A Reality Check On 300
Part 1
In another thread in the General Discussion Forum the movie 300, it’s merits as entertainment and /or it’s historical accuracy, has been the topic of discussion. Granted that the bulk of the discussion was a hijack that resulted from a simple question. For that I apologize. I have chosen not to continue the hijack of that thread any further, but rather to start a new thread.
In preface, my remarks about this movie are based solely upon my understanding of the historical events, characters, costumes, armies, tactics, and equipment of the era. I also understand that in creating fictional works that are based upon such historical events and characters “artistic license” is often used to enhance elements of that creation. However, artistic license does not mean that the events and characters can be completely distorted in order to provide a platform for the “artist” to create their work. Such a work leaves the realm of historical fiction and becomes either pure fiction or fantasy. As an artist myself I understand that when I use artistic license to enhance an element in one of my paintings I must also maintain a level of fidelity with the other elements, a reasonable balance. As I have previously stated, while it is unfortunate, many people develop their views of history by what they see on TV and in the movies. This places a certain onus upon those that produce these movies and shows to provide disclaimers as to the historical veracity of their work. On the official 300 website the only disclaiimer that I could find was: “Warner Bros. Pictures acknowledges and regrets that a number of the music cues for the score of ’300’ were derived from music composed by Academy Award winning composer Elliot Goldenthal for the motion picture ’Titus.’ Warner Bros. Pictures has great respect for Elliot, our longtime collaborator, and is pleased to have amicably resolved this matter.” It seem that not only have the producer of this movie misrepresented historical events and people, they are also guilty of theft. In order to remove the argument that I shouldn’t comment on a movie that I have not seen, I watched the movie (DVD). The following are my impressions of the movie.
The movie uses the thinnest veneer of historical fact upon with to build a weak storyline that provides an excuse for prolonged carnage and scenes of gratuitus sexual innuendo. The strongest points for the movie is that the choreography of the fight scenes was very good, and the computer generated graphics provide vistas that would have been impossible on a sound stage. However this is off set by the less than stellar acting and rather forced script.
![Remember our veterans and troops currently serving today. [amer-ribbon90.gif]](/images/amer-ribbon90.gif)