Page 1 of 2
Does Bama get there man?
Posted: January 3rd, 2007, 6:30 am
by Rob
ESPN is now reporting that Nick Saban has agreed to take the Alabama job. Dolfan what are your thoughts now.
Mountie12, you'll have another Marion County guy there in Tuscaloosa.
Posted: January 3rd, 2007, 10:27 am
by Mountie12
Rob,
I bet all those die hard Bama fans are loving the fact that RR turned them down. I hate to see the Dolphins lose Nick, but after his choice of Culpepper over Brees, I'm not sure he was the man for the job.
Bama football is filled with lunatics. Saban is going to have to be as hard as rock if he survives. Aaron and I were walking through University Mall the other day and we came face to face with Mark Gotfried (Bama b'ball coach, I guess that's how you spell his name). He was just hanging out waiting for his wife to come out of a store. Nobody was talking to him and as busy as the mall was he was basically ignored. I got by him so fast it took me a second to realize who he was. He sat down in a chair in the mall and I saw him wave to someone, but for the most part people just ignored him. All I could think of was - "Only in Alabama can a major University coach with a top 5 NCAA basketball program be ignored in a public facility." No one asking for autographs or talking to him because he's a celebrity. Last year he had to make an urgent plea to the fans to attend the games. B'ball attendance is sad in comparison to other top ten programs.
I'm a die-hard WVU fan whether it's football, b'ball, lacross or spitball fighting. Go Eers! In Alabama it's football or nothing.
Posted: January 3rd, 2007, 10:39 am
by Rob
Mountie,
I'm not sure that Nick was ever suited for the pro game. I think he regrets leaving LSU, especially seeing what they are doing now. However, I do believe that Nick will have 'Bama back on the college football map in a few years. Of course, if the cupboard is not as bear as everyone says, it may not take him long at all.
Posted: January 3rd, 2007, 11:39 am
by Mountie12
I'm not sure that Nick was ever suited for the pro game. I think he regrets leaving LSU, especially seeing what they are doing now. However, I do believe that Nick will have 'Bama back on the college football map in a few years. Of course, if the cupboard is not as bear as everyone says, it may not take him long at all.
Nick will have a full compliment of players, schollies and recruits (even the wafflers will jump on board now) at his disposal. Shula did not leave the cupboard bare. He will have immediate success.
The first thing I would do is look for another QB. I know Bama fans are in love with Wilson, but after watching his performance in the bowl game I am firmly convinced he is a second-string QB. This guy makes some bonehead passes that stops the productivity of the offense. Nick had some athletic QB's at LSU.
Posted: January 3rd, 2007, 4:41 pm
by Mole_J
A lot of college coaches can not make the jump into the NFL. Not sure why, but there is a whole list of college coaches that went to the NFL and a few years later end back up coaching to college.
Posted: January 3rd, 2007, 4:55 pm
by Rob
Mole_J wrote:A lot of college coaches can not make the jump into the NFL. Not sure why, but there is a whole list of college coaches that went to the NFL and a few years later end back up coaching to college.
Let's see I can remember Lou Holtz, Dennis Erickson, and now Nick Saban. But who else?
Posted: January 3rd, 2007, 5:47 pm
by Mountie12
Let's see - Jimmy Johnson (Miami) - success; Bill Walsh (Stanford) - success; Vince Lombardi (asst. coach at Army) - success
Actually the ratio for success/failure with college coaches may be 50-50. There are a lot of factors that lead to coaching success. In this day and time NFL players are less controllable than in days gone by. College football is much closer to the purist aspect of the original game than pro football is.
Posted: January 3rd, 2007, 6:06 pm
by turbotim
Did you hear what Don Shula said when asked what he thought about Saban leaving?
as reported by ESPN...
Don Shula wrote:I don't think that will be any great loss.

Wow....

Posted: January 4th, 2007, 4:00 am
by Rob
Jimmy Johnson (Miami) - success; Bill Walsh (Stanford) - success; Vince Lombardi (asst. coach at Army) - success
But I don't think any of those coaches returned to the college game after the pro game did they?
Posted: January 4th, 2007, 4:41 am
by Paully_44
The media, at least here on the West coast, is sure painting this guy up to be a man who lies. Basing this on just a week prior to being let go at Miami, stating he had no intention of taking the Alabama job.
Do you think that is fair?
Posted: January 4th, 2007, 5:26 am
by Mountie12
But I don't think any of those coaches returned to the college game after the pro game did they?
The didn't have to go back because they were very successful. That was my point. In recent years guys like Butch Davis and Steve Spurrier stunk up the place, but that wasn't always the case with college coaches going pro.
The media, at least here on the West coast, is sure painting this guy up to be a man who lies. Basing this on just a week prior to being let go at Miami, stating he had no intention of taking the Alabama job.
Do you think that is fair?
Let's see - he definitively said, "IWill Not Be the Next Coach At Alabama." Denied it for several weeks and now he's the new coach at -of all places - ALABAMA.
Sounds to me like he lied. Now I know the modern day twist is that he just "
changed his mind." But, a contract should still be binding and your word should still be your bond. I know that the teams can fire a coach on the spot, but that's the purpose of a contract. You coach the team and fulfill your resposibilities and if you don't do a good job, you get fired and draw a tremendous buy-out package.
Saban did not honor his commitment. Doesn't matter that Huizenga gave him an out, he was not a man of his word - which means He Lied.
Posted: January 4th, 2007, 5:52 am
by pastorjason
which is why the scripture speaks of us not knowing the future so that we should not speak in absolutes.
He said X and therefore if the situation changes he should honor words spoken before all of the facts are in?
Yep he said it and since he did take the job he lied. I have a hard time judging the man who made what I think was a very good choice for his family
That being said I am really biased cause I had him picked from the beginning.
Roll Tide!!!! anyway I think he will be there at least the term of this contract and maybe longer but it's only football and after all he's from WV and you know you really can't trust those guys

Posted: January 4th, 2007, 7:33 am
by Mountie12
Yep he said it and since he did take the job he lied. I have a hard time judging the man who made what I think was a very good choice for his family
That being said I am really biased cause I had him picked from the beginning.
Roll Tide!!!! anyway I think he will be there at least the term of this contract and maybe longer but it's only football and after all he's from WV and you know you really can't trust those guys
The choice for his family is extremely obvious. Miama or Tuscaloosa, which is a safer, cleaner environment? Easy choice.
Being raised by a Marion County, WV woman I can tell you exactly how it all went down. Nick had every intention of making the Miami situation wok. His ego would not let him back away and accept defeat. When Bama came a callin', Nick went home to talk it over with momma (wife). Momma basically said, (
WV vernacular) "
You can keep your sorry butt here in S. Florida if you want to, but the kids and I are headed to Tuscaloosa." Nick ducked his head, tucked his tail between his legs and boldly announced, "
I've changed my mind."
Did you notice who Mal Moore introduced first at the press conference -MRS. SABAN. Nick sat there with his head drooped and dutifully stood and applauded her at the appropriate time. Face it Bama, Terri Saban will be a good coach for you guys, Nick is just the front man.
You may not be able to trust WV guys, but WV women will kick your butts and make you live right.

If you don't believe me ask Pastor Rob.
Posted: January 4th, 2007, 11:01 am
by pastorjason
you don't have to convince me I have been there
She will fit in well with the other Bama wives
Jason
Posted: January 4th, 2007, 11:20 am
by MrDanger
I can't believe all of the Bama people are so high on him after he pulled a Francone (sp?) by not showing up at Miami's press conference and not telling the players goodbye after telling them he wasn't leaving for weeks. A little hypocritical don't you think?
As far as being good for Bama, this was a great pick and I can't wait to see the three way battle between Bama, Auburn, and LSU for the west. It means Georgia, UT, and Florida better be on the ball (literally) when they go to the SEC Championship game. I gotta say, with the resurgence of South Carolina (they are getting better) and Kentucky and Vandy improving, the SEC is becoming an incredible place to watch football week in and week out.
I don't know about you, but I'm getting psyched for Football Time in Tennessee again.
