Possible Play-off System? Or at least a starting point.

A forum for the discussion of TV, movies, music and pop-culture influences from a Christian perspective. A free-wheeling forum for discussion of Christian issues.

Moderators: Pastor Gary, The J2 Mod Squad

User avatar
Rob
Hey, hey, hey
Posts: 1605
Joined: April 14th, 2004, 4:59 am
Location: USA,Kentucky

Re: Possible Play-off System? Or at least a starting point.

Postby Rob » November 14th, 2006, 4:51 am

TW wrote:
Pastor Rob wrote:TW, thank you for your work. I appreciate all the time energy and effort it took to comply that list.

I only have a few questions for you. First, remember now in college football there are no ties. You play overtime till someone wins. So it would simply be won/lost record.

My first question is on the Total Offense/Total Defense where did that information come from? I know that WVU in rushing offense is one of the top 2 or 3 teams in America. Passing is a different subject. You state that all D-1 teams have to meet minimum standards. My question is what are those standards?

I still think you have to figure in somewhere in the mix, the Strength of Schedule. While I have noticed you include Boise St. on your list, in all fairness, there is not a team you have listed that if they played Boise's schedule they would also be undefeated.

I noticed on your formula that Florida, Arkansas, where out of the playoffs, with all due respect, those have to be 2 of the top 8 teams.

While again I commend you on your work, those are some things that I believe in your system would not work.

My $.02


Rob I shall address your questions in the order in which you asked them.

"My first question is on the Total Offense/Total Defense where did that information come from?"

http://www.ncaa.org/stats/football/footballMenu.html

"You state that all D-1 teams have to meet minimum standards. My question is what are those standards?"

This is off the official NCAA website:

Division I
Division I member institutions have to sponsor at least seven sports for men and seven for women (or six for men and eight for women) with two team sports for each gender. Each playing season has to be represented by each gender as well. There are contest and participant minimums for each sport, as well as scheduling criteria. For sports other than football and basketball, Division I schools must play 100 percent of the minimum number of contests against Division I opponents -- anything over the minimum number of games has to be 50 percent Division I. Men's and women's basketball teams have to play all but two games against Division I teams; for men, they must play one-third of all their contests in the home arena. Schools that have football are classified as Division I-A or I-AA. I-A football schools are usually fairly elaborate programs. Division I-A teams have to meet minimum attendance requirements (average 15,000 people in actual or paid attendance per home game), which must be met once in a rolling two-year period. Division I-AA teams do not need to meet minimum attendance requirements. Division I schools must meet minimum financial aid awards for their athletics program, and there are maximum financial aid awards for each sport that a Division I school cannot exceed.


All D I programs are limited to the same minimum/maximum financial aid awards. They have a mimimum number of sports that must sponsor. In theory they all start out equal.

"While I have noticed you include Boise St. on your list, in all fairness, there is not a team you have listed that if they played Boise's schedule they would also be undefeated."

This system is based soley on statistical data, and the data supports Boise St. being in the mix.

"I noticed on your formula that Florida, Arkansas, where out of the playoffs, with all due respect, those have to be 2 of the top 8 teams."

At the present time the stats do not support Florida and Arkansas being in the top eight. I do think that by the end of the season much will have changed in the ststa and the top eight will be somewhat different than it is presently shown.


TW


TW, thanks for your facts and figures. I understand better your formula, but not sure I like it.

User avatar
dolfan
Established Member
Posts: 8016
Joined: March 17th, 2004, 1:25 pm
Location: USA,Alabama
Contact:

Postby dolfan » November 14th, 2006, 5:47 am

Pastor Rob wrote:
Dolfan, for the most part I have agree or at least made sense of most of your posts. However, this one has got me thinking the dude is one of two things. Drunk or doing drugs.


:lol:

I promise, I'm doing neither one! I'll lay off the Big East, too. I'll pick on C-USA instead. :wink:

I don't want to eliminate conferences, but if TW's system is to work, I think you'd have to do that or you wind up with these unusual results of a this season's (if it ended today) Boise St. getting in over a UF or Arkansas.
To factor in strength of schedule is still too much of a beauty contest, leaving too much in the hands of subjective preferences. The only way I've seen that takes that out of the equation is the NFL system. I don't want to see traditional conference rivalries go by the wayside, which they would under an NFL-like scheduling process. I suppose it depends on what all ills you try to cure with a playoff.

But, you can't have conference champs from Mountain West and C-USA getting in over runner ups like an Ohio State or Michigan or Florida or Arkansas (or still mathematically in it in the SEC, Auburn or LSU), or even third place teams like one of those in the SEC/Big Ten/Big 12/ACC/Pac 10/Big East. That's just unconscionable!!!
Human government bears the same relation to hell as the church bears to heaven. (David Lipscomb, On Civil Government, 72).

User avatar
Rob
Hey, hey, hey
Posts: 1605
Joined: April 14th, 2004, 4:59 am
Location: USA,Kentucky

Postby Rob » November 14th, 2006, 8:16 am

dolfan wrote:
Pastor Rob wrote:
Dolfan, for the most part I have agree or at least made sense of most of your posts. However, this one has got me thinking the dude is one of two things. Drunk or doing drugs.


:lol:

I promise, I'm doing neither one! I'll lay off the Big East, too. I'll pick on C-USA instead. :wink:

I don't want to eliminate conferences, but if TW's system is to work, I think you'd have to do that or you wind up with these unusual results of a this season's (if it ended today) Boise St. getting in over a UF or Arkansas.
To factor in strength of schedule is still too much of a beauty contest, leaving too much in the hands of subjective preferences. The only way I've seen that takes that out of the equation is the NFL system. I don't want to see traditional conference rivalries go by the wayside, which they would under an NFL-like scheduling process. I suppose it depends on what all ills you try to cure with a playoff.

But, you can't have conference champs from Mountain West and C-USA getting in over runner ups like an Ohio State or Michigan or Florida or Arkansas (or still mathematically in it in the SEC, Auburn or LSU), or even third place teams like one of those in the SEC/Big Ten/Big 12/ACC/Pac 10/Big East. That's just unconscionable!!!


I'll let you pick on the CUSA.

My thing with the BCS was a few years ago, I think it was OK, or Nebraska that got into the Championship game and didn't even play in their conference championship game. I also remember the year K-State was so good, got beat in the championship game of the Big XII and lost and got shipped to the Alamo Bowl.

I don't think a team that can't win it's conference, be it Auburn, LSU, Arkansas, WVU, UL, MI. OSU. WI or whomever deserves to play for a National Championship, unless you open it up to 16 teams and have wild-cards.

Plus it forces ND a school I love to hate get in a conference. My only beef with the BE and Mike Tranghese is he has allowed ND to have the best of both worlds. Either get in the BE or get out. They do nothing for us as a Basketball school and share no revenues with football schools.

PS. I didn't think you were drunk or doing drugs. :lol:

TC
Hey, hey, hey
Posts: 1922
Joined: February 20th, 2003, 5:00 pm
Location: "the Ville" ky

Postby TC » November 14th, 2006, 1:21 pm

TW wrote:TC,

As I have stated, there is no system that is perfect and everybody will buy into. That's a fact! Could some schools try to manipulate this system? Yes! Do some schools try to manipulate the current BCS system? Yes!

The fact is that life is not fair and you either learn to play by the rules of life or you die or go insane. It's unfair that I wasn't born rich. It's unfair that I'm not 6' 4" tall. It's unfair that I have to compete in the workplace with guys that are 1/3rd my age and in perfect health.

The most accurate way to determine who should be eligible for a NC play-off berth is by statistical analysis. And now I have added SOS as a factor in the final determination. Or we could just throw all 119 D I teams in a hat and draw the finalist.

Pastor Rob and dolfan have both had positive input in this, but all we have heard from you is "it won't work!" I find it hard to believe that someone who knows football as well as you do cannot come up with some constructive thinking.


TW


I am not sure where it is at but I made a long bracket that allowed for a champ game and and a true champ. 16 teams, 6bcs conferences... ACC, Big 10, Big 12 Big East, SEC, Pac 10...+4 at Large... to cover ND, Boise State and all the non BCS conferences.. All other teams would be allowed bowl games that would be staggered up until the NC

Get rid of all conf champ games...The top two teams will get bids into the tourney... 1's against 2's, In SEC or conferences with 2 divisions the top two take both division winners and determine who is one by what ever means the conference decides (that is up to them) Games would be rotated on which conference would play which, or could do a random draw and that would go by conference with the best overall win % or what ever.

For the SEC and two division conferences it would get rid of the champ game, you will aready have ONE bowl game so really you are adding 3 more games to them and 4 to conf without champ game.

that would be closest to a real National champ... NOW I do have this in bracket form SOMEWHERE... but it might be another year or so before i find it again..

User avatar
ImaPK
-= J2 =-
Posts: 4300
Joined: March 14th, 2004, 10:42 am
Location: USA,Tennessee
Contact:

Postby ImaPK » November 14th, 2006, 2:20 pm

Ok, let's eliminate "March Madness" and just take the top two ranked teams at the end of the season and let them play for the NC of basketball...or the top two teams in baseball and let them play for the CWS...or the top two teams in golf...or track and field...or swimming...or hockey...heck let's just do it with all sports in the NCAA...let the "media" and the "computers" determine who plays for the NC in all sports...heck let's don't even play the games just pit the lineups against each other on a computer based on stats that can be manipulated...think about it folks, some "smart" group of men came up with the JOKE of the BCS...don't you think they could figure out a PLAYOFF system where the deserving teams AND the bowls could both win?...IT AIN'T ROCKET SCIENCE :roll:
People are so worried about what they eat between Christmas and the New Year, but they really should be worried about what they eat between the New Year and Christmas. Author Unknown.

User avatar
TW
Established Member
Posts: 8866
Joined: November 4th, 2004, 3:38 pm
Location: USA,Georgia
Contact:

Postby TW » November 14th, 2006, 3:28 pm

OK, let's face it!!! The National Championship is supposed to pit the two best teams against each other. To determine the ranking of different teams you must use objective not subjective means. The win/loss record is the most objective means, you either won those games or you didn't. Total offense is an objective means, you either gained the yardage and scored the points or you didn't. Total defense is an objective means, you either stopped them or you didn't. SOS is a subjective measure for the most part. The reason that I say this is because there usually will not be enough common opposition to arrive at any realistic comparision between teams in different conferences, so it relies on historical data between the various conferences. Or worse yet, it makes assumptions, i.e. Team A beat Team B, Who beat Team C, who beat Team D, who beat Team E, therefor Team A must be better than Team E.


TW[/u][/b]
Anglo-Saxon Proto-English Manuscripts (995 AD): “God lufode middan-eard swa, dat he seade his an-cennedan sunu, dat nan ne forweorde de on hine gely ac habbe dat ece lif."

My blog - http://theoldman.wordpress.com/

TC
Hey, hey, hey
Posts: 1922
Joined: February 20th, 2003, 5:00 pm
Location: "the Ville" ky

Postby TC » November 14th, 2006, 4:16 pm

That is the reason you forget the conf champs game.. (it is really only for the money...) Forget Polls no matter who put them out they are totally flawed... (example how can WVU be ahead of UofL when they have the same record and head to head UofL won) ALSO the people who vote in the polls have a vested interest... They want to sell papers and stories in the big football markets.. or they want their conference to look good in the polls and to make their schedule look good because they are playing this or that ranked team.. (after they are the ones that ranked them...)

polls and total O and D doesn't really mean anything.. it is wins and losses. THEN play Head to head ...WINNER take all..move to next game loser back home to get better...

User avatar
Rob
Hey, hey, hey
Posts: 1605
Joined: April 14th, 2004, 4:59 am
Location: USA,Kentucky

Postby Rob » November 15th, 2006, 3:49 am

ImaPK wrote:don't you think they could figure out a PLAYOFF system where the deserving teams AND the bowls could both win?...IT AIN'T ROCKET SCIENCE :roll:


NO if they could they already would have.

User avatar
Rob
Hey, hey, hey
Posts: 1605
Joined: April 14th, 2004, 4:59 am
Location: USA,Kentucky

Postby Rob » November 15th, 2006, 3:53 am

[quote="TC]

I am not sure where it is at but I made a long bracket that allowed for a champ game and and a true champ. 16 teams, 6bcs conferences... ACC, Big 10, Big 12 Big East, SEC, Pac 10...+4 at Large... to cover ND, Boise State and all the non BCS conferences.. All other teams would be allowed bowl games that would be staggered up until the NC

Get rid of all conf champ games...The top two teams will get bids into the tourney... 1's against 2's, In SEC or conferences with 2 divisions the top two take both division winners and determine who is one by what ever means the conference decides (that is up to them) Games would be rotated on which conference would play which, or could do a random draw and that would go by conference with the best overall win % or what ever.

For the SEC and two division conferences it would get rid of the champ game, you will aready have ONE bowl game so really you are adding 3 more games to them and 4 to conf without champ game.

that would be closest to a real National champ... NOW I do have this in bracket form SOMEWHERE... but it might be another year or so before i find it again..[/quote]

TC, why play a regular season? Why divide a conference into 2 divisions with your system? Why make exceptions for ND and non BCS conferences?

Just like baseball now, you don't have to win your division to be in the playoff's. NFL does the same thing.

In my opinion to be a true NC, you MUST win your conference.

User avatar
Rob
Hey, hey, hey
Posts: 1605
Joined: April 14th, 2004, 4:59 am
Location: USA,Kentucky

Postby Rob » November 15th, 2006, 4:01 am

TW wrote:OK, let's face it!!! The National Championship is supposed to pit the two best teams against each other. To determine the ranking of different teams you must use objective not subjective means. The win/loss record is the most objective means, you either won those games or you didn't. Total offense is an objective means, you either gained the yardage and scored the points or you didn't. Total defense is an objective means, you either stopped them or you didn't. SOS is a subjective measure for the most part. The reason that I say this is because there usually will not be enough common opposition to arrive at any realistic comparision between teams in different conferences, so it relies on historical data between the various conferences. Or worse yet, it makes assumptions, i.e. Team A beat Team B, Who beat Team C, who beat Team D, who beat Team E, therefor Team A must be better than Team E.


TW[/u][/b]


TW, I couldn't agree more that the NC is suppose to pit the 2 best teams together.

I also agree that the record is the most objective means to determine.

However, I disagree with Total Offense and Total Defense.

For example I heard Urban Myer the present Florida coach say when he was at Utah he left the Smith kid in games to score "style" points for the voters.

Just this past weekend I watched WVU play Cincinnati, in the middle of the 3rd quarter WVU was up 42-10 Slayton had 148 yards on 10 carries, White was just a few yards short of 100 and Rich Rod took both of them out and most of his starting defense. Hence, Cincy scored 2 late touchdowns to make the score look closer than it was. 42-24 final.

Yes you gained the yards, but WVU could have ran it up more against Cincy, and yes they gave up 24 points but 14 of them was against 2nd/3rd team. Which in your system would hurt the team overall. Wouldn't you agree? Which to me simply states, leave you first team in, beat the crap out of a team, destroy a inferior teams morale which I have a problem with.

User avatar
TW
Established Member
Posts: 8866
Joined: November 4th, 2004, 3:38 pm
Location: USA,Georgia
Contact:

Postby TW » November 18th, 2006, 7:10 am

TC wrote:
"I am not sure where it is at but I made a long bracket that allowed for a champ game and and a true champ. 16 teams, 6bcs conferences... ACC, Big 10, Big 12 Big East, SEC, Pac 10...+4 at Large... to cover ND, Boise State and all the non BCS conferences.. All other teams would be allowed bowl games that would be staggered up until the NC "


TC the problems that I have with your “bracket” are first it is too long ( to many teams ), if you are higher than # 8 you shouldn’t be in consideration for the National Championship. The second problem is that of the distribution of the berths in the play-off. Under you system the six conferences get automatic berths, and those conferences represent 64 teams. At worst a team would have a one in six chance at one of the berths. The rest of the conferences and the independents would be competing for four berths ( at large ). This group consist of 55 teams, giving them a one in thirteen point five chance. Not exactly a level playing field! In my not so humble opinion the only teams with an automatic berth would be those teams that were undefeated. I would also reduce the number of teams in the play-offs to eight.

Pastor Rob wrote:
"TW, I couldn't agree more that the NC is suppose to pit the 2 best teams together.

I also agree that the record is the most objective means to determine.

However, I disagree with Total Offense and Total Defense."

Careful Rob, your beginning to sound like me. LOL! My system could be adjusted so that the win/loss record would become the dominate factor, with TO,TD, and SOS playing much less of a role in ranking the teams.
i.e. Win/Loss comprises 70% of the ranking score, with TO,TD, and SOS comprise 10% each. By modifying the system this way win/loss becomes the foremost factor and it reduces the temptation for coaches to run up the score. This results in a system that is based on win/loss while recognizing the other factors that effect the national rankings of teams. No matter what system you use someone will try to skew it in their favor. Fortunately these situations are usually short lived as other coaches catch on to what they are doing and they lose any advantage they might have gained. What I am trying to accomplish is to devise a system that is manageable, and will work in the real world.



TW
Anglo-Saxon Proto-English Manuscripts (995 AD): “God lufode middan-eard swa, dat he seade his an-cennedan sunu, dat nan ne forweorde de on hine gely ac habbe dat ece lif."



My blog - http://theoldman.wordpress.com/

User avatar
KBevangelist
Hey, hey, hey
Posts: 1998
Joined: August 21st, 2006, 12:00 pm
Location: USA,NorthCarolina
Contact:

Dear Lord

Postby KBevangelist » November 18th, 2006, 7:44 am

ImaPK wrote:Ok, let's eliminate "March Madness"...


Dear Lord, yall will have to bury me if they eliminate March Madness

About had a heart attack when I read this, LOL

:shock:

TC
Hey, hey, hey
Posts: 1922
Joined: February 20th, 2003, 5:00 pm
Location: "the Ville" ky

Postby TC » November 19th, 2006, 9:42 am

TC the problems that I have with your “bracket” are first it is too long ( to many teams ), if you are higher than # 8 you shouldn’t be in consideration for the National Championship.

The problem is that still would put the it in the hands of someone who is ranking the teams... As well is there are some times that there is more than one good team in the same conference (Osu/Mich) if you went with 8 that would be fine to me but it would get rid of all of the teams that had one bad game, OR it would get rid of a good team because another conference or two had two good teams and took those spots.


The second problem is that of the distribution of the berths in the play-off. Under you system the six conferences get automatic berths, and those conferences represent 64 teams. At worst a team would have a one in six chance at one of the berths. The rest of the conferences and the independents would be competing for four berths ( at large ). This group consist of 55 teams, giving them a one in thirteen point five chance.

And that is fine with me, there are some teams that are not on the same level as others in college football. most of your directional schools (central michigan, western ky, northern ill) they are just not on the same level as many in the bcs conferences... (yes there are expetions like south Fla, and duke) but if they should at least have a SHOT. NOW ON THe INDY's...get in a conference, or take your chances. There is really one ONE Indy, ND. And they are doing that for ONE reason MONEY... so it that is what they want let the pay the price for that. TO ME... ND gets too many breaks as it is.




Not exactly a level playing field! In my not so humble opinion the only teams with an automatic berth would be those teams that were undefeated. I would also reduce the number of teams in the play-offs to eight.

that would give more teams to schedule duke to get wins. It would make the power conferences to get a ton of teams so that the big dogs could get a ton of wins over the lesser teams, go undefeated and take a spot. You could actually have 2 or 3 from one conference go undefated just to them them in the 8

User avatar
TW
Established Member
Posts: 8866
Joined: November 4th, 2004, 3:38 pm
Location: USA,Georgia
Contact:

Postby TW » November 19th, 2006, 1:58 pm

Without modifying my system to the 70/10/10/10 format, in other words it's just like it was last week.

1.Ohio St. (t)
2. Boise St. (t)
3. Wisconson (t)
4. Florida (t)
5. West Virginia
6. Rutgers
7. Louisville (t)
8. Michigan (t)

9. So. Cal.
10. Notre Dame
11. Arkansas


9, 10, & 11 are still possible play-off teams, Wake Forest dropped out with their second loss.


TW
Anglo-Saxon Proto-English Manuscripts (995 AD): “God lufode middan-eard swa, dat he seade his an-cennedan sunu, dat nan ne forweorde de on hine gely ac habbe dat ece lif."



My blog - http://theoldman.wordpress.com/


Return to “Entertainment”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 2 guests

Login  •  Register