Heres one for you

A forum for the discussion of TV, movies, music and pop-culture influences from a Christian perspective. A free-wheeling forum for discussion of Christian issues.

Moderators: Pastor Gary, The J2 Mod Squad

TC
Hey, hey, hey
Posts: 1922
Joined: February 20th, 2003, 5:00 pm
Location: "the Ville" ky

Heres one for you

Postby TC » November 27th, 2006, 4:48 pm

even WITH the replay the refs still get it wrong...

http://www.sportsline.com/collegefootball/story/9832320

Officials are looking over their shoulders at Big Brother up in the booth. They're afraid to make calls. In some cases, you can actually see them looking at each other on bang-bang plays, thinking, a) "Should I?" b) "Touchdown?" or c) "You call it."


That is exactly what I have been saying... (remember Rob). Before it was a judgement call... now it is do I make the call and take a chance on getting it right or just don't make the call.

User avatar
Rob
Hey, hey, hey
Posts: 1605
Joined: April 14th, 2004, 4:59 am
Location: USA,Kentucky

Re: Heres one for you

Postby Rob » November 29th, 2006, 3:43 am

TC wrote:even WITH the replay the refs still get it wrong...

http://www.sportsline.com/collegefootball/story/9832320

Officials are looking over their shoulders at Big Brother up in the booth. They're afraid to make calls. In some cases, you can actually see them looking at each other on bang-bang plays, thinking, a) "Should I?" b) "Touchdown?" or c) "You call it."


That is exactly what I have been saying... (remember Rob). Before it was a judgement call... now it is do I make the call and take a chance on getting it right or just don't make the call.


I've said it once, I'll say it again Tony, you think it's easy? TAKE THE TEST, become an offical. You know what's amazing? The official was right. Oregon won the game. The won on Sept. 16, and they still won it today! Oklahoma still has a loss. Doesn't matter what you think, or what I think. The offical when he made the call it was correct. End of discussion. Stoops and Oklahoma and the rest of us (and I did say us, because I feel it was a bad call) can cry foul all we want to, but at the end of the day, Oregon is still going to win the game.

After reading the article here is the one correction that needs to be made in College football.

"I was talking to an NFL guy," Stoops said. "That's why the (official) on the field reviews plays. (The officials) take more pride in it, that, 'This is my team out here. We want this right.' There isn't any worry about who's feelings you hurt."
If I were to read, much less answer, all the attacks made on me, this shop might as well be closed for business. I do the very best I know how, the very best I can, and I mean to keep doing so until the end. If the end brings me out right, what is said against me won't amount to anything. If the end brings me out wrong, ten angels swearing I was right will make no difference." -Abraham Lincoln

TC
Hey, hey, hey
Posts: 1922
Joined: February 20th, 2003, 5:00 pm
Location: "the Ville" ky

Re: Heres one for you

Postby TC » November 29th, 2006, 3:14 pm

Pastor Rob wrote:
TC wrote:even WITH the replay the refs still get it wrong...

http://www.sportsline.com/collegefootball/story/9832320

Officials are looking over their shoulders at Big Brother up in the booth. They're afraid to make calls. In some cases, you can actually see them looking at each other on bang-bang plays, thinking, a) "Should I?" b) "Touchdown?" or c) "You call it."


That is exactly what I have been saying... (remember Rob). Before it was a judgement call... now it is do I make the call and take a chance on getting it right or just don't make the call.


I've said it once, I'll say it again Tony, you think it's easy? TAKE THE TEST, become an offical. You know what's amazing? The official was right. Oregon won the game. The won on Sept. 16, and they still won it today! Oklahoma still has a loss. Doesn't matter what you think, or what I think. The offical when he made the call it was correct. End of discussion. Stoops and Oklahoma and the rest of us (and I did say us, because I feel it was a bad call) can cry foul all we want to, but at the end of the day, Oregon is still going to win the game.

After reading the article here is the one correction that needs to be made in College football.

"I was talking to an NFL guy," Stoops said. "That's why the (official) on the field reviews plays. (The officials) take more pride in it, that, 'This is my team out here. We want this right.' There isn't any worry about who's feelings you hurt."


Where did I ever say it was easy? I didn't, You and I both know it is not, but neither is flying the space shuttle or playing in the NBA, NFL or PGA... but they get paid to do it... THEY GET PAID... that means they are professional refs... they are not Pastors who ref the local high school games. IF they can not handle it GET OUT... QUIT.. BUT make the call you see, get it right and don't worry about being over ruled from the press box. I don't want my team to win or lose because a ref missed a call, or made a bad one.

Yes that game is over... to be BLUNT I never saw the play, the call (if I did it wasn't enough for me to remember) I watch a ton of football games, game after game I see something happen and refs look at eachother to see if one of them is going to blow the whistle or throw the flag. IT is called a Judgement call.... MAKE A CALL to the best of your judgement. Hey I could throw a fit, there is holding on almost every play. but call it the same on both sides and then that is the way the game is played.

I think the the replay is the WORST thing that has happend to college football. It should be a good thing, it should hold refs accountable for their calls and if they consistantly make bad calls they will not be calling games. BUT it has become a way to cover thier butts.

Lets just take all the weight off the refs and Why don't we just put tracking devices in the ball and all thru the field, on the sidelines and goal lines, make them light up if they are touched. put a timer in the ball and it has to be held for 2 seconds before it is a catch if it touches the ground it will light up. as soon as the ball is snapped the clock will start automaiticly... YEP that would kill the game... use refs but expect them to make the call and get it right... make them accountable IF they consistantly miss calls retrain or get him out

User avatar
Rob
Hey, hey, hey
Posts: 1605
Joined: April 14th, 2004, 4:59 am
Location: USA,Kentucky

Re: Heres one for you

Postby Rob » November 30th, 2006, 5:44 am

TC wrote:Where did I ever say it was easy? I didn't, You and I both know it is not, but neither is flying the space shuttle or playing in the NBA, NFL or PGA... but they get paid to do it... THEY GET PAID... that means they are professional refs... they are not Pastors who ref the local high school games. IF they can not handle it GET OUT... QUIT.. BUT make the call you see, get it right and don't worry about being over ruled from the press box. I don't want my team to win or lose because a ref missed a call, or made a bad one.

Yes that game is over... to be BLUNT I never saw the play, the call (if I did it wasn't enough for me to remember) I watch a ton of football games, game after game I see something happen and refs look at eachother to see if one of them is going to blow the whistle or throw the flag. IT is called a Judgement call.... MAKE A CALL to the best of your judgement. Hey I could throw a fit, there is holding on almost every play. but call it the same on both sides and then that is the way the game is played.

I think the the replay is the WORST thing that has happend to college football. It should be a good thing, it should hold refs accountable for their calls and if they consistantly make bad calls they will not be calling games. BUT it has become a way to cover thier butts.

Lets just take all the weight off the refs and Why don't we just put tracking devices in the ball and all thru the field, on the sidelines and goal lines, make them light up if they are touched. put a timer in the ball and it has to be held for 2 seconds before it is a catch if it touches the ground it will light up. as soon as the ball is snapped the clock will start automaiticly... YEP that would kill the game... use refs but expect them to make the call and get it right... make them accountable IF they consistantly miss calls retrain or get him out


Tony, I don't ever recall you saying it was easy. What I do recall is every time UL/UT loses, it's the officials fault. You cry and bellyache because of it.

I get paid to call High School games, every official get's paid, but that in and of it'self does not make you a professional. As a matter of fact, [know what you are talking about Tony] College football officials work real jobs during the week as do NFL officials. The NBA, MLB, NHL all have PROFESSIONAL OFFICIALS but the NFL and College football does not. It's been a major complaint for years by NFL coaches, players that is the only professional sport that does not have them.

I do know of Pastor's that officiate college games, they do it for two reasons, the love the game, and they love the kids. Most of the officials I know do call what they see. They don't guess at it, either you seen it or you didn't. When players come up to me and say, I'm being held, or he grabbed my face mask, I will tell them I didn't see, if I do, I'll call it, or I'll be watching for it.

Tony, I disagee with you on instant replay. The worse thing about it, is you have a guy in a booth who has nothing at stake in the game, either agreeing or overruling a call on the field. The guy in the booth has the ability to either one, make a guy look good, or two, make a guy look bad. Yes, use instant replay, but do it like the NFL. No coaches request, have the guy in the booth signal the field, but have a monitor for the White Hat to look at. He is responsible for the crew, let him make the decision, not a guy in a booth.

Tony what does the majority of the fans do at a game? [waiting for the answer] They watch the ball!!!. Guess what I was before I was an official? I was a fan. And most officials where and are fans before they became officials. The hardest thing for me to do in both football and basketball is to stop watching the ball. I have to watch an area, and trust that my partner is doing the same. I will confess there are still times I get caught up watching the ball, and I'm trying hard to break that habit. But I can also tell you after attending 5 different college football games this year in 3 different stadiums, college football fans DON'T KNOW THE RULES! It's certainly different in basketball, most fans know the rules better. But again most fans are watching the ball and not an area. So there are times when I'm watching an area, that I miss a hold, or I miss a facemask or I miss a push [in basketball]. I will also tell you that when I attend games now, I'm not watching the play as much as I'm watching the officials. I want to see are they watching their area, or they watching the game. There is a major difference.

Since you watch "game after game" try watching the officials next time instead of the ball and see what they are watching, believe you can tell.
If I were to read, much less answer, all the attacks made on me, this shop might as well be closed for business. I do the very best I know how, the very best I can, and I mean to keep doing so until the end. If the end brings me out right, what is said against me won't amount to anything. If the end brings me out wrong, ten angels swearing I was right will make no difference." -Abraham Lincoln

TC
Hey, hey, hey
Posts: 1922
Joined: February 20th, 2003, 5:00 pm
Location: "the Ville" ky

Postby TC » November 30th, 2006, 2:47 pm

Tony, I don't ever recall you saying it was easy. What I do recall is every time UL/UT loses, it's the officials fault. You cry and bellyache because of it.


Well then one of two things have happened...UofL and UT have not lost any games since the WVU last year... because that was the ONLY game you have heard me complain about a bad call costing UofL or UT a loss... or you are recall ability is making things up.

amateur - a person who engages in a study, sport, or other activity for pleasure rather than for financial benefit or professional reasons

when you do something for money(or financial benefit), you are doing it as a profession, that makes you a professional. I don't care if it is for gas money it is a financial benefit. AND you need to get it right or find something else to do with your time. It does not matter if you also cut grass or are a pizza boy... you still get PAID... you are a professional and as a professional you need to get it right. Are you saying calling college games is not a real job? to me it is, to me if you get paiod it is a JOB, if you don't get anything for doing it ... it is a hobby.

I am not saying that ANY ref does it only for the money, and their motives about the game and the kids is great.

I do watch the refs alot more than most people, A ref that is bold with a call is most likely calling it as they saw it.. but when ref hesitate on a call and look at each other... that is the problem. I try to make the call of where the play is going and who will get it. I watch the rec as he makes his route. IF I see something that I didn't think was called correctly I watch that ref to see it they are missing other things. You and I have never been to a football game but you can ask Todd, I usually am looking thru the glasses, I have my headphones on listening to the call, trying to get any info I can.

My team win or lose I want it to be right. IF you recall I am the one that said UT was not that good this year, I was the one that said they would lose 3 to 4 games. I am the one that said that Rutgers totally stopped UofL in the second half. Yes there are bad calls in EVERY GAME. some are game changers and some are not, A bad call in a close game which gives a team a 1&10 or 4th &10 can change a game... ESP now with the clock not stopping.. on first down on a bad call late inthe game can cost a team the game. Judgement call are the differences between and incomplete pass and a fumble, they are totally a judgement call as to if he had control of the ball or not... that is a call the refs need to make and stand by that call... stepping out of bounds is NOT.

After two years of replays no one will ever be able to prove to me that some refs are not second guessing if they are going to make a call or not... IT IS HUMAN NATURE... Rob If you had someone looking at EVERY PLAY, EVERY CALL MADE to see if it is correct you would not be human if you did not question your calls. No one wants to be over ruled or in other words have someone say to everyone OVER THE PA that YOU made a mistake. I don't know for a fact it is being done but I would be willing to bet SOME coach of some team out there is having some assistant tracking every call made that was reversed all season and who made that call and that list will be checked when refs are picked for next season.

User avatar
Rob
Hey, hey, hey
Posts: 1605
Joined: April 14th, 2004, 4:59 am
Location: USA,Kentucky

Postby Rob » December 1st, 2006, 6:03 am

Tony you cried foul at the WVU game last year. Since UL has not lost except to Rutgers, and you knew better to cry foul in that game because UL got it handed to them by Rutgers, you have not cried this year because they are winning. Amazing how winning stops crying.

I Pastor I get paid for it, but I'm not a professional Pastor, Pastoring is my profession. My wife and I have had a yard sale, but we are not Professional Yard Saler's. Which makes your state correct that you are doing it has a profession, not as a professional.

A ref that is bold with a call, is what we as officals term "selling the call" and the more bold you are with it, the less likily it is to be questioned. However, I have had it happen to me more than once already this basketball season, the ball went out of bounds. I couldn't see who touched it last, because of players blocking my view, guess that makes me a poor offical in your book, so I looked to my partner for help. Also, I have seen a ball go out of bounds, and my partner totally missed the call, I blew my whistle to assist him, not to make him look bad, but to make sure the call is correct. Guess he is a poor offical as well.

Tony if you are watching a receiver run his route you are not watching the offical, so you have no idea what he is seeing! That qualifies you as a fan, not a judge of the offical. If you are listening to headphones, no doubt to the home school, who are biased, because they are being paid by the school, guess that would make them professional play by play guys, will probably cry foul when a call is not made.

Point in fact. Here in our football and basketball Association we are rated as officals. We are rated by the coaches of teams, and by our Assigning Secretary. Your rating determines what quality of games you get and coaches can scratch you from calling their games. But you know what Tony it has not stopped me from calling what I see. I get graded, there have been games that I have graded out very good, and some I graded out not so well. The coaches and the Assigning Secretary were very fair to me even if calls went against them.

Tony, it's real easy when you are in the stands, but it is a whole new ball game when you step on the field or on the court. Here's my line when I meet a center court or midfield to the players. You don't miss any shots, and I won't miss any calls, you complete all your passes and I'll catch all the penalties.
If I were to read, much less answer, all the attacks made on me, this shop might as well be closed for business. I do the very best I know how, the very best I can, and I mean to keep doing so until the end. If the end brings me out right, what is said against me won't amount to anything. If the end brings me out wrong, ten angels swearing I was right will make no difference." -Abraham Lincoln

TC
Hey, hey, hey
Posts: 1922
Joined: February 20th, 2003, 5:00 pm
Location: "the Ville" ky

Postby TC » December 2nd, 2006, 2:08 pm

What I do recall is every time UL/UT loses, it's the officials fault. You cry and bellyache because of it.


OK so really it is not a mistake it is a TYPO... you mispelled One by spelling it e v e r y,

In fact the ONLY game you have heard me complain about the refs causing UT or UofL a game was that ONE TIME... and since the BE officials stated that they blew that call and since it did give WVU the ball back for their last series of regulation, Since UofL had been able to hold on to the ball and run the clock...IT DID COST THEM THE GAME... IT WAS A BAD CALL that is just the fact.

My def of Professional... someone who does something and gets paid for doing it. Someone who take pride in their profession. ... BTW when you are having a yard sale, in fact you are becoming a salesman (sorry anita) you are changing goods for an amount of money. I consider you a professional pastor. You got paid to do it, you take pride you the way you do that work... AS A REF I think you are the same way, You do get paid, and from what you say YOU take pride in your work as a ref. TO ME that makes you a professional.

there is a BIG difference in calling a basketball game and a football game, In basketball it is a faster and missing who touched a ball before it went out of bounds is alot different than if someone dropped a pass or fumbled after he caught the ball....two totally different things...

I would much rather a ref ...."sell the call" than be timid about making a call....that is what they are there for...TO MAKE A CALL. I would much rather them call what they saw and not be timid and be wrong and overruled than not making a call, IF there is NO call it can not be overruled.

Yes you have been graded, and most likely it was fair... IT is also fair for someone to say...THAT REF missed 5 calls and he made 4 that were overturned...He wa overturned 8 times this year, we saw several calls he did not make... WE don't want that ref again. You may like to believe that every ref is has no other thoughts than that one game... Last year in college basketball, I remember a ref that made a bad call in an ACC game and the next game he did everything he could to get back on the good side of that coach. IT IS HUMAN NATURE...if you are graded you want to get a good grade and that will be in the back of your head.


Return to “Entertainment”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 24 guests

Login  •  Register