Pastor Rob wrote:
Paully, I feel your pain. As much as I want to see a playoff, I'm not sure how it make it work. ImaPK has yet to give me a good senerio to convince me. I'm still waiting.
Yes we need a playoff, but how to make it work is the question.
Here's a possiblity based upon NCAA stats:
W/L/T Record + Total Offense + Total Defense
These three catagories embody everything needed to determine a fair and equitable ranking.
note: All division I teams have to meet certain minimun standards and thus must be treated as being theoretically equal.
How it works -
From the W/L/T record: all undefeated and one loss teams, award raw points as follows: undefeated teams get zero points, one loss teams get one point.
From the Total Offense and Total Defense records award raw points from both catagories as follows: teams with the best record are awarded one point, the second best record gets two points, and so forth.
Total raw points to determine seed. The team with the lowest raw point value is the number one seed and so forth.
I would limit the play-off to the eight top teams. Some sort of tie breaker will probably have to be available in case of ties for the final slot in the play-offs.
A practical demonstration based upon the records to date:
Michigan - W/L/T ud (0) + TO 34 (10) +TD 3 (1) = 11 points = 3 seed
Ohio St. - W/L/T ud (0) + TO 19 (5) + TD 8 (4) = 9 pts = 1 seed
Boise St. - W/L/T ud (0) + TO 15 (4) + TD 29 ( 8 ) = 12 pts = 4 seed (t)
Rutgers - W/L/T ud (0) + TO 79 (11) + TD 4 (2) = 13 pts = 6 seed (t)
Wisconson - W/L/T 1 (1) + TO 26 ( 8 ) + TD 7 (3) = 12 pts = 4 seed (t)
W F - W/L/T 1 (1) + TO 101 (12) + TD 40 (10) = 23 pts = 12 seed
Florida - W/L/T 1 (1) + TO 29 (9) + TD 18 (5) = 15 pts = 10 seed
N D - W/L/T 1 (1) + TO 23 (7) + TD 59 (12) = 20 pts = 11 seed
Arkansas - W/L/T 1 (1) + TO 20 (6) + TD 24 (7) = 14 pts = 9 seed
So. Cal. - W/L/T 1 (1) + TO 9 (3) + TD 20 (6) = 10 pts = 2 seed
W. Vir. - W/L/T 1 (1) + TO 3 (2) + TD 35 (9) = 13 pts = 6 seed (t)
Louisville - W/L/T 1 (1) + TO 2 (1) + TD 50 (11) = 13 pts = 6 seed (t)
note: The bold numbers are NCAA rankings, the parenthetical numbers are rankings within this group.
The teams in red would be out of the play-offs.
I know that there isn't a system that everybody will like, but Ive tried to be fair and emotionally detached in designing this system.
TW

![Remember our veterans and troops currently serving today. [amer-ribbon90.gif]](/images/amer-ribbon90.gif)