A Reality Check on 300 (in 3 parts)

A forum for the discussion of TV, movies, music and pop-culture influences from a Christian perspective. A free-wheeling forum for discussion of Christian issues.

Moderators: Pastor Gary, The J2 Mod Squad

User avatar
TW
Established Member
Posts: 8866
Joined: November 4th, 2004, 3:38 pm
Location: USA,Georgia
Contact:

A Reality Check on 300 (in 3 parts)

Postby TW » July 13th, 2008, 7:02 am

A Reality Check On 300

Part 1
In another thread in the General Discussion Forum the movie 300, it’s merits as entertainment and /or it’s historical accuracy, has been the topic of discussion. Granted that the bulk of the discussion was a hijack that resulted from a simple question. For that I apologize. I have chosen not to continue the hijack of that thread any further, but rather to start a new thread.

In preface, my remarks about this movie are based solely upon my understanding of the historical events, characters, costumes, armies, tactics, and equipment of the era. I also understand that in creating fictional works that are based upon such historical events and characters “artistic license” is often used to enhance elements of that creation. However, artistic license does not mean that the events and characters can be completely distorted in order to provide a platform for the “artist” to create their work. Such a work leaves the realm of historical fiction and becomes either pure fiction or fantasy. As an artist myself I understand that when I use artistic license to enhance an element in one of my paintings I must also maintain a level of fidelity with the other elements, a reasonable balance. As I have previously stated, while it is unfortunate, many people develop their views of history by what they see on TV and in the movies. This places a certain onus upon those that produce these movies and shows to provide disclaimers as to the historical veracity of their work. On the official 300 website the only disclaiimer that I could find was: “Warner Bros. Pictures acknowledges and regrets that a number of the music cues for the score of ’300’ were derived from music composed by Academy Award winning composer Elliot Goldenthal for the motion picture ’Titus.’ Warner Bros. Pictures has great respect for Elliot, our longtime collaborator, and is pleased to have amicably resolved this matter.” It seem that not only have the producer of this movie misrepresented historical events and people, they are also guilty of theft. In order to remove the argument that I shouldn’t comment on a movie that I have not seen, I watched the movie (DVD). The following are my impressions of the movie.

The movie uses the thinnest veneer of historical fact upon with to build a weak storyline that provides an excuse for prolonged carnage and scenes of gratuitus sexual innuendo. The strongest points for the movie is that the choreography of the fight scenes was very good, and the computer generated graphics provide vistas that would have been impossible on a sound stage. However this is off set by the less than stellar acting and rather forced script.
Last edited by TW on July 13th, 2008, 12:20 pm, edited 1 time in total.

User avatar
TW
Established Member
Posts: 8866
Joined: November 4th, 2004, 3:38 pm
Location: USA,Georgia
Contact:

Postby TW » July 13th, 2008, 7:05 am

Part 2

The movie uses the thinnest veneer of historical fact upon with to build a weak storyline that provides an excuse for prolonged carnage and scenes of gratuitus sexual innuendo. The strongest points for the movie is that the choreography of the fight scenes was very good, and the computer generated graphics provide vistas that would have been impossible on a sound stage. However this is off set by the less than stellar acting and rather forced script.

Since the movie is set against a historical backdrop an examination of it’s historical accuracy is in order.

According to the movie Xerxes sent envoys to Athens and Sparta requesting an offering of “earth and water,” the customary symbols of submission. The true historical facts are that the responses depicted in the movie had actually occurred ten years before, prior to the invasion of Darius and the subsequent Battle of Marathon. When Xerxes sent his envoys around to the Greek city-states Athens and Sparta were omitted because of their response to Darius.

According to the movie Leonidas led his 300 Spartans into battle with Xerxes against the wishes of the Spartan Council and laws of Sparta. This is a total distortion of history. In the year 481 B.C. Xerxes had sent envoys around to the Greek city-states demanding submission, in late autumn a Council was called at Corinth, and a confederate alliance of 70 City-states was formed. They first dispatched 10,000 Greeks, including hoplites and cavalry to the Vale of Tempe. When warned that the Vale could be by-passed by the Sarantoporo Pass the Vale was abandoned. Then Leonidas with 5,200 Greeks was sent to Thermopylae to slow the advance of Xerxes. Herodotus wrote:
The force with Leonidas was sent forward by the Spartans in advance of their main body, that the sight of them might encourage the allies to fight, and hinder them from going over to the Medes, as was likely they might have done had they seen that Sparta was backward. They intended presently, when they had celebrated the Carneian Festival, which was what now kept them at home, to leave a garrison in Sparta, and hasten in full force to join the army. The rest of the allies intended to act similarly; for it happened that the Olympic Festival fell exactly at this same period. None of them looked to see the contest at Thermopylae decided so speedily; wherefore they were content to send forward a mere advance guard. Such accordingly were the intentions of the allies.


It was against Spartan Law to wage warfare during the Carneian Festival, however, on this occasion, the ephors decided the urgency was sufficiently great to justify an advance expedition. The ephors (overseers) were the five elected officials that swore each month to uphold the rule of the kings, and the kings swore to uphold the law. Leonidas was not acting against the wishes of his government, but rather at it’s direction.

While the movie does acknowledge the presence of other Greeks at Thermopylae, it does so with great reluctance and much misrepresentation. The first scene with the other Greeks has them joining Leonidas on his march to Thermopylae, the truth is that they were dispatched with the Spartans as part of Leonidas’s army. The second scene has them charging from concealment into the Persian flank, a physical impossibility given the topography of the battle field. The third scene is them abandoning the Spartans. Again a misrepresentation of what happened, Leonidas released them to return to the main army yet 1200 chose to stay and fight beside the Spartans.

Sparta had consulted the Oracle at Delphi, who according to legend issued the following prophecy in hexameter verse:
O ye men who dwell in the streets of broad Lacedaemon!
Either your glorious town shall be sacked by the children of Perseus,
Or, in exchange, must all through the whole Laconian country.
Mourn for the loss of a king, descendant of great Heracles.
Last edited by TW on July 14th, 2008, 4:46 pm, edited 1 time in total.

User avatar
TW
Established Member
Posts: 8866
Joined: November 4th, 2004, 3:38 pm
Location: USA,Georgia
Contact:

Postby TW » July 13th, 2008, 7:07 am

Part 3

The movie’s historical backdrop is indeed a thin veneer, a shadow of reality. This theme of deception and misrepresentation continues in the costumes and equipment of the Spartans and Persians. The Spartan army, as all of the Greek city -state’s armies, was comprised of heavy infantry, the Hoplites.
Image

They did not run around bare chested in leather briefs and red capes! They wore a bronze cuirass (breastplate and backplate) or a leather cuirass that had bronze plates riveted to it with a girdle of scale armor over their tunics. Bronze helmets with nasal and cheek pieces, often with decorative crest, protected their heads. Bronze greaves protect their lower legs. They were equipped with a large round bronze clad shield, a short (around 22 inch blade length) double edged leaf bladed sword. Their primary weapon however was a 13 foot, spear (sarissa). These spears weighed around 18 pounds and were counter balanced so that the point of balance was about 3/4ths of the way back from the spear tip on the shaft, giving the Hoplite a reach of almost 10 feet in front of the shield wall when set against a charge or during advancement.

In contrast the Persian army lacked heavy infantry. Their infantry had no armor or was lightly armored with a leather cuirass, possibly studded, a conical helmet, a small round shield, a short (20 inch) curved single edged sword, and a shorter (8 foot) spear or javelin. About 20% of the Persian army was cavalry, however, that cavalry did not have saddles with stirrups (which are clearly used in the movie), this type of saddle did not exist until the era of the Mongols.

In the movie elephants and a rhino are used against the Spartans. Allow me to point out that the first recorded use of war elephants against Europeans was by the Persians at the Battle of Gaugamela one hundred thirty nine years after Thermopylae. Rhinos have never been used in combat!

Now for a view of the tactics used on the battle field. The Greeks armies of heavy infantry used a formation known as a phalanx, a densely packed heavy infantry formation that was almost impervious to cavalry attack.
Image

Owing to their long thrusting spears Hoplites from the fifth rank forward could attack a foe. Anyone attempting to attack this formation from the front would have to content with multiple layers of spear tips prior to ever getting close enough to the front rank to engage in hand to hand combat. The main disadvantage of the phalanx was that its inability to maneuver. In the narrow confines of the pass at Thermopylae, about 100 meters wide, the phalanx did not need to maneuver but rather to simply hold its ground. With cliffs on both sides they could not be out flanked, so all assaults must be frontal, directly into the strength of the Hoplite Phalanx. When a phalanx advanced, it did so slowly, a charge by a phalanx would result in a loss of the cohesion that was the real strength of the formation. There were no heroic charges from the Spartans, nor charges by the other Greeks from concealed positions.

In summation, while this movie might provide some level of entertainment, particularly for pubescent males, it is bad history. The total lack of any disclaimer to the effect that this is a work of fiction based loosely on a historical event and not representative of true or accurate facts is in my opinion deceptive. When an artist set his work against a historical backdrop, even with the use of artistic license, he must retain the true essence of that event.


TW



Sources:
Battle of Thermopylae - Wikipedia

A Short History of War - The Evolution of Warfare and Weapons by Richard A. Gabriel and Karen S. Metz, - Strategic Studies Institute, U. S. Army War College

War Elephants - www.mlahanas.de/Greeks/LX/WarElephant.html
Anglo-Saxon Proto-English Manuscripts (995 AD): “God lufode middan-eard swa, dat he seade his an-cennedan sunu, dat nan ne forweorde de on hine gely ac habbe dat ece lif."

My blog - http://theoldman.wordpress.com/

User avatar
forestwalker
The 1,000 Club
Posts: 1078
Joined: July 9th, 2004, 8:04 pm
Location: USA,California

Postby forestwalker » July 14th, 2008, 9:17 am

I'd add the film's depiction of the Athenians as queer. It was Sparta, in fact, that was the "West Hollywood" of that period. "Sparta" was made into the same verb in the Greek language that "Sodom" was in English. The training of boys as warriors that the film spends so much time depicting was actually carried out by an older man who took the boy as lover.
For the truth that lies at the heart of theology is not something there to be discovered, but something, or rather someone, to whom we must surrender. The mystery of faith is not ultimately something that invites our questioning, but something that questions us.
Andrew Louth, Discerning the Mystery

User avatar
TW
Established Member
Posts: 8866
Joined: November 4th, 2004, 3:38 pm
Location: USA,Georgia
Contact:

Postby TW » July 14th, 2008, 4:39 pm

forestwalker,
You may want to reconsider those comments. This may have been one of the few things that the movie got right. Check out this website:

http://elysiumgates.com/~helena/

particularly the sections on marriage and sexuality.

http://elysiumgates.com/~helena/marriage.html

and

http://elysiumgates.com/~helena/sexuality.html


Xenophon, an Athenian who served with the Spartan army and sent his sons to the Spartan agoge, describes at length three aspects of Spartan sexuality in the Classical period. First, he explains that Spartan laws required men and women to marry in their physical prime and not when too young (for girls) or too old (for men) and that they should be initially restricted in their sexual contact so as to not to become “satiated” but rather to enjoy sex together. Note that there is explicit emphasis on the desirability of the female partner enjoying sex as much as the male. Second, Xenophon explains that Sparta’s laws allowed a wife of good repute to have a sexual relationship with another Spartiate of good character. Although Xenophon stresses that this is to take place with the husband’s consent, it is obvious that this was not always the case. And third, he describes at great length the practice of youths still in school having an elder mentor to guide and advise them, but he stresses emphatically that this relationship was not as “elsewhere in Greece.” On the contrary, according to Xenophon, Sparta’s laws made it just as disgraceful for an older man to molest a boy as for parents to have sexual intercourse with their children or brothers with their sisters. Aristotle, writing later still, has even more to say about the greed and avarice of Spartan women. Indeed he goes so far as to attribute Sparta’s decline to the power and wealth of her women – stating that undisciplined females are always the result in warlike societies, which do not esteem homosexuality.


Sparta may actually have been on the moral "high ground" as far as Greek culture was concerned.


TW
Anglo-Saxon Proto-English Manuscripts (995 AD): “God lufode middan-eard swa, dat he seade his an-cennedan sunu, dat nan ne forweorde de on hine gely ac habbe dat ece lif."



My blog - http://theoldman.wordpress.com/

User avatar
forestwalker
The 1,000 Club
Posts: 1078
Joined: July 9th, 2004, 8:04 pm
Location: USA,California

Postby forestwalker » July 16th, 2008, 1:14 pm

Meh. It's a game of "pick your scholar". :)
For the truth that lies at the heart of theology is not something there to be discovered, but something, or rather someone, to whom we must surrender. The mystery of faith is not ultimately something that invites our questioning, but something that questions us.

Andrew Louth, Discerning the Mystery

Full Quiver
--== J2 ==--
Posts: 4632
Joined: June 25th, 2004, 4:34 pm
Location: USA,Tennessee
Contact:

Postby Full Quiver » July 16th, 2008, 3:27 pm

pick your scholar indeed as it is with so much of history. Jus pick up the newspaper omorrow and read about todays, yesterdays, events. Depending on what paper, news report, book, etc. that you read depends on what is "truth" sometimes.

TW, did you watch the movie since the original discussion?

I just wander if the entire event or story is not a fabrication based on Gideon's 300 in the Old Testament. You know if the Israelites had a 300 man army that won a great victory then the world also had to have such a story. Kinda like all societies have their own version of the Great flood.
I have piped unto you, and ye have not danced!

User avatar
TW
Established Member
Posts: 8866
Joined: November 4th, 2004, 3:38 pm
Location: USA,Georgia
Contact:

Postby TW » July 16th, 2008, 4:34 pm

This is why when studying history it is important to study accounts from both sides. Yes, there will be differences, but there will be similarities. It is these similarities that render the best picture of that particular event. In the case of the Battle of Thermopylae there are the histories recorded by the Greeks, and there are the records from the Persian Court numerating the size and composition of the Persian army. The two reflect the same facts, with only minor differences. A Greek army of 1800 withstood a Persian army that numbered between 120,000 and 142,000. The variance in the number of Persians is because it is unknown exactly how many were involved in support roles.

Yes Danny, I did finally watch the movie. That should remove any argument that I have no right to pan the movie.


TW
Anglo-Saxon Proto-English Manuscripts (995 AD): “God lufode middan-eard swa, dat he seade his an-cennedan sunu, dat nan ne forweorde de on hine gely ac habbe dat ece lif."



My blog - http://theoldman.wordpress.com/


Return to “Entertainment”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 57 guests

Login  •  Register