Page 1 of 2
this could be trouble ... but
Posted: January 24th, 2007, 4:16 pm
by TC
we know that no team that has ever won a championship has ever really cheated.
http://sports.yahoo.com/top/news;_ylt=AtYXOdDIHQFPlnvZDHnWYTc5nYcB?slug=cr-bushtapes012407&prov=yhoo&type=lgns
there will most likely be a slap on the wrist... and Bush got special gifts and keeps his ring... the system has to be changed.
Posted: January 25th, 2007, 3:23 am
by dalebert
and the drama builds!!!

Posted: January 25th, 2007, 3:55 am
by turbotim
Well, Well, Well.
If he did it, they should reap the consequences like the rest of our schools have from the NCAA...
Posted: January 25th, 2007, 4:16 am
by Rob
If he did it, they should reap the consequences like the rest of our schools have from the NCAA...
Which is what?
Posted: January 25th, 2007, 7:36 am
by MrDanger
Probation...No Post Season Play....
Also, they were talking about it on sportstalk in Nashville this morning and said that it is stated that you can have any awards taken away, up to and including the Heisman. Notice the word can though. I don't know if they will do it or not.
Posted: January 25th, 2007, 10:25 am
by turbotim
Pastor Rob wrote:Which is what?
Whatever they hand down. What that is? I don't really know. What it should be? I don't really know. I would think they had all that in writing. What the penalty for this or that should be already established. I may be wrong.
Posted: January 25th, 2007, 10:37 am
by Rob
MrDanger wrote:Probation...No Post Season Play....
Also, they were talking about it on sportstalk in Nashville this morning and said that it is stated that you can have any awards taken away, up to and including the Heisman. Notice the word can though. I don't know if they will do it or not.
Well let's see we are talking USC here and NCAA and the man responsible for this would be the one and the only infamous Myles Brand. Who in my opinion gives a whole new definition to the world idiot.
Remember he is the one who stated that the punishment for Miami and FAU was enough that the schools and conferences did.
So IMO I will be surprised if they do anything about this.
Now what do I think should happen, if Bush is found to be guilty he should be stripped of the Heisman and ordered to repay the money or USC should suffer 5 years probation with 3 of those years being ineligible for any bowl games and a lost of 10 scholarships per year for the next 5 years. Unless we have stiff penalties for schools and players that break the rules nothing will change.
Re: this could be trouble ... but
Posted: January 25th, 2007, 11:13 am
by Paully_44
TC wrote:there will most likely be a slap on the wrist... and Bush got special gifts and keeps his ring... the system has to be changed.
That seems to be the problem for decades. I can understand punishing the school if the school knowingly cheats, but what if it is just a player?
If a coach makes recruiting violations or other infractions, he may lose his job and get hired on by another school(Slick Rick Neuhisel), If a player violates the rules, it us usually found out after the player has left school. I don't know how to fix it, but I am not holding my breath that they system will change anytime soon. I think a playoff system will be instituted and n.d will be forced to join a conference before the system is changed.
Posted: January 26th, 2007, 3:23 pm
by TC
That seems to be the problem for decades. I can understand punishing the school if the school knowingly cheats, but what if it is just a player?
Well that KNOWINGLY word is enough to get most schools out of trouble... because we didn't KNOW anything...
That can not even be used. The school has the duty to make sure the kids follow the rules. I think they should have to return all money made that year. Forfit all the games and give up title. Heisman should go to the second place guy.
what needs to be done is Pro sports need to get the players reps to put in their collective Barg agreement that anyone who is caught breaking NCAA rules they can not play on a team for 2 years. No money... If they go over seas then they still have to sit 2 years before they enter the league. ALSO any coach that is caught breaking rules in college can not coach in the pros for 3 years.
YES those are stiff, but IF you make the TIME not worth the crime ... the crime will not be an issue.
Just like the little slap troy smith got... Bush and USC will get a minor slap. The BCS and NCAA doesn't want to make football (or any sport)look bad, it is not good for their pocketbook... you let that happen at a school that is not a power.. watch the NCAA drop the hammer.
Posted: January 27th, 2007, 4:45 am
by ImaPK
TC said
what needs to be done is Pro sports need to get the players reps to put in their collective Barg agreement that anyone who is caught breaking NCAA rules they can not play on a team for 2 years. No money... If they go over seas then they still have to sit 2 years before they enter the league. ALSO any coach that is caught breaking rules in college can not coach in the pros for 3 years.
YES those are stiff, but IF you make the TIME not worth the crime ... the crime will not be an issue.
I like the way you think but it would never make it through a court challenge...college and pros are apples and oranges...I'm waiting for the first court challenge by a player in college who wants to leave after his freshman year and sues the NFL policy against drafting freshman...or the HS player who thinks he's ready for the pros and sues...the NBA has a similar rule but would either hold up in court?...as to the coaches being banned for a time, same problem, same verse...courts would have a field day...I agree that something needs to be done, but you have to look at it realistically...the NCAA and the NFL are seperate entities and as such can only punish their own...if I worked for Ford would it hold up in court if I quit there and went to work for GM and then Ford tried to fire me from GM?...won't happen, can't happen...just like the NFL has no right to "punish" for "crimes" comitted in the NCAA.
And your last statement is funny...prisons are full of people who thought they could beat the "time" when doing the crime

Posted: January 27th, 2007, 7:48 am
by TC
OK yes the prisions are full, but most people do not do crimes because they are wrong, they don't do them because of the punishment if they are caught.
here goes.
Think about it like this. I used to work for Metro EMS. You were not allowed to have a police record, In that they would not hire you or you would be fired for a police record. It was a requirement of the Job. If you had a moving violation, did not have auto insurance you could not be hired and you did you would be suspended for 90 days. AND that it not matter is your job had anything to do with your Job or not, like if you were a mechanic, dispatcher or janitor. Those were the requirements when you took the job, you accepted them or you would not be hired. IF you had one and did not tell, and you were hired and it came out then you would be fired for lying on your app. If you said you had on you would not be hired.
Pro leagues are not public businesses, In that the owners or commissioner speaks who speaks for all the owners as a group can place restrictions on the people who work for them. Like the NBA did on the attire of the players. It is a requirement of the Job. Just like Ford can require their workers to be in the union, the Leagues can require all their players to be a member of the players association. The players association (or union) can bargain for benefits for the players, it can also give to the owners/ teams. Just like the age limit, when all of the owners get together and make a rule they can enforce is, the players as a whole can have a accept it or the players strike.
All of the things I suggested can be done. I think it would be easier than the age limit. The way to do it would be to call it a morals clause. Saying that IF you were found to have broken the rules in your sport before, and it was proven then you have a problem following the rules. And the punishment could be not playing in the league for a period of time. I think there could be some problems from the players but if you made the same rules for the coaches (all of them assistants and head coaches) and you had the owners and the players associations agree, then the problem would be getting current players to agree but if you went with a 1 year amnesty (which is what they have TOTALLY NOW) then new players would not be allowed in the players association without agreeing to the rules. And they would not be allowed to play if they were not in the association (union).
The way to get them all to agree is for the NCAA to first set some of it own rules. If a coach is caught violating the rules he is banned from coaching for 2 years. That means all coaching; you can’t go to another level. Then the NCAA needs to propose ways to stop unfair advantage (cheating) In public and state the problem is when the players go to the next level there is no recourse. Basically shame the leagues to do some thing. That is what they did with age limits.
JUST another thought… Why doesn’t the NCAA sue the offending player on behalf of the school, stating that it cost them the money they will lose or have lost due to the player. Just think, Mr Bush is hit with a lawsuit for 30 mill, because he broke the rules and cost the school those wins and the money they got for the title. I really think that lawsuit would work. The school would have measurable damages. Two or three of those lawsuits would make people think twice about breaking the rules.
Posted: January 27th, 2007, 3:00 pm
by ImaPK
I agree with you up to the last sentence...in reality those who break rules do so knowingly but always think THEY are the ones who will never get caught...in reality the leagues can make all the rules they like but someone will always try to sneak by the rules...until every league enforces the same rules for the BIG and the little guy the rules don't mean squat...this past year in MLB several minor league and several "fringe players" in the majors were suspended for drug use....NOT ONE BIG NAME WAS SUSPENDED...the NFL has suspended low to mid range players but not one BIG name...same with the NBA...the owners in pros are gonna "protect" their money and the NCAA is gonna do the same...might not be right but that's the way it is

Posted: January 29th, 2007, 12:01 pm
by dolfan
The fix for the system is to pay the players. They bring a value to the big conferences and their schools far beyond the cost of their scholarships, yet they're limited to life as paupers on paper. I think it is time to make the rules conform to the reality. Give these guys a decent slice of the pie they're creating for these schools. That opens up way more problems than solutions, but it solves the one about schools and eligbility and sanctions regarding agents and money.
Posted: January 30th, 2007, 5:45 pm
by turbotim
dolfan wrote:The fix for the system is to pay the players. They bring a value to the big conferences and their schools far beyond the cost of their scholarships, yet they're limited to life as paupers on paper.
How do you decide how much they get paid? Just curious...
Posted: January 31st, 2007, 5:59 am
by dolfan
I don't know, but people who make those decisions in every other market manage to work it out. It wouldn't be pretty, but it can be done.