Page 1 of 1

Entertainment Weekly: Top 25 TV/movie Scifi of Past 25 Years

Posted: January 6th, 2008, 5:24 pm
by Gerald Creasy
List HERE


If you don't want to tab throught the 25 page list here is a summary:

25: V
24 Galaxy quest
23 Doctor Who
22 Quantum Leap
21 Futurama
20 Star Wars: Clone Wars (animated Series)
19 Starship Troopers
18 Heroes
17 The Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless mind
16 Total recall
15 Firefly -Serenity
14 Children of Men
13 Terminator /Terminator II
12 Back to the Future
11 Lost
10 The Thing
09 Aliens
08 Star Trek:TNG
07 ET
06 Brazil
05 Star trek II: The Wrath of Khan
04 The X-Files
03 Blade Runner
02 Battelstar Galactica (modern version)
01 The Matrix


I'm about only half satisfied with their opinions.

I am exceedingly glad that some of my favorites cracked the top ten (Brazil, Blade Runner, Battlestar Galactica).

Personally I would have allowed Firefly-Serenity in the Top Ten at least as it is vastly under-rated and Doctor Who a bit higher as well.

Having read Neuromancer and seen Ghost in the Shell movies and series, I find that The Matrix suffers greatly-because it can be seen where it derviced it's ideas- sometimes with BLATANT thievery- and so I would not rate it as high (in fact i would also add Ghost in the Shell to the list as it is some of the best scifi I have seen in ages) How can you have Star Wars: Clone Wars and not GITS??


And say....where is Babylon 5? That should be in the top ten as well. It was literate, clever, interwoven and very senitive to Religion (where most Scifi seems absolutely anti-religion)

Posted: January 7th, 2008, 4:18 am
by DeWayneTN
Galaxy Quest? It was funny, but top 25 material?
What about the original Star Wars movies?
I have tried several times to get into Blade Runner but never have been able to.
I agree with Aliens but I know just as many people (and more critics) who adore the original Alien more.

Re: Entertainment Weekly: Top 25 TV/movie Scifi of Past 25 Y

Posted: January 7th, 2008, 4:25 am
by DaJudge
I think Quantum Leap should be much higher on the list. Top Ten at least. That was a really original and great show. I'm not a fan of the Matrix or ET, although I know I'm in the minority on that one. I actually think that Star Trek: Deep Space 9 was a superior show to The Next Generation. And Futurama? Give me a break, that show stank. I am pleased that they included Galaxy Quest. I think that movie was greatly underrated. I'm not sure what the thinking is that put on the list the Clone Wars animated series and not the original Star Wars movie or Empire Strikes Back.

Additions?

Posted: January 7th, 2008, 4:41 am
by DeWayneTN
I see that Heroes is on here but no other superhero-type shows/movies. If they were included, I'd add:

-X-Men 2
-Spider-Man 2
-Batman Begins

Time Bandits might have been a good honorable mention but they might consider that fantasy. Independence Day doesn't get a lot of love but it was a significant sci-fi movie when it came out and the last time I ever stood in a winding long line for any movie.

Posted: January 7th, 2008, 5:06 am
by Gerald Creasy
Futurama stank!? How can you dislike a show that has Star trek jokes, AND a Rampaging Robo-Nixon!?

None of the first three Star Wars movies were included because they are older than 25 years.

Posted: January 7th, 2008, 5:08 am
by DaJudge
Gerald Creasy wrote:Futurama stank!? How can you dislike a show that has Star trek jokes, AND a Rampaging Robo-Nixon!?

None of the first three Star Wars movies were included because they are older than 25 years.


Gotcha. I didn't read the article, and I missed that part in you post's Subject line.

And yes, Futurama bored me to tears. I expected better, because I'm a huge Simpsons fan, and it disappointed me.

Posted: January 7th, 2008, 5:11 am
by DeWayneTN
I missed the 25 years part, too. That would explain the omission of Alien, also.

Posted: January 7th, 2008, 8:07 am
by Sherry
I think personally, Dr. Who, Firefly-Serenity, and Quantum Leap should have been in the top ten.

Brazil?? Never even heard of that one! :roll:

Posted: January 7th, 2008, 8:13 am
by TW
IMHO Dr. Who should be number 1, it was, and is, the longest running Sci Fi series in history. That fact alone should elevate it to the prime position, period!!! :evil:


TW

Posted: January 7th, 2008, 9:15 am
by Gerald Creasy
YellowRose wrote:I think personally, Dr. Who, Firefly-Serenity, and Quantum Leap should have been in the top ten.

Brazil?? Never even heard of that one! :roll:



You really should try out Brazil. It's a Terry Gilliam movie with Jonathon Price, Robert De Niro, Katerine Helmond and Michael Palin.

A bureaucrartic dystopian 1984-ish totalitarian society in which it may be easier to employ illegal Heat & Air repair men (who operate under the cover of darkness) than to go through the insurmountable paperwork to have it done legally.

A very dark movie, strangely and sometimes sickeningly funny.

Hard to describe the plot.

Harlan Ellison calls it the finest SF movie ever made. (He also praises Doctor Who so track Brazil down and give it a shot.)

Posted: January 7th, 2008, 9:24 am
by DeWayneTN
Another thing - I would replace Starship Troopers with that director's better movie, Robocop. Also the original Predator was pretty good, too.

Posted: January 7th, 2008, 10:40 am
by DaJudge
DeWayneTN wrote:Another thing - I would replace Starship Troopers with that director's better movie, Robocop. Also the original Predator was pretty good, too.


I agree. The only thing good about Starship Troopers is the redhead who played Barbara Gordon in "Birds of Prey".

Posted: January 7th, 2008, 11:20 am
by Paully_44
DeWayneTN wrote:Also the original Predator was pretty good, too.


Great movie!