Page 1 of 2

24 -- Redemption

Posted: November 23rd, 2008, 6:45 pm
by dolfan
Who all saw it? What'd you think?

I LOVED it. This season is going to be great (or it should be, looks to be on the previews).

PROBLEM: SAG strike looms. Will they delay the season premiere? Your thoughts.

Re: 24 -- Redemption

Posted: November 23rd, 2008, 9:08 pm
by Tim Elston
dolfan wrote:Who all saw it? What'd you think?


I don't know. To me it seemed a little flat. It was too black and white, no complexity of moral issues.

Old stereotypes. Incoming Democratic ("good") President. (They must have started writing when Hillary was still expected to win.) Outgoing Republican ("bad") President. Spineless UN Soldier. American that never shoots a child, even if the child has a weapon drawn at point blank range saying, "Kill the cockroaches." Sinister governmental leader.

I liked the redemption theme. The boy soldier problem is real. Bauer sacrificed his freedom for the children; his friend gave his life for them.

dolfan wrote:I LOVED it. This season is going to be great (or it should be, looks to be on the previews).


I'll probably like the season. Hopefully they'll weave some character complexity into it like they did last season. Some people say 24 bombed last year because of the family members, but, unlikely as the scenarios were, what sold it for me was just that character complexity.

dolfan wrote:PROBLEM: SAG strike looms. Will they delay the season premiere? Your thoughts.


I wish those rich whiners would sit down and shut up.

Posted: November 24th, 2008, 3:23 am
by DeWayneTN
We thought it was great. Looks like they are lining up some good plotlines this season - at least they are shaking it up a bit. Go Jack!!

Posted: November 24th, 2008, 9:49 am
by dolfan
Tim, I don't know how Jack Bauer shooting a 10 year old kid the same way he's mercilessly shot so many others would work. You can say a lot of things on TV, do almost anything, but killing a kid ---- we're still not there, yet. I think that was as much of a reason why that scene had to play out like it did as anything. We both know that most anyone else in that position would've killed the kid, or the kid would've killed him with that machine gun he had in his hands.

I found myself thinking about the kid-soldier problem a lot though. Who knows? Maybe this does something to the American mind about the thugs in Africa. IF we're going to make the world safe for democracy, it ought to be safe from child conscription at least. That's a cause worth doing some Van-Dammage over. :lol:

Posted: November 24th, 2008, 9:52 am
by DeWayneTN
Forget about that kid. What about the one who got Jack's friend killed by chasing after the scarf and then forced Jack to hold his hand and get himself turned in? Talk about a troublemaker.

Posted: November 24th, 2008, 11:25 am
by Tim Elston
dolfan wrote:Tim, I don't know how Jack Bauer shooting a 10 year old kid the same way he's mercilessly shot so many others would work. You can say a lot of things on TV, do almost anything, but killing a kid ---- we're still not there, yet. I think that was as much of a reason why that scene had to play out like it did as anything. We both know that most anyone else in that position would've killed the kid, or the kid would've killed him with that machine gun he had in his hands.


I agree. Although I think of a movie like Platoon (on my top ten list), where the protagonist committed murder out of a fragmented ethical core. Maybe prime time TV is not the place for that. On the other hand, I think we perpetuate a false stereotype when we always portray American protagonists as above such things. That's the power of a movie like Platoon: war twists us -- yes, even Americans -- and we do, in fact, shoot children in such situations. Part of our denial about who we are and what we do and what we support is tied to how we present our myths about ourselves in entertainment media.

dolfan wrote:I found myself thinking about the kid-soldier problem a lot though. Who knows? Maybe this does something to the American mind about the thugs in Africa. IF we're going to make the world safe for democracy, it ought to be safe from child conscription at least. That's a cause worth doing some Van-Dammage over. :lol:


I hear that some "foul" liberal organizations are making deals with child conscriptors to rescue the children. A couple years ago I read a book by a boy soldier who was rescued by such an organization. He told the tale of his capture and military ventures, during which he committed many murders. He eventually came to the United States and went to college at Columbia University. The name of the book was A Long Way Gone: Memoirs of a Boy Soldier, by Ishmael Beah. Well worth the read.

Posted: November 24th, 2008, 6:10 pm
by DaJudge
I loved how the UN guy was a sniveling, useless little coward. Just like real life.

Posted: November 24th, 2008, 6:51 pm
by Tim Elston
DaJudge wrote:I loved how the UN guy was a sniveling, useless little coward. Just like real life.


Are American soldiers who are assigned to UN duty sniveling, useless little cowards? What are they when they get transfered to Iraq and Afghanistan and die serving their country?

Posted: November 25th, 2008, 11:42 am
by one love
I just watched it. I have been working so much I did not know it came on. I thought it was really good major change from the usual technology etc...

I beleive Tony is supposed to come back in this one and be the bad guy from what I have seen, yet that was months and months ago.

I love it we are pulling political discussions out of a show :shock: :lol: :lol:

Yes I agree with Dajudge and No Tim it is not the Americans in the U.N but rahter the organization itself that is the problem. They do what is best for their interest and financial gain. They also seem to always lean toward Europe's opinion over everyone elses. My .02 regarding a TV show...


Curious why are we not able to assist places in Africa when these things happen? I have seen another SHOW that there was a Koo and the American president told the other president "you know why we cant help you"
I know minorities say we will not because there is no money there for us and we dont care but I am curious as to what the real reason is, anyone know??????



With that siad "JACK BAUER FOR PRESIDENT" :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol:

Tim will now say I support torture :lol: I am kidding

Posted: November 25th, 2008, 5:39 pm
by Tim Elston
one love wrote:Yes I agree with Dajudge and No Tim it is not the Americans in the U.N but rahter the organization itself that is the problem. They do what is best for their interest and financial gain. They also seem to always lean toward Europe's opinion over everyone elses. My .02 regarding a TV show...


It's fair enough to criticize the UN, but it's not fair to say that UN soldiers are useless cowards. Soldiers do what they are commanded to do. They may or may not be cowards. Few probably are. It's unfair to judge the courage of soldiers by their command orders. The character of the UN soldier on 24 was a stereotype.

By the way, America also does what is best for its own interests and financial gain. What is in America's interests is also sometimes in the interests of others, and so it is with the UN. The UN has its limitations precisely because it is an organization of member states that have competing interests. That doesn't make it useless, but it does make it weak. Besides that, yes, the UN has its own administrative corruption. Why can we see that so clearly but not see our own national faults? I wot that it is a problem of pride, arrogance, nationalism and wilfulness. Where is the self-criticism? Where is the humility? Where is the transcendence of principle for which America presumably stands?

one love wrote:Curious why are we not able to assist places in Africa when these things happen? I have seen another SHOW that there was a Koo and the American president told the other president "you know why we cant help you"
I know minorities say we will not because there is no money there for us and we dont care but I am curious as to what the real reason is, anyone know??????


It's complex. We are rightly afraid of getting mired. We know that we can't police the whole world. Leaders know that we don't have the stomach to endure too much loss if our interests aren't at stake. If our leaders take us in and things go wrong, they know that they'll be in a mess. It involves political will, resources, and practicality.

There is a wing of the Democrats that believes in humanitarian military interventionism. Obama had some of those people at his side during the campaign, but as he got closer to winning, he started moving more toward realpolitik, so some of those people quit. Republicans tend not to be militarily humanitarian interventionist. Republican and centrist Democratic policy is usually to reserve military action for national rather than humanitarian interests.

There are books about the quandary. It's not an easy problem.

Posted: November 26th, 2008, 9:37 am
by DaJudge
Tim, American soldiers are not "UN troops". While United States armed forces have on several occassions fought in conflicts that were authorized by the United Nations (Korea, Persian Gulf Wars I and II, and Somalia), our troops were never under the command of the United Nations. Our troops were have always been commanded by our own Commander in Chief and Joint Chiefs.

Posted: November 26th, 2008, 11:02 pm
by Tim Elston
DaJudge wrote:Tim, American soldiers are not "UN troops". While United States armed forces have on several occassions fought in conflicts that were authorized by the United Nations (Korea, Persian Gulf Wars I and II, and Somalia), our troops were never under the command of the United Nations. Our troops were have always been commanded by our own Commander in Chief and Joint Chiefs.


Okay, I'll have to fact check this. I thought US Army personnel had served in UN uniform, at the command of the US President. I could very well be wrong, though. It wouldn't be the first time.

Posted: November 30th, 2008, 1:41 am
by one love
It's fair enough to criticize the UN, but it's not fair to say that UN soldiers are useless cowards. Soldiers do what they are commanded to do.


I was talking about the UN itself as a organization NOT soldiers, so i can Understand.


By the way, America also does what is best for its own interests and financial gain.


Ummmm Yeah we are a nation Tim the UN is NOT. That is my point. They are not supposed to act as a nation. I expect nations to do all they can for their nation.

The UN has its limitations precisely because it is an organization of member states that have competing interests.



correct they are not meant to do what is financially best for them and do things so crooked. I agree America is not perfect but is the best nation their is and puts a ton of money in aid to other nations. The UN was never meant to be a nation type organization,

God Bless

Posted: November 30th, 2008, 9:19 am
by Tim Elston
one love wrote:Ummmm Yeah we are a nation Tim the UN is NOT. That is my point. They are not supposed to act as a nation.


Could you elaborate? What is the UN supposed to do? What is it not supposed to do?

one love wrote:I agree America is not perfect but is the best nation their is


A country can be measured against many different standards. America is the best in some things, but it is not the best in others. I wouldn't doubt that it may be worst in at least one.

one love wrote:and puts a ton of money in aid to other nations.


If I'm not mistaken, our foreign aid expenditure is among the lowest of developed nations as a percentage of GDP. We give a few mites from our abundance. If I don't think that's all that impressive, I'm in good company, if I recall correctly from Sunday School days.

Posted: December 1st, 2008, 6:48 am
by RamboPreacher
skipped all the posts, cause I don't want any spoilers. I recorded it and DVD'd it without watching it. :)

We are catching up and only just finished up season, three (I think).