUT make the call you see, get it right and don't worry about being over ruled from the press box. I don't want my team to win or lose because a ref missed a call, or made a bad one.
Yes that game is over... to be BLUNT I never saw the play, the call (if I did it wasn't enough for me to remember) I watch a ton of football games, game after game I see something happen and refs look at eachother to see if one of them is going to blow the whistle or throw the flag. IT is called a Judgement call.... MAKE A CALL to the best of your judgement. Hey I could throw a fit, there is holding on almost every play. but call it the same on both sides and then that is the way the game is played.
I think the the replay is the WORST thing that has happend to college football. It should be a good thing, it should hold refs accountable for their calls and if they consistantly make bad calls they will not be calling games. BUT it has become a way to cover thier butts.
Lets just take all the weight off the refs and Why don't we just put tracking devices in the ball and all thru the field, on the sidelines and goal lines, make them light up if they are touched. put a timer in the ball and it has to be held for 2 seconds before it is a catch if it touches the ground it will light up. as soon as the ball is snapped the clock will start automaiticly... YEP that would kill the game... use refs but expect them to make the call and get it right... make them accountable IF they consistantly miss calls retrain or get him out
Tony, I don't ever recall you saying it was easy. What I do recall is every time UL/UT loses, it's the officials fault. You cry and bellyache because of it.
I get paid to call High School games, every official get's paid, but that in and of it'self does not make you a professional. As a matter of fact, [know what you are talking about Tony] College football officials work real jobs during the week as do NFL officials. The NBA, MLB, NHL all have
PROFESSIONAL OFFICIALS but the NFL and College football does not. It's been a major complaint for years by NFL coaches, players that is the only professional sport that does not have them.
I do know of Pastor's that officiate college games, they do it for two reasons, the love the game, and they love the kids. Most of the officials I know do call what they see. They don't guess at it, either you seen it or you didn't. When players come up to me and say, I'm being held, or he grabbed my face mask, I will tell them I didn't see, if I do, I'll call it, or I'll be watching for it.
Tony, I disagee with you on instant replay. The worse thing about it, is you have a guy in a booth who has nothing at stake in the game, either agreeing or overruling a call on the field. The guy in the booth has the ability to either one, make a guy look good, or two, make a guy look bad. Yes, use instant replay, but do it like the NFL. No coaches request, have the guy in the booth signal the field, but have a monitor for the White Hat to look at. He is responsible for the crew, let him make the decision, not a guy in a booth.
Tony what does the majority of the fans do at a game? [waiting for the answer] They watch the ball!!!. Guess what I was before I was an official? I was a fan. And most officials where and are fans before they became officials. The hardest thing for me to do in both football and basketball is to stop watching the ball. I have to watch an area, and trust that my partner is doing the same. I will confess there are still times I get caught up watching the ball, and I'm trying hard to break that habit. But I can also tell you after attending 5 different college football games this year in 3 different stadiums, college football fans
DON'T KNOW THE RULES! It's certainly different in basketball, most fans know the rules better. But again most fans are watching the ball and not an area. So there are times when I'm watching an area, that I miss a hold, or I miss a facemask or I miss a push [in basketball]. I will also tell you that when I attend games now, I'm not watching the play as much as I'm watching the officials. I want to see are they watching their area, or they watching the game. There is a major difference.
Since you watch "game after game" try watching the officials next time instead of the ball and see what they are watching, believe you can tell.
If I were to read, much less answer, all the attacks made on me, this shop might as well be closed for business. I do the very best I know how, the very best I can, and I mean to keep doing so until the end. If the end brings me out right, what is said against me won't amount to anything. If the end brings me out wrong, ten angels swearing I was right will make no difference." -Abraham Lincoln