Page 1 of 2
BCS Screw-up
Posted: November 30th, 2006, 11:10 am
by Rob
While I know BSC bids will not be out till Sunday rumor has it that LSU will play in the Rose Bowl.
Those of you that know the BCS better than I do please explain to me, how a team, in this case LSU is going to get to play in the Rose Bowl, when they couldn't even play in the Championship Game of their own conference?
Not only that how in the world does Boise St. get to play in the Fiesta Bowl?
If we are going to keep the BCS, which I wish we wouldn't, then my suggestion is that if a conference is to be considered to play in the BCS, that conference must have a conference Championship, and unless you play in that game you cannot be considered for a BCS bid.
IMaPK, I feel your pain, I want a playoff. PLEASEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
Posted: November 30th, 2006, 11:49 am
by Paully_44
This thread was started twice. I deleted the second thread as it looked identical.
Re: BCS Screw-up
Posted: November 30th, 2006, 12:03 pm
by Paully_44
Pastor Rob wrote:While I know BSC bids will not be out till Sunday rumor has it that LSU will play in the Rose Bowl.
CNNSI is reporting it also.
Pastor Rob wrote:Those of you that know the BCS better than I do please explain to me, how a team, in this case LSU is going to get to play in the Rose Bowl, when they couldn't even play in the Championship Game of their own conference?
Excellent question. Do they travel well, get alot of supporters and Alumi at their bowl games?
Pastor Rob wrote:Not only that how in the world does Boise St. get to play in the Fiesta Bowl?
they are 12-0 and ranked 10 in the AP poll.
Pastor Rob wrote:If we are going to keep the BCS, which I wish we wouldn't, then my suggestion is that if a conference is to be considered to play in the BCS, that conference must have a conference Championship, and unless you play in that game you cannot be considered for a BCS bid.
IMaPK, I feel your pain, I want a playoff. PLEASEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
I don't think the powers that be are considering doing away with the BCS. It seems to work, in their twisted minds. I like the controversy, the junk. Every year I hope for either 3-5 undefeated teams or many 1 loss teams just so it messes with their systems and keeps the controversy alive.
Here is
ESPN's bowl predictions.
As for a playoff, it will never work. Just look at all the controversy and missed classes, poor grades that surround the
Division-II schools. They prove every year that a playoff system just wont work.

Posted: November 30th, 2006, 4:59 pm
by ImaPK
Paully said
As for a playoff, it will never work. Just look at all the controversy and missed classes, poor grades that surround the Division-II schools. They prove every year that a playoff system just wont work.
That cup don't hold water

...if that's true then Div I would have to do away with March Madness and the CWS...every sport in Div I has a playoff EXCEPT football...and for some unknown reason the other sports have a higher graduation rate WITH A PLAYOFF then football does WITHOUT...football plays 12 games a year...basketball 28-30 a year...baseball 45-55 a year...like I said that cup don't hold water

Posted: November 30th, 2006, 5:02 pm
by ImaPK
And Pastor Rob, Boise State gets to play in Arizona because of the rule change that states that any NON-BCS Conference team who finishes in the top 12 of the BCS gets to play in a BCS Bowl
Posted: November 30th, 2006, 5:45 pm
by doilooklost
Well, I was waiting Till after Sunday to post this but
University of Houston- Liberty bowl
Rice- New Orleans bowl
I know not that big a deal except here, But these two teams played by the rules set up and for the first in a long time are going to a bowl. 42yrs for Rice and these 2 school do not have a big following.
Re: BCS Screw-up
Posted: December 1st, 2006, 4:36 am
by dolfan
Paully_44 wrote: As for a playoff, it will never work. Just look at all the controversy and missed classes, poor grades that surround the
Division-II schools. They prove every year that a playoff system just wont work.

And, my alma mater, the University of North Alabama, D-II champs 1992, 1993 and 1994, play in tomorrow's semifinal, and if they win, they will host the championship game next Saturday. D-II championships have all been played in Florence, AL for, like 10 years. Go Lions!!
Posted: December 1st, 2006, 4:38 am
by dolfan
doilooklost wrote:Well, I was waiting Till after Sunday to post this but
University of Houston- Liberty bowl
Rice- New Orleans bowl
I know not that big a deal except here, But these two teams played by the rules set up and for the first in a long time are going to a bowl. 42yrs for rice and these 2 school do not have a big following.
I didn't know Rice had made a bowl game. That's great! I'm happy for them. Smallest school in Division 1A, smaller than some D-2 schools. Glad for the Owls.
Posted: December 1st, 2006, 5:39 am
by Rob
ImaPK wrote:And Pastor Rob, Boise State gets to play in Arizona because of the rule change that states that any NON-BCS Conference team who finishes in the top 12 of the BCS gets to play in a BCS Bowl
I know what the rule says, but come on, does anyone here think Boise has a chance against OK or Neb?
Besides that, who wants to see OK or Neb play them in the Fiesta Bowl? I don't! If Boise deserves to go to a bowl, fine, but not a BCS bowl.
Posted: December 1st, 2006, 5:41 am
by Rob
Paully44,
I think it is a down right shame that LSU is playing in a BCS bowl and didn't win their division, nor play in the Conference Championship game. That STINKS!
Posted: December 1st, 2006, 6:18 am
by Paully_44
Pastor Rob wrote:Paully44,
I think it is a down right shame that LSU is playing in a BCS bowl and didn't win their division, nor play in the Conference Championship game. That STINKS!
You're right it does stink, I don't agree with it either, but I don't think this is the first time a team that hasn't won its conference has played in a BCS game. The joys of bowl season.

Posted: December 2nd, 2006, 6:25 am
by ImaPK
Pastor Rob wrote:ImaPK wrote:And Pastor Rob, Boise State gets to play in Arizona because of the rule change that states that any NON-BCS Conference team who finishes in the top 12 of the BCS gets to play in a BCS Bowl
I know what the rule says, but come on, does anyone here think Boise has a chance against OK or Neb?
Besides that, who wants to see OK or Neb play them in the Fiesta Bowl? I don't! If Boise deserves to go to a bowl, fine, but not a BCS bowl.
They have as good a chance of beating OK or Neb as, say, Louisville or WVU does

Posted: December 3rd, 2006, 4:22 am
by Rob
ImaPK wrote:They have as good a chance of beating OK or Neb as, say, Louisville or WVU does

Are you crazy? If I was a betting man, I'd bet you the mortgage Boise gets killed by Oklahoma. I'd don't know how many points Boise will be getting, but I'd even give you the points, not just an outright win.
Boise deserves to stay at home and play on the smurf blue turf, not in a BCS bowl. Those bowls should match not only conference champs, but the best of the rest, and Boise is not in the best of the rest.
Posted: December 3rd, 2006, 7:24 am
by ImaPK
Pastor Rob said
Those bowls should match not only conference champs, but the best of the rest, and Boise is not in the best of the rest.

Let's see now

...Boise State IS THE WAC CONFERENCE CHAMPION....I'm not saying that Boise State can beat OK or NEB...I said they have as good a chance as UL or WVU because I don't think either of those could beat OK or NEB either

Posted: December 3rd, 2006, 11:06 am
by Rob
ImaPK wrote:Pastor Rob said
Those bowls should match not only conference champs, but the best of the rest, and Boise is not in the best of the rest.

Let's see now

...Boise State IS THE WAC CONFERENCE CHAMPION....I'm not saying that Boise State can beat OK or NEB...I said they have as good a chance as UL or WVU because I don't think either of those could beat OK or NEB either

Okay you have convinced me you are crazy. After we agree on the OSU/Florida game, and now you think that Boise has just a good a chance as WVU/UL at beating OK. Allow me to remind you a few years ago, when WVU went to Norman, when Jeff Hosteler was the QB for the Mountaineers and beat OK and Switzer, one's one of the big wins that put WVU on the map.
The WAC is like the MAC, or any other Mid-Major. While the BE may not be as power top to bottom as the SEC or Big Ten, we are just as good as the ACC and to prove it, WVU get's Georgia Tech in the Gator Bowl and will win, and UL get's Wake in the Orange Bowl, and while I hope Wake win's (because I hate UL) UL will win and make the BE 2-0 against the ACC. I'm telling you Boise St
CAN NOT NOR WILL NOT beat the sooners.