My review of"Enchanted" Rough Draft (warning lengt

A forum for the discussion of TV, movies, music and pop-culture influences from a Christian perspective. A free-wheeling forum for discussion of Christian issues.

Moderators: Pastor Gary, The J2 Mod Squad

User avatar
Jennifer Smith
Moderator
Posts: 3745
Joined: June 23rd, 2003, 11:40 am
Location: USA,Indiana

My review of"Enchanted" Rough Draft (warning lengt

Postby Jennifer Smith » February 29th, 2008, 10:13 am

Sorry this is so long, but I would love any feedback. It had to be 1400 words or more. Let me know what you think!

“Enchanted” is a film you will love, or at the very least mildly enjoy, no matter your age. This film has both an innocent charm as well as a wry sense of humor, and appeals to both young and old, with an engaging romantic story line and believable acting. Production values and family values have been taken seriously, and the plot-line elements do not insult the intelligence of the viewer. I would like to evaluate “Enchanted” based on several criteria: first of all , the range of ages this film appeals to, since it is a family film. How well does it appeal to adults and to children? Also, I will evaluate “Enchanted” based on the quality of acting, since a believable performance in a fantasy film can make the difference on whether the viewer can easily suspend their disbelief long enough to enjoy it. Another criteria I will use for this evaluation is the quality of production values. Production values include everything from editing to quality of animation, editing, music, costumes, set design and cinematography. If the right attention is given to these details, a film looks and sounds beautiful and pertinent parts of the story are not left on the cutting room floor. Finally, I will gauge the criteria of family values, because this is a film marketed and aimed at families, and also because I am a mother myself who is careful about choosing the right films for my family.

I chose to evaluate “Enchanted” because I have always loved a princess story and Disney has had some wonderful stories. This film does not take itself too seriously to poke fun at itself. As Bob Hoose of “Plugged In Online” commented: Enchanted emerges an endearingly gentle riff on past princess tales that is equal parts parody of and homage to Disney's classics.” Like “Lion King” it “offers a series of knowing moments to the audience.”(Martin Barker) Even if fairy tales are not your favorite genre, I believe you will enjoy “Enchanted.”

The film begins in animated form and with rosy hues as the heroine, Giselle, sings and dreams about the prince she knows she will someday meet. At home in her idealistic, fairy-tale land of Andalasia, forest animal friends help Giselle decorate a makeshift mannequin to resemble her dreamed-of prince (shades of “Sleeping Beauty” and “Snow White”). At the same time, a prince is passing through the forest nearby. It is Prince Edward, the heir to the throne of Andalasia, who has just conquered an enormous troll, when he hears a beautiful voice lilting through the trees. Prince Edward is instantly enamored. He drops everything, including the captured troll, to look for his would-be bride. Soon, Edward finds and rescues Giselle from the escaped troll, the two fall in “love”, and they vow to be married the very next morning.

Unfortunately, Edward also has an evil step-mother who does not wish Edward to be married and to take her throne. So, dressed as an old woman, the evil Queen sidesteps Giselle on the way to her wedding, and tricks her into gazing into a wishing well. The queen pushes Giselle into the well, which is actually a portal to the “real” world- New York City. So, the lovely Giselle lifts a manhole cover smack dab in the middle of a busy city street, and comes face-to-face with true harsh reality. Giselle’s experiences in this reality lead her to a true knight, a gracious single father who is also a divorce lawyer about to be engaged to a woman he does not love.

Without describing all the details of what follows, I found an engaging story here which often left me laughing. Giselle is a pure heart who maintains the hope of true love prevailing over all. I found her character to be refreshingly different from most modern love stories.

Besides Giselle’s infectious charm, other endearing elements make this story appropriate and enjoyable for all ages. This is the difficult balance a “family” film tries to achieve: a subject and story that are fun and interesting for both younger and older viewers. I believe this film has achieved that balance very well. It does not offend the sensibilities of its adult viewers or put them to sleep. Despite one scene that could be frightening for small children, I believe that this film would be enjoyable for children as well. I hoped this film would appeal to a family with both older and younger children like my own, so I brought my family, and I found that even my husband, who enjoys a vastly different genre, liked “Enchanted.” It held the attention of both my two-year old and ten-year old for its entirety. This film was a refreshing change-of-pace for all of us.

Next, I based the next part of my evaluation on acting quality. Were the actor’s performances believable and entertaining, did they convey the emotions and mannerisms of the characters they were attempting to portray? I believe that the cast did an excellent job of playing out the story. Also, the characters were developed enough to have a dimensional personality. As Bob Hoose put it:“The cast is terrific—particularly Amy Adams with her spot-on depiction of an animated Giselle brought to live-action life.” This role moves from an animated character to a live-action version of the same character, which required Ms. Adams to adopt the mannerisms and expressions of a typical animated princess. Ms. Adams gave a beautiful performance in this role. The character of Prince Edward, played by Thomas Marsden, is also somewhat a caricature. He is a two-dimensional, simple-minded persona, but he demonstrates slightly more depth towards the end of the film. He was enthusiastic and also sang quite well.

The character of Robert is played by Patrick Dempsey (Grey’s Anatomy) who demonstrates depth and emotion in his role of a conflicted single father who desires to make sensible romantic choices for himself due to the hurt of his past divorce.

Susan Sarandon did a fair job of conveying the evil queen (ala Snow White). Her acting was somewhat less dazzling in comparison to the other actors, however; and somewhat lacking in heartfelt enthusiasm and charm. The rest of the supporting actors were well-cast and played-out their roles well. This comedy/fantasy contained acting good enough to inspire its viewers to become involved in the story.

Besides good acting, the production values also greatly enhanced the story in “Enchanted.” Attention was given to the little details that make a film beautiful and help the storyline stay together.

Part of production values include music quality, and the musical numbers are beautifully composed and choreographed. As Manohla Dargis, reviewer for the New York Times noted: “the director Kevin Lima keeps the tone light and playful while also scaling some charmingly dizzy heights with two musical numbers, one… a brilliantly surrealistic number with Giselle and some urban critters.”

This musical scene involving “critters” is brilliant and funny. Reminiscent of “Snow White,” Giselle summons animals to Robert’s New York apartment with a sing-song voice. Once they arrive, she is momentarily drawn back by their “urbanness”- (the creatures include huge rats, pigeons and cockroaches) but then as Giselle sings a song uncannily similar to “Whistle While You Work”, the animals get right to work. As cockroaches clean off surfaces, one gets the feeling that this humorous moment is “for our mock discomfort” –(Martin Barker)

As delightful as this is, a later musical number in Central Park is even more incredible. As Todd McCarthy of Variety put it: “Most striking… is a prolonged production number… that moves through many sections of Central Park and employs dozens or more musicians, dancers and backgrounders. It's hard to think of a traditional musical number done on such a scale since the '60s..”

Other aspects of production values include costumes, sets, animation, and editing. The costumes for this film are beautiful, and the setting utilizes many notable places in New York. As Todd McCarthy put it: “The skillfully produced and mounted picture makes massive use of Manhattan as a glorious backdrop;…The extensive scenes involving countless cars and extras must have tied up traffic for days...” No expense seems to have been spared for this film. The animation at the beginning of the film is charming and colorful, and the editing left out no important part of the story-line, so that the story makes sense, but it also moves along at a good pace. One of my particular pet-peeves of modern films is over-editing, so I was pleased to see that the story was left intact in this film.

A final criteria I looked at were the family values contained in “Enchanted.” As a mother, I constantly evaluate films for my family based on and content and appropriateness. “Enchanted” contained many noble themes. But, it did also have a moderate amount of objectionable material. Families with small children will want to be aware of a fairly intense scene involving the evil Queen who transforms into a horrific dragon. Additionally, there is quite a bit of magic, and as reviewer Bob Hoose commented: “The magic utilized here is exactly the type that you would expect to see in a Disney animated movie such as Snow White, (et al)..” This may be something for Christian parents to consider before taking their children to see this film. Also, one or two slight innuendo were present as well as some bathroom humor.

However, good values present in Enchanted include Giselle’s character, who begins to cry when she meets a couple in Robert’s office who are divorcing. After meeting Giselle, this couple later reconsiders their decision because of what Giselle said to them. The character of Robert is also very kind and caring, showing mercy towards Giselle. Another brave character is a small chipmunk who defies the hefty queen’s henchman repeatedly to try to save and protect Giselle. These demonstrations of virtue are rare in modern films, and I found them to be very disarming, sweet, and notable.

To sum, Enchanted is a wonderful film for families. Enchanted contains excellent acting, a solid story line, and good quality production values, and it held my attention for the entire length of the film. There was a sweetness in this film, and a delightful sense of humor, plus a catchy musical theme. Regardless of your age, I believe you will enjoy “Enchanted”.
Last edited by Jennifer Smith on March 2nd, 2008, 7:00 pm, edited 1 time in total.
..I press on to take hold of that
for which Christ took hold of me.
-Phil 3:12

User avatar
DeWayneTN
-= J2 =-
Posts: 4477
Joined: March 15th, 2004, 7:09 am
Location: USA,Florida
Contact:

Postby DeWayneTN » February 29th, 2008, 12:17 pm

I am going to read this when I have a chance. I enjoyed this movie.
"...The life you see me living is not 'mine,' but it is lived by faith in the Son of God, who loved me and gave himself for me. I am not going to go back on that."- Galatians 19:20 (The Message)
Visit my blog: www.dewaynehamby.com

DaJudge
-= J2 =-
Posts: 4477
Joined: June 10th, 2004, 3:33 am
Location: USA,Georgia

Postby DaJudge » February 29th, 2008, 5:49 pm

My family enjoyed Enchanted as well, Jennifer

User avatar
Jennifer Smith
Moderator
Posts: 3745
Joined: June 23rd, 2003, 11:40 am
Location: USA,Indiana

Postby Jennifer Smith » March 2nd, 2008, 7:01 pm

I put some paragraph breaks in here to make it more readable! :D :D
..I press on to take hold of that

for which Christ took hold of me.

-Phil 3:12


Return to “Entertainment”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 7 guests

Login  •  Register