Page 1 of 23
American Idol
Posted: January 25th, 2007, 6:28 pm
by pastorables
Does anyone besides myself feel that AI is becoming almost theatrical and staged for ratings? It doesn't seem honest and down to earth as in the beginning. It just seems a little fake now.
pa
Re: American Idol
Posted: January 25th, 2007, 7:02 pm
by Paully_44
pastorables wrote:Does anyone besides myself feel that AI is becoming almost theatrical and staged for ratings? It doesn't seem honest and down to earth as in the beginning. It just seems a little fake now.
pa
it never does in the beginning. the first few shows are just a train wreck. As you notice, the majority of those put thru to Hollywood are not showcased, only those who "Think" they can sing.
Posted: January 26th, 2007, 3:46 am
by Pastor Bill
They screen them before they even get to the "judges" that we see, they'd have to, 3 celebs are not going to sit through 20,000 auditions in 2 days, it isn't going to happen. the screenings put through those that will make it on, and those that will make a good show for their lack of ability, drama, or something.
I wonder at times if there are those that are given "maybe" as an answer, and that may make up many we don't see, because they seem to always come out with 22 each day. Either than, or the screenings are what puts them through, and the "audition" is all for show in the first weeks.
Posted: January 26th, 2007, 4:45 am
by HogWild
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/15310288/
MSNBC posts a pretty good article with a inside look into the audition process. It answered some of my questions.
Posted: January 26th, 2007, 4:59 am
by Paully_44
I read that article before the season started and have watched the "auditions" from a different perspective this year.
Posted: January 26th, 2007, 5:29 am
by HogWild
Yeah, me too! It really changed my view. In fact, I'm a little aggravated that at the manipulation of the audience after reading the article. Yet, I continue to DVR it and watch it and laugh!
Posted: January 26th, 2007, 5:54 am
by jinjer
I have watched differently this year. A young man at our church auditioned in Birmingham. The guy has an amazing voice, butter melts when he sings. Anyway, he almost didn't make it through the first round!

He did audition in front of Simon and Randy, Paula wasn't there. I can't believe he didn't make it through, compared to the others I've seen.
Jinjer
Posted: January 26th, 2007, 6:23 am
by Paully_44
jinjer wrote: He did audition in front of Simon and Randy, Paula wasn't there. I can't believe he didn't make it through, compared to the others I've seen.
Jinjer
Did they give him any feedback as to why he wasn't AI material?
As for Paula, even when she is sitting in her chair she doesn't seem to be "there" this year.
Posted: January 26th, 2007, 8:21 am
by jinjer
It was very vague, like "I'm just not feeling it.." sort of thing. Spencer just really couldn't believe it.
Jinjer
By the way, Spencer is a very handsome young man.
Posted: January 26th, 2007, 8:03 pm
by pastorables
Paully_44 wrote:
I read that article before the season started and have watched the "auditions" from a different perspective this year.
Ah-hem, I didn't realize this about AI. Reckon this explains why the shows last three male winners or runners ups have been from Alabama?
pa
Posted: January 26th, 2007, 8:24 pm
by turbotim
jinjer wrote:I have watched differently this year. A young man at our church auditioned in Birmingham. The guy has an amazing voice, butter melts when he sings. Anyway, he almost didn't make it through the first round!

He did audition in front of Simon and Randy, Paula wasn't there. I can't believe he didn't make it through, compared to the others I've seen.
Jinjer
Will he be on Tuesday night?
Posted: January 26th, 2007, 9:33 pm
by crazygirl
My best friend went to the Birmingham auditions. She is a really good singer, and I'm not just saying that either. Her account was almost exactly like this other girl explains.
Except when she went down to audition, the person at the table told her to step forward and sing. So she stepped forward and got 2 words out of her mouth and the person told her okay step back. My friend said but I didn't even get to sing my song. The lady told her You're just not what we are looking for.
But yet, they were sending people back all day in costumes, she said.
That's crazy, we could be missing out on some really good singers, if they would quit putting these stupid people through.
Posted: January 27th, 2007, 3:49 am
by Shellie
I have never really watched it a whole lot, but decided this season to try and catch more since everyone and their mother (except Gerald) loves it.
After watching, I told scooter that most of those were fake. scooter pegged it. He said some people will be outrageous just to get on TV and of course they let them on because they are outrageous. He also said that he thinks the average to good singers are rooted out to make room for the outrageous so that they have a show. After reading the article it makes sense.
Posted: January 27th, 2007, 10:49 am
by jinjer
I don't know if he will be on or not. Every person that is in line has to sign the TV release. I can't remember if he said he knew he would be on or not. I'll try and ask tomorrow at church.
Jinjer
Posted: January 27th, 2007, 10:50 am
by turbotim
Shellie wrote:After watching, I told scooter that most of those were fake. scooter pegged it. He said some people will be outrageous just to get on TV and of course they let them on because they are outrageous. He also said that he thinks the average to good singers are rooted out to make room for the outrageous so that they have a show. After reading the article it makes sense.
Yeah..... If you think about it, it's really about the money. If it's funny and we do enjoy laughing at it, then they aren't hurting much. I do agree that the average to good singers are rooted out to make room for the others to get the ratings.
