Page 1 of 1
OK ROB...
Posted: December 2nd, 2006, 7:27 pm
by TC
good call or bad,
near the end of first half, wvu player gets pass catches it two feet inbounds and is knocked out of bounds... Clock was restarted after ball was set. With that WVU lost almost 30 seconds and stopped any chance of more points... Was not called, (from what I read on WVU board... ) it was stated that was not a reviewable call so would/ could that have been a call that cost them the game and allowed them to have to go to OT to win the game?
To me a bad call, WVU should have had the time kick or run another play..
Re: OK ROB...
Posted: December 3rd, 2006, 4:07 am
by Rob
TC wrote:good call or bad,
near the end of first half, wvu player gets pass catches it two feet inbounds and is knocked out of bounds... Clock was restarted after ball was set. With that WVU lost almost 30 seconds and stopped any chance of more points... Was not called, (from what I read on WVU board... ) it was stated that was not a reviewable call so would/ could that have been a call that cost them the game and allowed them to have to go to OT to win the game?
To me a bad call, WVU should have had the time kick or run another play..
Tony, If I remember the call your talking about, the offical gave him forward progess inbounds. So, chains are moved, ball is set ready to play, clock starts. Good call.
Posted: December 3rd, 2006, 11:10 am
by TC
You must be thinking of a different play. It had nothing to do with forward progress. It was a pass, the replay was checked to see it he had both feet in bounds when he caught the pass. He was never stopped in his forward progress, it was a pass. He took two steps and was pushed out of bounds...
THAT was a completed pass. rec went out of bounds. clock was stopped when they were setting the ball but then started with the play clock... It was either a mistake on the time keepers part or the refs.
Posted: December 3rd, 2006, 11:15 am
by Rob
TC wrote:THAT was a completed pass. rec went out of bounds. clock was stopped when they were setting the ball but then started with the play clock... It was either a mistake on the time keepers part or the refs.
Play clock should have started.
Posted: December 3rd, 2006, 11:22 am
by TC
Pastor Rob wrote:TC wrote:THAT was a completed pass. rec went out of bounds. clock was stopped when they were setting the ball but then started with the play clock... It was either a mistake on the time keepers part or the refs.
Play clock should have started.
OK miswrote that...clock was stopped when they were setting the ball the but then they started the play clock AND THE GAME CLOCK.
Yes the play clock should have started but the play went out of bounds, that stopped the game clock.
IF it has been at the end of the game it might have been a bigger deal but WVU had a good shot at scoring points had they had the time on the clock.
Posted: December 4th, 2006, 3:35 am
by Rob
Tony,
I'm sorry, but I have tried to recall the play your having reference to and can not. With that thought in mind, it must have not as been a big of deal to me as it has been to you.
Posted: December 4th, 2006, 12:25 pm
by TC
It is (was) not that big of a deal to me, but I saw it as well as a few WVU fans that were at the house I was watching the game with. I saw it and never said a word, the TV came back from break and showed a replay then the others noticed...It came to mind because I wanted to know what YOU thought about it.