Possible Play-off System? Or at least a starting point.

A forum for the discussion of TV, movies, music and pop-culture influences from a Christian perspective. A free-wheeling forum for discussion of Christian issues.

Moderators: Pastor Gary, The J2 Mod Squad

User avatar
TW
Established Member
Posts: 8866
Joined: November 4th, 2004, 3:38 pm
Location: USA,Georgia
Contact:

Possible Play-off System? Or at least a starting point.

Postby TW » November 12th, 2006, 6:58 am

From another thread.

Pastor Rob wrote:
Paully, I feel your pain. As much as I want to see a playoff, I'm not sure how it make it work. ImaPK has yet to give me a good senerio to convince me. I'm still waiting.

Yes we need a playoff, but how to make it work is the question.


Here's a possiblity based upon NCAA stats:
W/L/T Record + Total Offense + Total Defense

These three catagories embody everything needed to determine a fair and equitable ranking.
note: All division I teams have to meet certain minimun standards and thus must be treated as being theoretically equal.

How it works -
From the W/L/T record: all undefeated and one loss teams, award raw points as follows: undefeated teams get zero points, one loss teams get one point.

From the Total Offense and Total Defense records award raw points from both catagories as follows: teams with the best record are awarded one point, the second best record gets two points, and so forth.

Total raw points to determine seed. The team with the lowest raw point value is the number one seed and so forth.

I would limit the play-off to the eight top teams. Some sort of tie breaker will probably have to be available in case of ties for the final slot in the play-offs.

A practical demonstration based upon the records to date:

Michigan - W/L/T ud (0) + TO 34 (10) +TD 3 (1) = 11 points = 3 seed
Ohio St. - W/L/T ud (0) + TO 19 (5) + TD 8 (4) = 9 pts = 1 seed
Boise St. - W/L/T ud (0) + TO 15 (4) + TD 29 ( 8 ) = 12 pts = 4 seed (t)
Rutgers - W/L/T ud (0) + TO 79 (11) + TD 4 (2) = 13 pts = 6 seed (t)
Wisconson - W/L/T 1 (1) + TO 26 ( 8 ) + TD 7 (3) = 12 pts = 4 seed (t)
W F - W/L/T 1 (1) + TO 101 (12) + TD 40 (10) = 23 pts = 12 seed
Florida - W/L/T 1 (1) + TO 29 (9) + TD 18 (5) = 15 pts = 10 seed
N D - W/L/T 1 (1) + TO 23 (7) + TD 59 (12) = 20 pts = 11 seed
Arkansas - W/L/T 1 (1) + TO 20 (6) + TD 24 (7) = 14 pts = 9 seed
So. Cal. - W/L/T 1 (1) + TO 9 (3) + TD 20 (6) = 10 pts = 2 seed
W. Vir. - W/L/T 1 (1) + TO 3 (2) + TD 35 (9) = 13 pts = 6 seed (t)
Louisville - W/L/T 1 (1) + TO 2 (1) + TD 50 (11) = 13 pts = 6 seed (t)

note: The bold numbers are NCAA rankings, the parenthetical numbers are rankings within this group.

The teams in red would be out of the play-offs.

I know that there isn't a system that everybody will like, but Ive tried to be fair and emotionally detached in designing this system.


TW
Anglo-Saxon Proto-English Manuscripts (995 AD): “God lufode middan-eard swa, dat he seade his an-cennedan sunu, dat nan ne forweorde de on hine gely ac habbe dat ece lif."

My blog - http://theoldman.wordpress.com/

TC
Hey, hey, hey
Posts: 1922
Joined: February 20th, 2003, 5:00 pm
Location: "the Ville" ky

Postby TC » November 12th, 2006, 3:42 pm

Never work... it will get back to the SOS and people having to run up the score. To keep your points down you would schedule the wanna be teams that really only play you for the TV time and money and you would have to run up the score to make it look good. IT was just about that way before, You had to beat a team BADLY or it didn't matter if you won or not. THEN how would you take care of the weak teams... IS it fair that FSU would get to beat up on DUKE (a team that most HS teams would beat the pants off) and others would have as their "light weight" conference team would be like IU making good steps forward. It would not be fair to have points against Duke count the same as points against OSU/USC..or any other top 10 team

User avatar
RamboPreacher
RamboPreacher
Posts: 12355
Joined: July 17th, 2004, 5:41 pm
Location: USA, Texas

Postby RamboPreacher » November 12th, 2006, 3:51 pm

it's sports. you beat a team, you are the winner. :)
Thanks, Brent "RamboPreacher" Hoefling

User avatar
Rob
Hey, hey, hey
Posts: 1605
Joined: April 14th, 2004, 4:59 am
Location: USA,Kentucky

Re: Possible Play-off System? Or at least a starting point.

Postby Rob » November 13th, 2006, 3:45 am

TW wrote:From another thread.

Pastor Rob wrote:
Paully, I feel your pain. As much as I want to see a playoff, I'm not sure how it make it work. ImaPK has yet to give me a good senerio to convince me. I'm still waiting.

Yes we need a playoff, but how to make it work is the question.


Here's a possiblity based upon NCAA stats:
W/L/T Record + Total Offense + Total Defense

These three catagories embody everything needed to determine a fair and equitable ranking.
note: All division I teams have to meet certain minimun standards and thus must be treated as being theoretically equal.

How it works -
From the W/L/T record: all undefeated and one loss teams, award raw points as follows: undefeated teams get zero points, one loss teams get one point.

From the Total Offense and Total Defense records award raw points from both catagories as follows: teams with the best record are awarded one point, the second best record gets two points, and so forth.

Total raw points to determine seed. The team with the lowest raw point value is the number one seed and so forth.

I would limit the play-off to the eight top teams. Some sort of tie breaker will probably have to be available in case of ties for the final slot in the play-offs.

A practical demonstration based upon the records to date:

Michigan - W/L/T ud (0) + TO 34 (10) +TD 3 (1) = 11 points = 3 seed
Ohio St. - W/L/T ud (0) + TO 19 (5) + TD 8 (4) = 9 pts = 1 seed
Boise St. - W/L/T ud (0) + TO 15 (4) + TD 29 ( 8 ) = 12 pts = 4 seed (t)
Rutgers - W/L/T ud (0) + TO 79 (11) + TD 4 (2) = 13 pts = 6 seed (t)
Wisconson - W/L/T 1 (1) + TO 26 ( 8 ) + TD 7 (3) = 12 pts = 4 seed (t)
W F - W/L/T 1 (1) + TO 101 (12) + TD 40 (10) = 23 pts = 12 seed
Florida - W/L/T 1 (1) + TO 29 (9) + TD 18 (5) = 15 pts = 10 seed
N D - W/L/T 1 (1) + TO 23 (7) + TD 59 (12) = 20 pts = 11 seed
Arkansas - W/L/T 1 (1) + TO 20 (6) + TD 24 (7) = 14 pts = 9 seed
So. Cal. - W/L/T 1 (1) + TO 9 (3) + TD 20 (6) = 10 pts = 2 seed
W. Vir. - W/L/T 1 (1) + TO 3 (2) + TD 35 (9) = 13 pts = 6 seed (t)
Louisville - W/L/T 1 (1) + TO 2 (1) + TD 50 (11) = 13 pts = 6 seed (t)

note: The bold numbers are NCAA rankings, the parenthetical numbers are rankings within this group.

The teams in red would be out of the play-offs.

I know that there isn't a system that everybody will like, but Ive tried to be fair and emotionally detached in designing this system.


TW


TW, thank you for your work. I appreciate all the time energy and effort it took to comply that list.

I only have a few questions for you. First, remember now in college football there are no ties. You play overtime till someone wins. So it would simply be won/lost record.

My first question is on the Total Offense/Total Defense where did that information come from? I know that WVU in rushing offense is one of the top 2 or 3 teams in America. Passing is a different subject. You state that all D-1 teams have to meet minimum standards. My question is what are those standards?

I still think you have to figure in somewhere in the mix, the Strength of Schedule. While I have noticed you include Boise St. on your list, in all fairness, there is not a team you have listed that if they played Boise's schedule they would also be undefeated.

I noticed on your formula that Florida, Arkansas, where out of the playoffs, with all due respect, those have to be 2 of the top 8 teams.

While again I commend you on your work, those are some things that I believe in your system would not work.

My $.02

User avatar
Rob
Hey, hey, hey
Posts: 1605
Joined: April 14th, 2004, 4:59 am
Location: USA,Kentucky

Here's my formula for a Playoff

Postby Rob » November 13th, 2006, 4:01 am

Every Conference that wants to be considered for the BSC must have the following:

MUST have an 8 game regular season schedule of conference teams. Most do that now if they have enough teams.

MUST have a conference championship game. Like the SEC, Big XII, ACC, MAC does. IMO only conference champions should play for NC.

Now what that does it makes the Big Ten have to include another team. The Big East must add 4, Pac 10 must add one, but what that does is it gives conference's like the MAC, WAC, Mountain West, a chance to compete with the Big Boy's.

With that formula you would have 8 Conference Champions. Big 10, SEC, ACC, Big East, Big XII, PAC 10, MAC, Mountain West, Champions, have a blind draw, that way there can be no arguing over seating. Then play first round games in the COTTON, GATOR, ORANGE, CITRUS bowls, play Semi-Finals in FIESTA and SUGAR bowls, and championship game in ROSE bowl alternating the Championship game between ORANGE/ROSE/FIESTA and SUGAR.

I know this is not perfect, but hey it's better than what we have right now.

User avatar
Paully_44
Established Member
Posts: 7480
Joined: January 30th, 2003, 4:20 am
Location: USA,Washington

Re: Here's my formula for a Playoff

Postby Paully_44 » November 13th, 2006, 5:06 am

Pastor Rob wrote:Every Conference that wants to be considered for the BSC must have the following:

MUST have an 8 game regular season schedule of conference teams. Most do that now if they have enough teams.

MUST have a conference championship game. Like the SEC, Big XII, ACC, MAC does. IMO only conference champions should play for NC.

Now what that does it makes the Big Ten have to include another team. The Big East must add 4, Pac 10 must add one, but what that does is it gives conference's like the MAC, WAC, Mountain West, a chance to compete with the Big Boy's.

With that formula you would have 8 Conference Champions. Big 10, SEC, ACC, Big East, Big XII, PAC 10, MAC, Mountain West, Champions, have a blind draw, that way there can be no arguing over seating. Then play first round games in the COTTON, GATOR, ORANGE, CITRUS bowls, play Semi-Finals in FIESTA and SUGAR bowls, and championship game in ROSE bowl alternating the Championship game between ORANGE/ROSE/FIESTA and SUGAR.

I know this is not perfect, but hey it's better than what we have right now.


And it will cause N.D to actually enter a conference and stop getting preferential treatment.

Notre Dame needs to finish in the top eight in the final BCS standings for automatic entry. A top-12 finish makes the Irish eligible for selection.
Let the wild rumpus start!

User avatar
Rob
Hey, hey, hey
Posts: 1605
Joined: April 14th, 2004, 4:59 am
Location: USA,Kentucky

Re: Here's my formula for a Playoff

Postby Rob » November 13th, 2006, 5:23 am

Paully_44 wrote:And it will cause N.D to actually enter a conference and stop getting preferential treatment.

Notre Dame needs to finish in the top eight in the final BCS standings for automatic entry. A top-12 finish makes the Irish eligible for selection.


That is exactly correct. I wondered how long it would take for someone to catch what I was doing and saying.

Thanks Paully

User avatar
KBevangelist
Hey, hey, hey
Posts: 1998
Joined: August 21st, 2006, 12:00 pm
Location: USA,NorthCarolina
Contact:

Re: Here's my formula for a Playoff

Postby KBevangelist » November 13th, 2006, 8:53 am

Pastor Rob wrote:
Paully_44 wrote:And it will cause N.D to actually enter a conference and stop getting preferential treatment.

Notre Dame needs to finish in the top eight in the final BCS standings for automatic entry. A top-12 finish makes the Irish eligible for selection.


That is exactly correct. I wondered how long it would take for someone to catch what I was doing and saying.

Thanks Paully


I think ND should be forced to actually have to get in a conference, their basketball teams already are.

They get special treatment regardless of their record :lol:

TC
Hey, hey, hey
Posts: 1922
Joined: February 20th, 2003, 5:00 pm
Location: "the Ville" ky

Postby TC » November 13th, 2006, 12:31 pm

I think ND should be forced to actually have to get in a conference, their basketball teams already are.


AMEN... I agree. They have the best of both worlds. They get BE basketball money (which is not a money maker for them) they get the shot at BE basketball NCAA tourney spots and they share any money that the other BE teams get... BUT their money making sport they don't have to share any of their TV money or bowl money... If they are not in the BCS bowl they can actually take a BE bowl and put the BE team to a lower bowl...

THEY NEED TO GET IN OR GET OUT... ALL IN or ALL OUT...

[/code]

User avatar
dolfan
Established Member
Posts: 8016
Joined: March 17th, 2004, 1:25 pm
Location: USA,Alabama
Contact:

Postby dolfan » November 13th, 2006, 1:33 pm

I like TW's system enough, with some tweaks. First, all teams are not equal, even theoretically. Without sparking flames among those who love the Big East teams, I'd argue that year-in and year-out, SEC and Big 10 teams at the top of their conferences can handily thump the BE teams that lead it. And Boise State? I like 'em, blue field and all, fun to watch if you like basketball scores in football games, which I do sometimes.

So, let's eliminate conferences altogether as a means of determining anything. Let's cordon off, for geography's sake, conferences, but not determine a "champion" of any of them. We could arrange schedules as the NFL does, based on previous year's performance. For instance, every year, AFC East team #4 from previous year will play AFC Central team #3 and NFC West #2, or some such. Conferences help build rivalries that sell tickets, but they mainly just give a framework for scheduling, increasing parity (in the NCAA? Perish the thought!), and seeding playoffs.

So, let's start on an imperfect footing since we already have that, and have, say, 2010 as a benchmark after which all schedules are made according to something akin to the NFL mode. Each team can still play half its games as conference games, (even in the NFL most teams play only 6 division games on a 16 game schedule). You can maintain the best rivalries and increase fully national play among powerhouses. No more just getting beat up by the tough defenses in the SEC and getting losses from pure attrition and physicality while teams like Boise State wait until their bowl game (if then even) to even play a real college defense. Plus, you build parity, get more fully national exposure for your program (if you need it), and you wind up with a playoff bracket that is, if nothing else, more objective as TW has outlined. That at least makes it less likely that a Rutgers gets in on a softer schedule (sorry, BE fans) while Arkansas is on the outside looking in simply because it lost to USC while beating all other comers, (assuming it beats LSU in 2 weeks and then Florida in the championship game, which is a safe one if they keep looking like they did against Tenn.).
Human government bears the same relation to hell as the church bears to heaven. (David Lipscomb, On Civil Government, 72).

User avatar
TW
Established Member
Posts: 8866
Joined: November 4th, 2004, 3:38 pm
Location: USA,Georgia
Contact:

Re: Possible Play-off System? Or at least a starting point.

Postby TW » November 13th, 2006, 2:26 pm

Pastor Rob wrote:TW, thank you for your work. I appreciate all the time energy and effort it took to comply that list.

I only have a few questions for you. First, remember now in college football there are no ties. You play overtime till someone wins. So it would simply be won/lost record.

My first question is on the Total Offense/Total Defense where did that information come from? I know that WVU in rushing offense is one of the top 2 or 3 teams in America. Passing is a different subject. You state that all D-1 teams have to meet minimum standards. My question is what are those standards?

I still think you have to figure in somewhere in the mix, the Strength of Schedule. While I have noticed you include Boise St. on your list, in all fairness, there is not a team you have listed that if they played Boise's schedule they would also be undefeated.

I noticed on your formula that Florida, Arkansas, where out of the playoffs, with all due respect, those have to be 2 of the top 8 teams.

While again I commend you on your work, those are some things that I believe in your system would not work.

My $.02


Rob I shall address your questions in the order in which you asked them.

"My first question is on the Total Offense/Total Defense where did that information come from?"

http://www.ncaa.org/stats/football/footballMenu.html

"You state that all D-1 teams have to meet minimum standards. My question is what are those standards?"

This is off the official NCAA website:

Division I
Division I member institutions have to sponsor at least seven sports for men and seven for women (or six for men and eight for women) with two team sports for each gender. Each playing season has to be represented by each gender as well. There are contest and participant minimums for each sport, as well as scheduling criteria. For sports other than football and basketball, Division I schools must play 100 percent of the minimum number of contests against Division I opponents -- anything over the minimum number of games has to be 50 percent Division I. Men's and women's basketball teams have to play all but two games against Division I teams; for men, they must play one-third of all their contests in the home arena. Schools that have football are classified as Division I-A or I-AA. I-A football schools are usually fairly elaborate programs. Division I-A teams have to meet minimum attendance requirements (average 15,000 people in actual or paid attendance per home game), which must be met once in a rolling two-year period. Division I-AA teams do not need to meet minimum attendance requirements. Division I schools must meet minimum financial aid awards for their athletics program, and there are maximum financial aid awards for each sport that a Division I school cannot exceed.


All D I programs are limited to the same minimum/maximum financial aid awards. They have a mimimum number of sports that must sponsor. In theory they all start out equal.

"While I have noticed you include Boise St. on your list, in all fairness, there is not a team you have listed that if they played Boise's schedule they would also be undefeated."

This system is based soley on statistical data, and the data supports Boise St. being in the mix.

"I noticed on your formula that Florida, Arkansas, where out of the playoffs, with all due respect, those have to be 2 of the top 8 teams."

At the present time the stats do not support Florida and Arkansas being in the top eight. I do think that by the end of the season much will have changed in the ststa and the top eight will be somewhat different than it is presently shown.


TW
Anglo-Saxon Proto-English Manuscripts (995 AD): “God lufode middan-eard swa, dat he seade his an-cennedan sunu, dat nan ne forweorde de on hine gely ac habbe dat ece lif."



My blog - http://theoldman.wordpress.com/

User avatar
TW
Established Member
Posts: 8866
Joined: November 4th, 2004, 3:38 pm
Location: USA,Georgia
Contact:

Postby TW » November 13th, 2006, 2:40 pm

Rob,
Just a thought. SOS could be factored in, but only after all teams had played their entire regular schedules. That way you would have a real comparison for SOS.


TW
Anglo-Saxon Proto-English Manuscripts (995 AD): “God lufode middan-eard swa, dat he seade his an-cennedan sunu, dat nan ne forweorde de on hine gely ac habbe dat ece lif."



My blog - http://theoldman.wordpress.com/

TC
Hey, hey, hey
Posts: 1922
Joined: February 20th, 2003, 5:00 pm
Location: "the Ville" ky

Postby TC » November 13th, 2006, 3:30 pm

This system is based soley on statistical data,


but the data can be manipulated by the teams played... 400 passing yards on Duke is not like 400 passing yards on WVU, or FLA... but according to what I have read in your post... it would be equal no matter who the other team was... THAT is not fair to the teams that play a tougher schedule... and tougher teams...

User avatar
TW
Established Member
Posts: 8866
Joined: November 4th, 2004, 3:38 pm
Location: USA,Georgia
Contact:

Postby TW » November 13th, 2006, 6:03 pm

TC,

As I have stated, there is no system that is perfect and everybody will buy into. That's a fact! Could some schools try to manipulate this system? Yes! Do some schools try to manipulate the current BCS system? Yes!

The fact is that life is not fair and you either learn to play by the rules of life or you die or go insane. It's unfair that I wasn't born rich. It's unfair that I'm not 6' 4" tall. It's unfair that I have to compete in the workplace with guys that are 1/3rd my age and in perfect health.

The most accurate way to determine who should be eligible for a NC play-off berth is by statistical analysis. And now I have added SOS as a factor in the final determination. Or we could just throw all 119 D I teams in a hat and draw the finalist.

Pastor Rob and dolfan have both had positive input in this, but all we have heard from you is "it won't work!" I find it hard to believe that someone who knows football as well as you do cannot come up with some constructive thinking.


TW
Anglo-Saxon Proto-English Manuscripts (995 AD): “God lufode middan-eard swa, dat he seade his an-cennedan sunu, dat nan ne forweorde de on hine gely ac habbe dat ece lif."



My blog - http://theoldman.wordpress.com/

User avatar
Rob
Hey, hey, hey
Posts: 1605
Joined: April 14th, 2004, 4:59 am
Location: USA,Kentucky

Postby Rob » November 14th, 2006, 4:50 am

dolfan wrote:I like TW's system enough, with some tweaks. First, all teams are not equal, even theoretically. Without sparking flames among those who love the Big East teams, I'd argue that year-in and year-out, SEC and Big 10 teams at the top of their conferences can handily thump the BE teams that lead it. And Boise State? I like 'em, blue field and all, fun to watch if you like basketball scores in football games, which I do sometimes.

So, let's eliminate conferences altogether as a means of determining anything. Let's cordon off, for geography's sake, conferences, but not determine a "champion" of any of them. We could arrange schedules as the NFL does, based on previous year's performance. For instance, every year, AFC East team #4 from previous year will play AFC Central team #3 and NFC West #2, or some such. Conferences help build rivalries that sell tickets, but they mainly just give a framework for scheduling, increasing parity (in the NCAA? Perish the thought!), and seeding playoffs.

So, let's start on an imperfect footing since we already have that, and have, say, 2010 as a benchmark after which all schedules are made according to something akin to the NFL mode. Each team can still play half its games as conference games, (even in the NFL most teams play only 6 division games on a 16 game schedule). You can maintain the best rivalries and increase fully national play among powerhouses. No more just getting beat up by the tough defenses in the SEC and getting losses from pure attrition and physicality while teams like Boise State wait until their bowl game (if then even) to even play a real college defense. Plus, you build parity, get more fully national exposure for your program (if you need it), and you wind up with a playoff bracket that is, if nothing else, more objective as TW has outlined. That at least makes it less likely that a Rutgers gets in on a softer schedule (sorry, BE fans) while Arkansas is on the outside looking in simply because it lost to USC while beating all other comers, (assuming it beats LSU in 2 weeks and then Florida in the championship game, which is a safe one if they keep looking like they did against Tenn.).


Dolfan, for the most part I have agree or at least made sense of most of your posts. However, this one has got me thinking the dude is one of two things. Drunk or doing drugs.

Allow me to remind you, that a BE team went to the Sugar Bowl last year, in Georgia's backyard and beat them. This year, WVU has beat a team that has the chance to play in the ACC championship game if it wins out, Maryland. So give up the year-in-year-out argument. I also know that UL has tried to schedule other SEC teams a home & home and other than UK NO ONE from the SEC will schedule them. (Did I just take up for UL, I guess I'm on drugs now)

Eliminate conferences? Now it must be crack you are on!! Football's regular season is the only college sport where the regular season actually means something. Even in basketball teams make conference tourney's and can spoil the whole thing. e.g., South Carolina last year in the SEC tourney almost won the whole thing with a terrible regular season record.

Let the NFL be the NFL, but let college be college. Remember a few years ago in the NCAA you had to win the conference tourney to make the Big Dance, now 65 teams get in and every year you have a school or two that cries because Robert Morris won their conference tourney and another school got beat in a power conference.

Want a playoff. Get in a conference. Have a conference championship game. Let those winners play for the NC. That way ND has to be in a conference. Boise St., would have a chance to win.

Even if you use stats, you can run stats up when you play a weaker team. Football was made to be played between white lines on a 100 yard field 50 yards wide not on a keyboard with a screen or calculator.


Return to “Entertainment”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 42 guests

Login  •  Register