Page 1 of 2
With College Football almost over.....
Posted: January 2nd, 2007, 5:25 pm
by Rob
I would like to see a couple of rule changes made before next year.
#1 On a change of possession, when ball is ready for play don't start the clock. That has been a terrible rule.
#2 Get rid of instant replay. They can't get it right in the review booth any more than on the field. They cost Oklahoma the game at Oregon, and in the first half of the Orange Bowl they missed one. Get rid of it.
Any thoughts?
Posted: January 2nd, 2007, 5:46 pm
by Rob
Now they miss one in the second half against Louisville GET RID OF REPLAY!!!
Posted: January 2nd, 2007, 5:59 pm
by Rob
Now they get one right. 1 out of 3 not bad
Posted: January 2nd, 2007, 6:31 pm
by turbotim
Posted: January 3rd, 2007, 2:30 am
by dalebert
#1 On a change of possession, when ball is ready for play don't start the clock. That has been a terrible rule.
I like this rule, i think it makes the game move a little faster!#2 Get rid of instant replay. They can't get it right in the review booth any more than on the field.
I'm not sure how i really feel about this yet. I still have mixed feelings! I like instance replay but not sure how it plays in college FT yet.......
Posted: January 3rd, 2007, 2:31 am
by dalebert
dalebert wrote:#1 On a change of possession, when ball is ready for play don't start the clock. That has been a terrible rule.
I like this rule, i think it makes the game move a little faster!#2 Get rid of instant replay. They can't get it right in the review booth any more than on the field.
I'm not sure how i really feel about this yet. I still have mixed feelings! I like instance replay but not sure how it plays in college FT yet.......
Posted: January 3rd, 2007, 2:57 pm
by TC
and in the first half of the Orange Bowl they missed one
So did that cost wake the game? what about the face guarding with mario on the 50+ yard pass in the end zone.
On the replays of turnovers, even if I disagreed with the original call, they were all upheld and mainly due to the fact that the call was too close to overturn. and Could have gone either way. NOW the face guarding was just a blown call.
I think over all replay is good but the refs need to be confident and make a call and then the replay guy needs to be just as confident. Limit the replay to 2 mins. IF he can no make a decision in less than two mins then there is NO way it is undesputable evidence to over turn the call.
OFF coaches hate the new clock rules... While Def coaches love it. It takes too many plays out of the game. Yes it does make teams play with the clock but I hate it when a team has the ball with 5 mins and runs and delays to make that the whole game. AT LEAST if you stop the clock it makes that run it out a little harder.
Posted: January 3rd, 2007, 4:51 pm
by Rob
NOW the face guarding was just a blown call
Tony, you obviously you don't know the rules. Face guarding is legal in High School and College, it's only illegal in the pros. As a matter of fact you can bump beyond 5 yards in High School and College as long as the ball is not in the air!.
So Tony, wrong again, not a blown call.
Posted: January 3rd, 2007, 4:52 pm
by Rob
Just got in from church, and turned on the Sugar Bowl to see review blew it again. LSU intercepted the ball, it never touched the ground. GET RID OF INSTANT REPLAY. They can't get it right.
Posted: January 3rd, 2007, 5:51 pm
by turbotim
Well, I'm glad instant replayed showed the ND did not have possession of that ball when he went out of bounds. LSU ball..... I understand what you are saying, and I know that instant replay has some problems. But it does help at times.... The result was 24-14 instead of a possible 21-21... lol
Posted: January 4th, 2007, 4:49 am
by TC
face guarding is what he was doing... the flag would be for PI. he has to at least make an attempt for the ball, which he could not do unless he turns and sees where the ball is. yes you can bump within 5 yards and as long as ball is not in the air... not the case here about a 50 yard pass bumping was in the end zone and ball almost to receiver.
again face guarding what he was doing, flag should be on Pass Interference
Posted: January 4th, 2007, 4:59 am
by TC
let me get this strange ...refs made a call and blew the call. replay ref comfirmed call on field. (in orange bowl no call overturned). so the replay got it wrong. so get rid of replay...
by that logic we need to get rid of the refs as well, since (according to you) they got it wrong to begin with
Posted: January 4th, 2007, 11:41 am
by Rob
TC wrote:face guarding is what he was doing... the flag would be for PI. he has to at least make an attempt for the ball, which he could not do unless he turns and sees where the ball is. yes you can bump within 5 yards and as long as ball is not in the air... not the case here about a 50 yard pass bumping was in the end zone and ball almost to receiver.
again face guarding what he was doing, flag should be on Pass Interference
You can face guard with out touching the receiver. Therefore it cannot be Pass Interference. If he touches him it is Pass Interference, but if he face guards, it means he has not touched him, no foul. So it was the right call.
Posted: January 4th, 2007, 11:46 am
by Rob
TC wrote:let me get this strange ...refs made a call and blew the call. replay ref comfirmed call on field. (in orange bowl no call overturned). so the replay got it wrong. so get rid of replay...
by that logic we need to get rid of the refs as well, since (according to you) they got it wrong to begin with
Tony, if the first half of the UL/WF game, the running back's knee was down, ball came out. On the field it was called a fumble. Replay should have reversed the call. Have no problem with officials calling the fumble, it happens so fast, you have to make the call. However, replay, which has the opportunity to slow the play down still got it wrong and gave the ball to UL.
Same thing happened in the second have. #7 receiver for UL was down, ball came out the officials called fumble on the field and gave ball to WF. Again, I have no problem with the call on the field, I have a problem with replay they should have reversed the call. He was down, ball came out it's not a fumble.
Get rid of replay. The officials call the game the way they see it. I have no problem with that. I have a problem when they review the call, and stick with the call on the field when replay shows that it should be reversed. That's what I'm saying.
Posted: January 4th, 2007, 11:55 am
by TC
Pastor Rob wrote:TC wrote:face guarding is what he was doing... the flag would be for PI. he has to at least make an attempt for the ball, which he could not do unless he turns and sees where the ball is. yes you can bump within 5 yards and as long as ball is not in the air... not the case here about a 50 yard pass bumping was in the end zone and ball almost to receiver.
again face guarding what he was doing, flag should be on Pass Interference
You can face guard with out touching the receiver. Therefore it cannot be Pass Interference. If he touches him it is Pass Interference, but if he face guards, it means he has not touched him, no foul. So it was the right call.
He was face guarding the receiver, when the receiver went up for the ball, HE TOUCHED HIM... IT was Pass Interference. i have it on DVR if you want to see it...
Yes it was a bad call, did it hurt YEP, cost the game ...in the end NO.. but it did change the game.