Is it just sour grapes or were the refs really that bad?

A forum for the discussion of TV, movies, music and pop-culture influences from a Christian perspective. A free-wheeling forum for discussion of Christian issues.

Moderators: Pastor Gary, The J2 Mod Squad

User avatar
justsam
Woohoo!
Posts: 1439
Joined: July 18th, 2003, 5:05 pm
Location: USA,Indiana
Contact:

Is it just sour grapes or were the refs really that bad?

Postby justsam » February 6th, 2006, 5:49 am

From and article by Sportswriter Kevin Hench. You can read the whole article here: http://msn.foxsports.com/nfl/story/5310192

This is the space where I get to crow about the frightening precision of my Super Bowl prediction.

Where I get to remind everyone that I guaranteed the Steelers would win the title after they beat the Colts. That they were the only championship-caliber team among the final four. That they would dismantle the Broncos in Denver and waylay whomever the NFC sent at them.
This is the space where I get to wag a finger at my colleague Ian O'Connor, with whom I'd waged a dueling columns battle of opposing prognostication. He picked the Seahawks and made a very strong case for them.

This is the space where I get to say, I told ya so. But I won't. I can't.

I've never felt so empty being right. I feel dirty. I wish I'd been wrong. The Steelers did not deserve to win this game. They were not the better team. O'Connor was right. Seattle was the better team.

So, Paul Tagliabue, how does a team lose when it outgains an opponent by 57 yards, controls time of possession and wins the turnover battle?

Like a crazed CIA analyst running through the halls of Langley screaming into open offices about some impending calamity, I've been shrieking hysterically about the terrible officiating in the NFL and warning that some day the brutal calls were going to affect the outcome of the Super Bowl.

That some day was Sunday.

Every single questionable, marginal or outright bad call went against the Seahawks.

[/b]
Do ye not therefore err, because ye know not the scriptures, neither the power of God? (Jesus)

User avatar
dolfan
Established Member
Posts: 8016
Joined: March 17th, 2004, 1:25 pm
Location: USA,Alabama
Contact:

Postby dolfan » February 6th, 2006, 6:24 am

I gotta tell you that I thought this was the worst officiated SB I've ever seen. It is no fault of the Steelers, and they may have won in any event (you never know how different calls would've turned out plays later). Pittsburgh executed their game plan to the best of their ability and did what they had to do.


But, the interference call against Jackson was ridiculous (the ball was uncatchable as to the defender and the leverage from Jackson's contact was minimal as his feet clearly did the most work in getting him turned around for the reception; plus, the defender had his arms on Jackson, too), and the holding call against Seattle when they scored again later was so questionable that in the context of it it shouldn't have been made. As to the Roethlisberger TD run, I can't say certainly that the ball did not break the plane. The nose of the ball was inside #7's arm, and his elbow, in part, crossed the edge of the white line on the replay. It is a metaphysical mystery whether the ball actually did, but the standard of review on replays gives the live official the benefit of any doubt, and the replay didn't definitively show whether the ball broke the plane or not.

Little calls on penalties just broke in favor of the Steelers on too many important points of the game. I can't say that the Steelers would not have won but for the calls, but the score would've been different, and it might've been enough that the Seahawks would've won. It was a much more defensive game than I thought it would be, and I enjoyed watching it.

The commercials were no good this year, though. The fly zapping with the electric shock panel in the hospital was the funniest one, IMHO, along with the stripper-sheep.
Human government bears the same relation to hell as the church bears to heaven. (David Lipscomb, On Civil Government, 72).

User avatar
Paully_44
Established Member
Posts: 7480
Joined: January 30th, 2003, 4:20 am
Location: USA,Washington

Postby Paully_44 » February 6th, 2006, 6:25 am

Check out the fan poll on ESPN about the officiating. 61,000 responded to the poll & 61% say the officiating affected the outcome.
Let the wild rumpus start!

User avatar
RamboPreacher
RamboPreacher
Posts: 12355
Joined: July 17th, 2004, 5:41 pm
Location: USA, Texas

Postby RamboPreacher » February 6th, 2006, 6:49 am

as a non-fan of either (or any), can't a public statement be made by communicating the disatisfaction to the reffing organization? it probably won't change the outcome, but wouldn't changes possibly be made to help future outcomes? (that's what we do in paintball - don't whine about the ref to the refs or the staff, take it to the management/organization that provided them).
Thanks, Brent "RamboPreacher" Hoefling

User avatar
Paully_44
Established Member
Posts: 7480
Joined: January 30th, 2003, 4:20 am
Location: USA,Washington

Postby Paully_44 » February 6th, 2006, 10:22 am

I have found it interesting to hear the national attention (from fans & media) that the SuperBowl has received today. Of course, I would blast the men in stripes.. my team lost. But when you see others around the country saying similar things....

This from an ESPN 'guru' who has blasted the Seahawks all year
ESPN Steeling one

Your Seahawks lost this game a little more than Pittsburgh won it.

Your defense battled its guts out and mostly stuffed Pittsburgh's run. But one breakdown allowed Willie Parker to escape untouched for a 75-yard TD. You can't overcome mistakes like that in a game like this.

But, no, you can't overcome 11 lost points worth of penalties, either. On this night, you belonged in the Super Bowl as much as Pittsburgh did, for what that's worth.

On this night, the only frauds wore stripes.
Let the wild rumpus start!

User avatar
Paully_44
Established Member
Posts: 7480
Joined: January 30th, 2003, 4:20 am
Location: USA,Washington

Postby Paully_44 » February 7th, 2006, 5:50 am

I do want to add that the apparent "blown calls" during the SuperBowl were not an isolated incident. This was going on all season, and during the entire playoffs. When you have 90+ million people watching one game, of course it gets more coverage.

Do I think the refs were out to get the Seahawks? Heck no.
Do I think the NFL wanted The Bus to get this ring before he retires? Nope

I do think,though, it is about time the NFL seriously considers going to a full time officiating crew. Train em, teach em, make them the pinnacle of Professional Refs. Will that stop the bad calls? nadda. they are human, prone to mistakes.
Let the wild rumpus start!

User avatar
dolfan
Established Member
Posts: 8016
Joined: March 17th, 2004, 1:25 pm
Location: USA,Alabama
Contact:

Postby dolfan » February 7th, 2006, 6:19 am

What would these guys do in the off season, though, to earn a check? The league's whole complement of officials works from August to December. Playoff crews constitute less than 1/3 of all officials. It isn't like baseball (Late Feb./ March through September, early Oct.) and basketball (October - April, then 2 1/2 months of playoffs), or even hockey (October - May and Stanley Cup in June now). I just don't see where putting these guys on full-time works. I can see requiring their full time during the season, to some extent. But, even with reviews, preparation and travel, they only work one game per week unlike the officials in the other major sports.

What I'd like to see is some common sense. Lack of opportunity to call a game didn't cause the blown call on the interference, the tackle that was called a block in the back, nor the, ahem, holding call. That was something else. But, even adding yet another level of accountability by giving a replay official some authority to just reverse a blown call won't work either because it stretches the games too long, and they're already too long.
Human government bears the same relation to hell as the church bears to heaven. (David Lipscomb, On Civil Government, 72).

User avatar
Paully_44
Established Member
Posts: 7480
Joined: January 30th, 2003, 4:20 am
Location: USA,Washington

Postby Paully_44 » February 7th, 2006, 8:24 am

dolfan wrote:What would these guys do in the off season, though, to earn a check? The league's whole complement of officials works from August to December. Playoff crews constitute less than 1/3 of all officials. It isn't like baseball (Late Feb./ March through September, early Oct.) and basketball (October - April, then 2 1/2 months of playoffs), or even hockey (October - May and Stanley Cup in June now). I just don't see where putting these guys on full-time works. I can see requiring their full time during the season, to some extent. But, even with reviews, preparation and travel, they only work one game per week unlike the officials in the other major sports.

What I'd like to see is some common sense. Lack of opportunity to call a game didn't cause the blown call on the interference, the tackle that was called a block in the back, nor the, ahem, holding call. That was something else. But, even adding yet another level of accountability by giving a replay official some authority to just reverse a blown call won't work either because it stretches the games too long, and they're already too long.


Maybe giving them the opportunity to say, "I may have been wrong" and give them a predefined amount of time to talk among themselvs.
In baseball, more and more you will see the umps all gather together if the one who made the call on a certain play has second thoughts. Does it mean they are 100% right? Nope, but it gives them the leeway to talkabout a questionable call.

For the NFL, I do think if you pay them well enough ($150-$250K)per season, they can survive the year. That season running from the start of Fall practice/camps (July thru December). The refs themselves, having camps where they do drills, watch tape, call situational games, etc.
Maybe they are doing that now, I'm not sure.
Do I think they'll ever go to full time refs" No, simply based off the points you raised.
Let the wild rumpus start!

User avatar
Pastor Gary
Kahu Gary, Benevolent Dictator
Posts: 10475
Joined: January 28th, 2003, 9:03 pm
Location: USA,Hawaii
Contact:

Okay

Postby Pastor Gary » February 11th, 2006, 12:27 pm

I am not really a sports fan, and have no dog in this hunt. It didn't matter a lot to me which team of highly-overpaid, ego-inflated large men got the biggest paycheck.

But I watched the game on a HUGE screen (9' x 12') and the officiating stunk. The Steelers did steal a touchdown to win -- though I don't blame them.

With all the ESPN-type technology available for such a major game, couldn't those balls be sewn with thread that would enable the officials to "see" through the ball-carrier's arms and the pile of flesh to "see" if the ball hit the line??? Seems like that would be easy to me.
"God is excited to show you mercy. He rises to give you His compassion." (Isaiah 30:18)

"For surely, O LORD, you bless the righteous;
you surround them with your favor as with a shield." (Psalm 5:12)

User avatar
justsam
Woohoo!
Posts: 1439
Joined: July 18th, 2003, 5:05 pm
Location: USA,Indiana
Contact:

Postby justsam » February 11th, 2006, 2:41 pm

I am not really a sports fan, and have no dog in this hunt. It didn't matter a lot to me which team of highly-overpaid, ego-inflated large men got the biggest paycheck.

But I watched the game on a HUGE screen (9' x 12') and the officiating stunk. The Steelers did steal a touchdown to win -- though I don't blame them.

With all the ESPN-type technology available for such a major game, couldn't those balls be sewn with thread that would enable the officials to "see" through the ball-carrier's arms and the pile of flesh to "see" if the ball hit the line??? Seems like that would be easy to me.


I was actually thinking of something along the same lines- tennis uses a cyclops camera, but I was thinking of some kind of magnetic material that would trip a sensor if the ball crossed any of the goal lines. In addition to Big Ben's touchdown (which he himself thinks didn't make it in), there was what appeared to be another touchdown that Daryl Evans scored where he stepped out of bounds but first appeared to break the plane of the goal line with the ball.

Good Idea, Gary.

God Bless You- Sam Smith
Do ye not therefore err, because ye know not the scriptures, neither the power of God? (Jesus)


Return to “Entertainment”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 50 guests

Login  •  Register