TW wrote:Pastor Rob wrote:TW, thank you for your work. I appreciate all the time energy and effort it took to comply that list.
I only have a few questions for you. First, remember now in college football there are no ties. You play overtime till someone wins. So it would simply be won/lost record.
My first question is on the Total Offense/Total Defense where did that information come from? I know that WVU in rushing offense is one of the top 2 or 3 teams in America. Passing is a different subject. You state that all D-1 teams have to meet minimum standards. My question is what are those standards?
I still think you have to figure in somewhere in the mix, the Strength of Schedule. While I have noticed you include Boise St. on your list, in all fairness, there is not a team you have listed that if they played Boise's schedule they would also be undefeated.
I noticed on your formula that Florida, Arkansas, where out of the playoffs, with all due respect, those have to be 2 of the top 8 teams.
While again I commend you on your work, those are some things that I believe in your system would not work.
My $.02
Rob I shall address your questions in the order in which you asked them.
"My first question is on the Total Offense/Total Defense where did that information come from?"
http://www.ncaa.org/stats/football/footballMenu.html
"You state that all D-1 teams have to meet minimum standards. My question is what are those standards?"
This is off the official NCAA website:Division I
Division I member institutions have to sponsor at least seven sports for men and seven for women (or six for men and eight for women) with two team sports for each gender. Each playing season has to be represented by each gender as well. There are contest and participant minimums for each sport, as well as scheduling criteria. For sports other than football and basketball, Division I schools must play 100 percent of the minimum number of contests against Division I opponents -- anything over the minimum number of games has to be 50 percent Division I. Men's and women's basketball teams have to play all but two games against Division I teams; for men, they must play one-third of all their contests in the home arena. Schools that have football are classified as Division I-A or I-AA. I-A football schools are usually fairly elaborate programs. Division I-A teams have to meet minimum attendance requirements (average 15,000 people in actual or paid attendance per home game), which must be met once in a rolling two-year period. Division I-AA teams do not need to meet minimum attendance requirements. Division I schools must meet minimum financial aid awards for their athletics program, and there are maximum financial aid awards for each sport that a Division I school cannot exceed.
All D I programs are limited to the same minimum/maximum financial aid awards. They have a mimimum number of sports that must sponsor. In theory they all start out equal.
"While I have noticed you include Boise St. on your list, in all fairness, there is not a team you have listed that if they played Boise's schedule they would also be undefeated."
This system is based soley on statistical data, and the data supports Boise St. being in the mix.
"I noticed on your formula that Florida, Arkansas, where out of the playoffs, with all due respect, those have to be 2 of the top 8 teams."
At the present time the stats do not support Florida and Arkansas being in the top eight. I do think that by the end of the season much will have changed in the ststa and the top eight will be somewhat different than it is presently shown.
TW
TW, thanks for your facts and figures. I understand better your formula, but not sure I like it.
![Remember our veterans and troops currently serving today. [amer-ribbon90.gif]](/images/amer-ribbon90.gif)