Page 1 of 1

When a band member loses faith

Posted: July 24th, 2008, 7:40 am
by DeWayneTN
What do you do if you're a Christian band and a member loses their faith in God? That's an interesting question and the group Haste the Day had to deal with it. Interesting article on Christianity Today website:

http://blog.christianitytoday.com/ctliv ... ns_wh.html

Posted: July 24th, 2008, 8:00 am
by DaJudge
How do you lose your faith? I just don't understand it.

One funny bit from the article though:

Everyone who either grew up as an evangelical Christian or dated one has heard or spoken this line: "It's not you. I just want to spend more time with God."

I always thought this line was a crock, not because wanting to spend more time with God wasn't admirable, but because it was typically used as a cop-out, a way to ease the discomfort of ruining someone's junior year of high school.


I used that line with a girl from camp that I broke up with (in late July.
Boy that romance lasted a long time!). She said I was full of crap. And she was right.

Re: When a band member loses faith

Posted: July 24th, 2008, 8:52 am
by Paully_44
DeWayneTN wrote:What do you do if you're a Christian band and a member loses their faith in God?


I guess it would depend on how the persons actions were toward continuing the journey with the band. After the article, in the comments, some said

is the musician, despite his loss of faith, still willing to play the same message that the band continues to play? if so, i don't see why his remaining in the band would be harmful.

i can't help thinking of the reverse of this situation, because U2's Rattle and Hum was on TV two weeks ago. here, at a time when the only Christian in the band was Bono, i witnessed his bandmates fully supportive of his songs, rocking out, and having a great time while Bono preached the gospel singing "Pride in the Name of Love". Bono is no longer the only Christian member of U2...but look at what a little healthy respect for a friend accomplished, not only for the band members as people but for millions more.


There must be more to this than just "losing faith".

Posted: July 24th, 2008, 10:30 am
by pastorables
DaJudge wrote:
I used that line with a girl from camp that I broke up with (in late July.
Boy that romance lasted a long time!). She said I was full of crap. And she was right.


I didn't know you were still a VLB. 8)