College Basketball

A forum for the discussion of TV, movies, music and pop-culture influences from a Christian perspective. A free-wheeling forum for discussion of Christian issues.

Moderators: Pastor Gary, The J2 Mod Squad

TC
Hey, hey, hey
Posts: 1922
Joined: February 20th, 2003, 5:00 pm
Location: "the Ville" ky

Postby TC » February 15th, 2007, 9:44 am

Not sure where to start... OK lets start here...

I am no Rick Fan, I don't hate him but I am not like the blue koolaid drinkers were for year. Here is something for you to think of... Rick has gone to a final four at Louisville. His problems at UofL has been the pros. Rick has recruited players that had committed and went to the pros, other kids were passed on because of commited kids and when they went pro the other kids were gone. One of the best examples is Telfair, one of the biggest recruits that year, ESPN did a whole series on him, it has already came out on DVD...He was the top recruit, Lofton and Rondo were the next in line, Neither liked that but they both wanted to come to the ville. Telfair committed to the Ville and Lofton to UT and Rondo to lessington. Telfair goes pro and we didn't get any replacements. Having kids go pro has hurt the Ville over and over, Rick has got a ton of grief for going after the top kids and not getting the kids that are a little below their level.

Now with the age limit it has helped some, most kids will at least GO to college or 1 or 2 years. NOW that leads me to Pat Summit. That is the reason she will never go to the mens team, I am not sure but I heard somewhere that before Buzz, Pat was actually offered the mens team but she did not want that. One reason she has had success in the womens but would not in the mens is that IN the womens, you don't have to worry about about kids skipping school and going pro. that gives you 4 years to work with them and allows you to know who you will have every year.

I got this from one of those blue koolaid drinkers.. Tubbys team won the title INSPITE of Tubby not because of him. He said that the team didn't run Tubbys plays they ran mostly what they had learned from their former coach. I don't know I didn't watch them either year. He said that was one of the problems LAST year, Rondo didn't want to run the called plays but ran his own and tubby never yanked him for doing it,

the kittens need to stick with Demoss, she will be successful, she is younger and has a longer career ahead of her.

Billy Boy will not leave Fla for lessington. WHY? he has already won the title, he pay is among the top, He is far less pressure to win that he would in bluetown, the weather is better in Fla during the season.

I would not touch Thad with a ten foot pole. He went to OSU, which had not pulled in the kids in years.. then BAM.. he get several Burger Boys... Sound a lOT like the fab 5, If they stay and win a title... I look for a few years later for them to have to pull it like they did in michigan.

User avatar
Susie Hamilton
Established Member
Posts: 7587
Joined: May 7th, 2003, 9:14 am
Location: USA,Virginia
Contact:

Postby Susie Hamilton » February 15th, 2007, 1:34 pm

Thanks, TC, that was a very good post. Explained a lot.
To God be the Glory.

TC
Hey, hey, hey
Posts: 1922
Joined: February 20th, 2003, 5:00 pm
Location: "the Ville" ky

Postby TC » February 15th, 2007, 2:02 pm

I would bet if ROB was not watching races... He would find several things to disagree with.... BUT what else is new

User avatar
dalebert
Woohoo!
Posts: 1324
Joined: April 5th, 2004, 6:34 am
Location: USA,Ohio
Contact:

Postby dalebert » February 16th, 2007, 3:31 am

I would not touch Thad with a ten foot pole.


ok i will bite. Why?


He went to OSU, which had not pulled in the kids in years.. then BAM.. he get several Burger Boys


is why OSU wanted him as a coach...he can recruit great ball players. and IMHO he is one of the best game coaches that i have seen in a while. Plus the fans in columbus love him and so do the players.

Sound a lOT like the fab 5, If they stay and win a title... I look for a few years later for them to have to pull it like they did in michigan.


dont blame the kids for wanting to make the big bucks if they can after their sophomores years. After all the kids didnt make the rules saying they can leave college and play pro if they desire. As much as i would love to see any school keep their best for five yrs, i also say that if a kid can make it in pros after two yrs of college..go for it!!!....

just my .02 cents

User avatar
mom of two
Ranking in the posts...
Ranking in the posts...
Posts: 257
Joined: April 5th, 2004, 8:10 am
Location: Hendersonville, TN

Postby mom of two » February 16th, 2007, 5:35 am

TC is correct...Pat was offered the men's team. Rob doesn't think the men's team could be coached by a woman. I ask one question...when the cameras are rolling on the sidelines, what do all players say..."Hi, Mom!" Don't ever try to convince me guys won't listen to a mom. Just remember, Pat flew to visit a recruit WHILE IN LABOR. The story goes that after the recruit & her family agreed to go to UT, Pat said she needed to hurry back to Knoxville. When they got on the plane, her assistant asked what was wrong. Pat told her that her water had broket 3 hours earlier. That is one tough woman in my book! I don't think too many guys would mess with her! The main point is Pat doesn't WANT to leave UT's women's program. It would greatly surprise me is she doesn't retire from there.
The overall intelligence of the earth remains constant...unfortunately, the population increases daily!

User avatar
dalebert
Woohoo!
Posts: 1324
Joined: April 5th, 2004, 6:34 am
Location: USA,Ohio
Contact:

Postby dalebert » February 16th, 2007, 8:06 am

when the cameras are rolling on the sidelines, what do all players say..."Hi, Mom!"


saying hi to mom and playing for mom are two different things!

TC
Hey, hey, hey
Posts: 1922
Joined: February 20th, 2003, 5:00 pm
Location: "the Ville" ky

Postby TC » February 16th, 2007, 8:11 am

I would not touch Thad because there has been rumor in the past how he got players, but nothing was ever proven. When he went to OSU, he got players but the number of top players he got was unheard of except at Puke... (and we all know the "rules" don't apply to them). OSU is not above "bending" a rule or two and why not usually they get a small smack on the wrist. I am not against giving a kid a second chance but if the Troy Smith thing had happened to most other teams he would have sat the whole year if allowed to play ever again.

NOW the people in columbus loving him has nothing to do with it, they also loved Clarrett, so that is not an issue. They will love him as long as he is winning... IF they get caught cheating then they will dump him by the side of the road.

I think you missed my point about the fab 5, we have heard about how good they were and how Fisher was so great at getting kids to come to michigan as well as such a good coach... WELL yes they (the fab 5 did well) but the problem was they were given money to GO to Michigan, given money while at Michigan. When Michgan was forces to forfit wins, titles and banners http://espn.go.com/ncb/news/2002/1107/1457316.html

I am a mod on a sports board, (Louisville) but it is a board that has all of the college teams, being a mod we have several forums that are for mods only and it has info about recurits, current players and breaking news. I have read so meany stories from others about OSU and Thad. Thad it getting the rep like the guy that was at Texas,(forgot his name) Larry Eustacy (sp) at Iowa st and a few others as great young coaches but did not do it "with in the rules" or had personal issues and out weighed his abilities.

OSU needs to watch its "brothers" in the big 10 there are rumors that some if not ALL of the Burger boys they have now have recieved special treatment, some have recieved money and the like. Others in the Big ten are actively working to prove it to the NCAA. Even having some current recruits taping the OSU staff to see if they are making improper offers. it is a proven fact that the coaches in the Big 10 do not get along too well. IU and Ill are just a current example.

I do think thad is a good coach and has done well, Yes he is liked but so was Huggie bear at Cincy. He was loved but when there are problems with the way he was winning he was kicked to the side quickly

I think that Oden will go pro as soon as possible... He is 40 isn't he? (well he does LOOK LIKE IT :lol: ) I have no problem with kids going pro, but I would LOVE for the NBA to make the age limit 22 so most kids would stay in college, Not because I think college is the best thing for them... BUT because I LOVE College sports and the better the players the better the games. I couldn't care less about the NBA, or the kids who want to jump to the NBA... it only hurts what I like. yes it is their right but I don't like it.

TC
Hey, hey, hey
Posts: 1922
Joined: February 20th, 2003, 5:00 pm
Location: "the Ville" ky

Postby TC » February 16th, 2007, 8:17 am

not sure if I made myself clear. Pat has had success because she has had the time develop her players and fit them into the team concept. With guys and them jumping to the NBA she would have to alter her system every year for her current players. I am not sure her system could do that and be successful,

That is the problem with Rick at UofL. We have lost too many kids, kids that never made it to school and went pro or changed schools. That with injuries we are playing kids that are not D1 level stars, they are D1 players but not the powerhouse kids you need.

Pat has it made at UT. I know that when she was offered UofL several years ago, and almost triple what she was making at UT (at the time) but she knew that UT was the place for her and nothing could ever get any better.

User avatar
mom of two
Ranking in the posts...
Ranking in the posts...
Posts: 257
Joined: April 5th, 2004, 8:10 am
Location: Hendersonville, TN

Postby mom of two » February 17th, 2007, 3:54 pm

Dalebert, my point was that men can show respect for women/mothers...even in sports. There are lots of women coaching on lower levels due to absence of dads. Locally, one of our youth teams went to the playoffs with "mom" coaching.

I must admit...I threw in the comment about Summit because of the stir it would cause among the males posting. Hang in there Rahab...we know sports too!

I believe one of the reasons Pat Summit is so successful is that she guarantees her players she is committed to the game...and she demands the same of her players.
The overall intelligence of the earth remains constant...unfortunately, the population increases daily!

TC
Hey, hey, hey
Posts: 1922
Joined: February 20th, 2003, 5:00 pm
Location: "the Ville" ky

Postby TC » February 18th, 2007, 7:26 am

and she demands the same of her players.


AND there it is.. She would not get that from male players. Not because she is a woman, why for the same reason some of the best Male coaches can't. THE PRO DRAW is too strong. Guys are always looking to the next level, looking to jump instead of making that "committment" Where it is still too not a problem for women players.

User avatar
dalebert
Woohoo!
Posts: 1324
Joined: April 5th, 2004, 6:34 am
Location: USA,Ohio
Contact:

Postby dalebert » February 20th, 2007, 3:22 am

I would not touch Thad because there has been rumor in the past how he got players, but nothing was ever proven.


So why r u casting stones?

OSU is not above "bending" a rule or two and why not usually they get a small smack on the wrist.


Ummm like most other colleges?! R u saying that OSU is THE only team to do so?

I am not against giving a kid a second chance but if the Troy Smith thing had happened to most other teams he would have sat the whole year if allowed to play ever again.


And Troy paid for his mistake..missed three games which one of them (Texas game ) could have meant an NC for Ohio State!


Hello we r talking about coaches not players! Clarrett is another story in itself.

They will love him as long as he is winning... IF they get caught cheating then they will dump him by the side of the road.


If a player or coach gets "Caught" as u say they will face the punishment that is set down by the NCAA rules and the University they coach or play at....OSU is no exception!

I have read so meany stories from others about OSU and Thad. Thad it getting the rep like the guy that was at Texas,(forgot his name) Larry Eustacy (sp) at Iowa st and a few others as great young coaches but did not do it "with in the rules" or had personal issues and out weighed his abilities.


I have no clue what you r talking about. There has been no stories that i have heard of here in columbus or national about the way Thad recruits.


OSU needs to watch its "brothers" in the big 10 there are rumors that some if not ALL of the Burger boys they have now have recieved special treatment, some have recieved money and the like. Others in the Big ten are actively working to prove it to the NCAA. Even having some current recruits taping the OSU staff to see if they are making improper offers



TC you need to prove the statements you are reporting or watch what you are saying. Again i have not heard of any such things going on in the B10 or at Ohio State. Why are you casting stones here? And if u r correct i would like for you , on this board, post the information you are spreading!

t is a proven fact that the coaches in the Big 10 do not get along too well. IU and Ill are just a current example.


Again I dont know what you r talkng about.....do you think that ever conf that all the coaches get alone but only the B10? Man what world do u live in?

I think that Oden will go pro as soon as possible... He is 40 isn't he? (well he does LOOK LIKE IT Laughing )


And if he is? What does that have anything to do with who he is or how he plays?[/quote]

TC
Hey, hey, hey
Posts: 1922
Joined: February 20th, 2003, 5:00 pm
Location: "the Ville" ky

Postby TC » February 20th, 2007, 4:15 pm

I am not casting stones... I don't know about anything when he was at butler but there were rumors about a few players he got at X. Now he goes to OSU and has one of the best classes OSU has ever had as well as a few Burger Boys. The only way a team gets that many top recruits is when they win the title or If you are Duke or NC..

Ummm like most other colleges?! R u saying that OSU is THE only team to do so?


do two wrongs make a right? I never once said they were the ONLY ones and if you can bend a rule without breaking it that is fine.

And Troy paid for his mistake..missed three games which one of them (Texas game ) could have meant an NC for Ohio State! ....

Hello we r talking about coaches not players! Clarrett is another story in itself.


OK first off it should not matter what games he missed, HOPEFULY the NCAA doesn't make a kid miss a game depending on who the team was playing...AND if it cost them the NC that is just the way it is... BUT when you look at what the NCAA has done in way of taking care of some players and teams, You will have to admit if it had been someone from Baylor.. they would have got more than 3 game.

Actually we were talking about coaches teams and players... and if you think that Clarrett went down hill ONLY after leaving OSU you are dreaming. AND if he would have been allowed to play you could bet your bottom dollar that he would have been in Uniform.

If a player or coach gets "Caught" as u say they will face the punishment that is set down by the NCAA rules and the University they coach or play at....OSU is no exception!


the problem is the punishments are not fairly imposed, some schools get off alot easier than others... YOU HAVE TO ADMIT THAT...On Troy Smith 3 game was a smack on the wrist, it does not and should not matter who those games are against. Should OSU/Troy say “no we want a harsher penalty”, No they did the time that was assigned to them. I am saying that other player has done less and gotten more time, It is one of those things, OSU is a powerhouse and the NCAA did not want the bad PR they would have gotten if they had been more harsh. ANYONE who has seen anything to do with the NCAA and violations/penalties has to admit they are far from consistent. I don’t remember the actual schools but it was something like the NCAA was so mad at Kentucky they put Cleveland state on probation

Here take this quiz

School A hires a kid’s dad to become “head of basketball operations” Dad has never coached, had any job to do with basketball, and does not have any degree? This is done while they school is recruiting the kid. Kid then signs with school? Was it a violation? What should the penalty be?

School B. School signs a kid and before the kid ever gets to the school, his mother is interview for a job, for a company that is one of the schools biggest boosters, She has never worked in that field, she is hired to a position that did not exist before and is paid more than the person how hired her and is only responsible to the owner. Was it a violation? What should the penalty be?

School C A players dad is wanting to move where his son is playing ball, he calls the school and ask where he could get a room until he could find a job. The told him of a long stay hotel they normally use. He called could not get a reservation because he did not have a credit card. An assistant coach then called the hotel and reserved the room with his personal credit card under the condition that is would not be charged but just used to reserve the room. The hotel mistakenly charged the card. They admitted it was their mistake and they actually charged both for the room. Was it a violation? What should the penalty be?

School D. A local school is recruiting a kid and childhood friend gives him a sweatshirt of that university as a birthday present. Was it a violation? What should the penalty be?

School E. A kid is given the use of a very expensive SUV for his entire time in college, from a family friend that also attended that same school and was a former player? Was it a violation? What should the penalty be?

OF all of those schools two were violations (you know it will be the ones that seem the most harmless or the silliest)

Those are just a few of the inconsistencies I have seen, But there are worst, A kid takes 10K from a booster, when he has problems at that school he calls the NCAA reports he took the money, he is allowed to transfer, not have to wait the year for the transfer and KEEP THE MONEY while the school who did not give him the money, or have knowledge of the money yet they are the ones that go on probation.

BUT what I think is the absolute worst is a kid from another country who barely speaks english, gets paid 100 dollars for the summer to help pay his expenses while traveling playing for his national team, he is not allowed to play in the NCAA at ALL. Yet kids from the US get paid more money and all they have to do is sit two early season basketball games. The foreign kid is expected to be able to read English and expected to follow all of the rules but as stated before a kid get 10k and gets to keep it and really pays not penalty.

One of the most recent illustrations of how schools are treated differently, just look at USC and Bush. If that had been an SEC school it would still be front-page news. If it had been Alabama you would have seen story after story about it and there is no way it would be anything other than loss of scholarships and no TV and/or Bowl game.

I am a mod on a sports board; it is part of a larger group that has a site for every team, college, pro semi-pro. I can not tell you everything I have read and every story that is in progress. As mod I have access to forums that are not open to the public. In those forums stories are discussed and people communicate issues on their forums as well as others on the network. The sometimes us it to slow down a story until more facts are known. Or push it to make it bigger story so that when it comes out there is already a buzz about it. Along with that you get rumors that are going around. I heard about the Bush rumor almost a month before it hit the news.

I also read where there were boosters from other schools that were feeding info to the press to get them caught. From my understanding it was reported to the NCAA but nothing had been done yet so that is why it went to the press. I have read parts of stories where members of the network from other schools in the big ten were working on stories about the recruits at OSU and that some had first hand knowledge of schools reporting to the NCAA that the OSU did this or that. Some think that does not happen,(rival schools reporting each other) but just look the NCAA and Phil Fulmer or the great treatment Steve Spurrier got and we later find out he had a hotline to the infractions committee.

I know other conferences have a coach that do not get along, that is part of the game. I am just saying I have read on boards of schools that are trying to prove that SOMEONE did something wrong and that Thad is the one that will take the blame. Exact words were, “where there is smoke there is fire and there was smoke around him before, and smoke around him now.” Look at the other teams that were in on several of your recruits. The example was this “everyone asked how Michigan got the Fab 5 but is was said that Steve fisher was just such a good recruiter, years later we find out that booster gave a bunch of money and it cost them a bunch of wins and banners” Thad is just the latest, “all those good players says something is wrong, where does he think he is DUKE…the only way you get that many burger boys is win the National title or if you are Duke or NC.” Personally I think that some in the Big 10 are feeling the heat and are trying to deflect it. I would not be surprised if a booster gave a rival kid something to get that school in trouble…


Look at it like this… Thad is a coach that has his stock rise fairly quickly. He had a total of 4 years as a head coach before getting OSU. He was an assistant under a few coaches, His most notable was one year under under Herb Sendek at Miami (Ohio) University. He has been mentioned at several OTHER schools and people like Rob are already talking about him taking one of the top ten programs in all college basketball. Do I think he is a good coach; yes… would I want him as my head coach… NOT NOW, maybe in the future. I as well as many other college basketball fans don’t want any part of any coach that there are any rumors of NCAA problems.

If you follow college ball (not just osu) you will remember the media lovefest that went on when Quinn Snyder was picked at the head coach at Missouri Tigers head coach… He was an on fire assistant under Coach K and he was supposed to be the second coming of K… well we all seen how that went. Quinn was rumored to have had some problems with the rules as an Asst at Duke, but Duke never does wrong. So he thought he could do the same with the tigers… Well again we see how that went. One problem after another and he STILL wasn’t winning. Well we know that SOME will put up with cheating as long as you win… When you cheat and still lose that is just pathetic.

Again when rumors are out there (true or not) it makes most schools and fan think twice or three times. If he can stay at OSU for 5+ years no problems pop up and he wins… well then he can write his own ticket just about anywhere.


And if he is? What does that have anything to do with who he is or how he plays?


DUDE IT IS A JOKE... Look at him he does not look like a 18-19 year old kid.

BTW I will be sending this novel to my publisher :lol: [/quote]

User avatar
Rob
Hey, hey, hey
Posts: 1605
Joined: April 14th, 2004, 4:59 am
Location: USA,Kentucky

Postby Rob » February 21st, 2007, 5:06 am

TC wrote:I would bet if ROB was not watching races... He would find several things to disagree with.... BUT what else is new


Gone to the races and what happens Tony slams me.
If I were to read, much less answer, all the attacks made on me, this shop might as well be closed for business. I do the very best I know how, the very best I can, and I mean to keep doing so until the end. If the end brings me out right, what is said against me won't amount to anything. If the end brings me out wrong, ten angels swearing I was right will make no difference." -Abraham Lincoln

User avatar
Rob
Hey, hey, hey
Posts: 1605
Joined: April 14th, 2004, 4:59 am
Location: USA,Kentucky

Postby Rob » February 21st, 2007, 5:14 am

TC wrote:Not sure where to start... OK lets start here...

I am no Rick Fan, I don't hate him but I am not like the blue koolaid drinkers were for year. Here is something for you to think of... Rick has gone to a final four at Louisville. His problems at UofL has been the pros. Rick has recruited players that had committed and went to the pros, other kids were passed on because of commited kids and when they went pro the other kids were gone. One of the best examples is Telfair, one of the biggest recruits that year, ESPN did a whole series on him, it has already came out on DVD...He was the top recruit, Lofton and Rondo were the next in line, Neither liked that but they both wanted to come to the ville. Telfair committed to the Ville and Lofton to UT and Rondo to lessington. Telfair goes pro and we didn't get any replacements. Having kids go pro has hurt the Ville over and over, Rick has got a ton of grief for going after the top kids and not getting the kids that are a little below their level.

Now with the age limit it has helped some, most kids will at least GO to college or 1 or 2 years. NOW that leads me to Pat Summit. That is the reason she will never go to the mens team, I am not sure but I heard somewhere that before Buzz, Pat was actually offered the mens team but she did not want that. One reason she has had success in the womens but would not in the mens is that IN the womens, you don't have to worry about about kids skipping school and going pro. that gives you 4 years to work with them and allows you to know who you will have every year.

I got this from one of those blue koolaid drinkers.. Tubbys team won the title INSPITE of Tubby not because of him. He said that the team didn't run Tubbys plays they ran mostly what they had learned from their former coach. I don't know I didn't watch them either year. He said that was one of the problems LAST year, Rondo didn't want to run the called plays but ran his own and tubby never yanked him for doing it,

the kittens need to stick with Demoss, she will be successful, she is younger and has a longer career ahead of her.

Billy Boy will not leave Fla for lessington. WHY? he has already won the title, he pay is among the top, He is far less pressure to win that he would in bluetown, the weather is better in Fla during the season.

I would not touch Thad with a ten foot pole. He went to OSU, which had not pulled in the kids in years.. then BAM.. he get several Burger Boys... Sound a lOT like the fab 5, If they stay and win a title... I look for a few years later for them to have to pull it like they did in michigan.


Tony, why is it that you are the only one on here that degrades other schools? Like calling UK "blue koolaid drinkers? lessington? kittens? bluetown? When OSU gets a McDonalds recruit, he's a burger boy?

Tony, you are better than that. You have good things to say, without all the despairing remarks. However, you are losing my respect for you very quickly with those remarks (as if my respect means anything).
If I were to read, much less answer, all the attacks made on me, this shop might as well be closed for business. I do the very best I know how, the very best I can, and I mean to keep doing so until the end. If the end brings me out right, what is said against me won't amount to anything. If the end brings me out wrong, ten angels swearing I was right will make no difference." -Abraham Lincoln

User avatar
Rob
Hey, hey, hey
Posts: 1605
Joined: April 14th, 2004, 4:59 am
Location: USA,Kentucky

Postby Rob » February 21st, 2007, 5:17 am

mom of two wrote:TC is correct...Pat was offered the men's team. Rob doesn't think the men's team could be coached by a woman. I ask one question...when the cameras are rolling on the sidelines, what do all players say..."Hi, Mom!" Don't ever try to convince me guys won't listen to a mom. Just remember, Pat flew to visit a recruit WHILE IN LABOR. The story goes that after the recruit & her family agreed to go to UT, Pat said she needed to hurry back to Knoxville. When they got on the plane, her assistant asked what was wrong. Pat told her that her water had broket 3 hours earlier. That is one tough woman in my book! I don't think too many guys would mess with her! The main point is Pat doesn't WANT to leave UT's women's program. It would greatly surprise me is she doesn't retire from there.


Mom, there is no man a live that is a bigger mommy's boy than me. But with all due respect to my mom, I'm not going to play ball for her! Respecting her and playing for her are two different things. As I have previously stated I have nothing but respect for Pat, she is a great women's coach.

I bet no one ever thought Sprewell would try and choke a coach either?
If I were to read, much less answer, all the attacks made on me, this shop might as well be closed for business. I do the very best I know how, the very best I can, and I mean to keep doing so until the end. If the end brings me out right, what is said against me won't amount to anything. If the end brings me out wrong, ten angels swearing I was right will make no difference." -Abraham Lincoln


Return to “Entertainment”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 59 guests

Login  •  Register