Harry Potter and Charmed Ones

A forum for the discussion of TV, movies, music and pop-culture influences from a Christian perspective. A free-wheeling forum for discussion of Christian issues.

Moderators: Pastor Gary, The J2 Mod Squad

User avatar
Jennifer Smith
Moderator
Posts: 3745
Joined: June 23rd, 2003, 11:40 am
Location: USA,Indiana

Postby Jennifer Smith » September 26th, 2006, 4:41 pm

Can't BCoy, there is also power in a child believing and affirming his beliefs to others. If your child is saved they can have enough discernment to tell right from wrong without you sitting down and examining every form of entertainment with them.

When my oldest daughter, Katie was in 3rd grade public school her teacher knew that she didn't celebrate Halloween because my daughter had told her so. She called me on the phone, and with a humble attitude told me that she was feeling very guilty about stamping skeletons on a little child's papers who didn't believe in celebrating Halloween. She told me she had planned to use some Halloween math papers with the children and would I mind? I hesitated, not wanting to interfere. I told her I didn't want to interfere..but I did ask, "Do they have witches on them?" She seemed to be under very heavy conviction. She told me her parents had brought her to church as a child and that she kept thinking about my little girl. I said I didn't want to make her decision concerning the math papers. She hung up, and called me back twice and very apologetically said she would not use the Halloween stamps or any halloween papers. She further added that their fall party would be simply a fall party and not a halloween party. I don't believe that children are idiots, they see things in black and white more often than we do and sometimes we need to!
..I press on to take hold of that
for which Christ took hold of me.
-Phil 3:12

Gerald Creasy

Postby Gerald Creasy » September 27th, 2006, 3:09 am

I dont see anything whatsoever wrong With Harry Potter.

Folks my age grew up watching Bewitched, I dream of Jeane, Dark Shadows and Bedknobs and Broomsticks... Full of all kinds of horrid stuff.

Never once have I wanted to summon a demon or practice witchcraft or any such thing.

MAINLY BECAUSE I HAVE THE INTELLIGENCE TO KNOW THAT THOSE WERE WORKS OF FICTION (BUt hey, How many people fell for Mike Warnke's Out Of Witchcraft into Christianity fiction????)

I don't read Rowling for my own sense of cussedness. My favorite is Terry Pratchett (Who I've mentioned here before) the SECOND most published British writer {but most shoplifted author) who writes using all kinds of characters: imps, wizards, witches, golems, trolls, dwarves , vampires you name it.

The thing is he uses them as SATIRE of OUR CURRENT CULTURE. His latest one was a clever parody of The Davinci Code, muslim extremists and racial hatred.

Why can't trolls & dwarves get along? Why do the black garbed dwarf holy figures desire war, violence and killing so much? Oh the answer may lie in a famous painting!!

I laughed my self silly.

User avatar
Pastor Bill
---=== J2 ===---
Posts: 5168
Joined: February 3rd, 2003, 10:04 am
Location: USA,Kentucky
Contact:

Postby Pastor Bill » September 27th, 2006, 5:32 am

Honestly this really depends on you, and (as a parenting issue) your children.

Some people are pulled in my these things, some these are areas of temptation that they don't need, for others, it's not a stumbling block and purely entertainment.

YOU have to know where you stand, and as a Parent, you have to know what your children can handle and what they cannot. It's an individual thing, and depends alot on personality, convictions and temptations. for myself, I have never been even tempted toward witchcraft, and I have watched the HP movies, and enjoyed them, My son has not, he has a very strong imagination, and loves to act out his favorite movies, and had a little trouble recognizing reality from fiction when these were first coming out (he was 4-5 at the time) Now, I probably wouldn't have a problem with it, because he is older, and we talk about those type of things.

Frankly we are more concerned with some of the junk they have on TV for kids that is constantly rude and obnoxious, because THAT they do pick up on and continue much more than something they see as make believe.

User avatar
Jennifer Smith
Moderator
Posts: 3745
Joined: June 23rd, 2003, 11:40 am
Location: USA,Indiana

Postby Jennifer Smith » September 27th, 2006, 11:08 am

My point was to merely point out that parents that do not allow a certain amount of controlled exposure, run the risk of allowing your child to be taught by someone else.



I agree that it is wise not to be overly prohibitive, especially without giving the moral reason why some things are not allowed. My children don't seem to fel any fascination or inclination towards Harry Potter. What fellowship does light have with darkness? I don't see why any thing that is an abomination to God should be entertaining to a Christian.
I'm sorry if I speak too plain or straightforward, it's just something I feel strongly about.

Gerald you said that many watched Bewitched and it had "no effect"- but how can you be so sure? Is the devil always obvious or blatant in his tactics or is he subtle? My pastor's wife grew up thinking she could perform magic and as an unchurched young girl it (Bewitched) created a doorway in her life to the occult. If God doesn't want us visiting mediums or witches would He want us to invite them in our home through tv or movies?I believe this can be a doorway we open, inviting demonic presence. It doesn't matter if you "believe it" or not, demons are still real.

HP and Charmed are certainly "darker" than Bewitched; perhaps Bewitched paved the way making them "acceptable" or more easily palatable in our now Post-Christian society. Rowling said early on her books would get darker as the series progressed. This should also make it an easier decision for Christians to avoid them.
..I press on to take hold of that

for which Christ took hold of me.

-Phil 3:12

Gerald Creasy

Postby Gerald Creasy » September 27th, 2006, 1:19 pm

Jennifer Smith wrote:Gerald you said that many watched Bewitched and it had "no effect"- but how can you be so sure?


You're right..you are absolutely right.

I think Elizabeth Montgomery as her evil dark haired twin Cousin Serena plainly did something to my prepubescent idea of what was"sexy"

User avatar
Shellie
Site Admin
Posts: 8750
Joined: January 29th, 2003, 4:24 pm
Location: USA,Florida
Contact:

Postby Shellie » September 27th, 2006, 1:43 pm

I think the Left Behind series can be damaging. I think it can give kids a false sense of security.

Since I am not a Pre-tribber, I never encouraged my kids to read them.
There never was a horse that couldn't be rode and there never was a cowboy that couldn't be throwed.

User avatar
Jennifer Smith
Moderator
Posts: 3745
Joined: June 23rd, 2003, 11:40 am
Location: USA,Indiana

Postby Jennifer Smith » September 27th, 2006, 5:08 pm

I think Elizabeth Montgomery as her evil dark haired twin Cousin Serena plainly did something to my prepubescent idea of what was"sexy"


Okay Gerald that's more info than I was looking for! :)

I used to watch the show too but we had halloween parties at our church then too.
..I press on to take hold of that

for which Christ took hold of me.

-Phil 3:12

Gerald Creasy

Postby Gerald Creasy » September 28th, 2006, 3:28 am

Jennifer Smith wrote:Okay Gerald that's more info than I was looking for! :)

I used to watch the show too but we had halloween parties at our church then too.



How could it have affected me without me knowing it?

What was meant by that?

Do I wiggle my nose in my sleep and the sheep count themselves??

User avatar
Blended
Woohoo!
Posts: 1319
Joined: March 18th, 2004, 6:16 pm
Location: the Bible Belt

Postby Blended » September 28th, 2006, 10:28 am

We give to much power to the devil and his minions

how can we know we have not be affected?

We know we have passed from death into life because we love our brothers.

I am sorry but this HP/charmed thing just takes me back to the music, television debate of my childhood.

It was Ok for my parents generation to listen to george, Hank and tammy sing about all night drunks and honkytonks but because rock music had that beat it was of the devil. How many preachers talked about that One eyed devil in our homes.

Folks the enemy has found his way to entice and lead astray in the midst of the most puritanical societies.I know preacher's kids who were not allowed to breathe let alone watch tv or listen to "ungodly" music who are the worse sinners today it was not bewitched that led them astray it was the prideful domination of their parents who were so full of fear that they instilled a respect for sin in the lives of their children.

listen to what you are saying the devil is so strong and powerful that he can use a book of fiction to overwhelm the truth that you have and are teaching your children.

Instead of expeling all of this angst and energy trying to hold back every thing that mentions a mythical power or trait of the enemy should not we be spending more time and effort educating and drawing in to closer relationship our children to christ.
Speaking the truth as I know it.

User avatar
Jennifer Smith
Moderator
Posts: 3745
Joined: June 23rd, 2003, 11:40 am
Location: USA,Indiana

I meant

Postby Jennifer Smith » September 28th, 2006, 11:46 am

Gerald don't get your shorts in a wad! I'm not trying to say you were demonized by watching the show! I meant how can you be sure if it affected anyone- you said a whole generation had watched the show. (That is why I mentioned my pastor's wife.)

Also wanted to mention a young man my husband counseled, part of our church in PA who struggled with witchcraft. Though he was baptized and confessed this struggle it was difficult for him, probably because of his desire to control situations and circumstances.

Blended I wasn't raised superstrict. My parents gave us reasons for why things were wrong. I've noticed that folks who had or feel they had a strict, legalistic upbringing have a more difficult time with knowing where to draw a line in their lives. I do believe that many issues are personal between a person and God.

After Sam started pastoring in an a/g church, for a time God had us give up tv, that was just for us at that time. Many people can listen to secular music and not have it affect them spiritually, but I myself don't, because as someone else put it, "my flesh is too healthy." Sam does sometimes but that's fine for him. I don't judge another person's choice. I get concerned though when people seem to want to say anything goes, when they seem to want to throw out the concept of holiness entirely. The Bible says without holiness noone will see God. Besides that holiness has great benefits, both spiritually and in living a healthy, happy life!
..I press on to take hold of that

for which Christ took hold of me.

-Phil 3:12


Return to “Entertainment”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 3 guests

Login  •  Register