Page 1 of 3
Rematch?
Posted: November 19th, 2006, 4:02 am
by Rob
Don't know how many of you seen the OSU/MI game. Talk has already begun about a possible rematch between OSU/MI in the NC game.
What is your take? Should OSU/MI have a rematch, netural field for BSC NC?
Posted: November 19th, 2006, 11:21 am
by rough_rider
That was a great game, YES! a rematch a is in order...

Posted: November 19th, 2006, 12:56 pm
by rough_rider
Bowl Champ. Series
1. Ohio State
2. Michigan
Guess the rematch is on

Re: Rematch?
Posted: November 19th, 2006, 2:49 pm
by Paully_44
Maybe it is because I am a fan of neither team. I don't really think that Michigan should have remained at #2. Oh well. Guess that is just another feather in the BCS hat. What better way to make even more money on the championship game? after all that is what matters most.
RE: Rematch
Posted: November 19th, 2006, 3:10 pm
by HogWild
Urban Meyer, coach of Florida, had this to say about a rematch...
Florida coach Urban Meyer said Sunday a rematch between Michigan and Ohio State would be cause for immediate change to the BCS.
“If that does happen, all the (university) presidents need to get together immediately and put together a playoff system,” he said. “I mean like now, January or whenever to get that done.”
Let the fun begin! It's been said by others a whole lot smarter than I am: If the SEC gets stiffed again this year (or feels like they do) they will raise a fuss until something changes...
Posted: November 19th, 2006, 4:11 pm
by TW
REMATCH???
I would hope not! And if the BCS is dumb enough to rematch them, they should require that somebody brings their defense. 800 yards of offense tells me the defenses weren't there. Net yards of offense - OSU 403, Mich. 397.
TW
Posted: November 19th, 2006, 5:54 pm
by Paully_44
TW wrote:REMATCH???
I would hope not! And if the BCS is dumb enough to rematch them, they should require that somebody brings their defense. 800 yards of offense tells me the defenses weren't there. Net yards of offense - OSU 403, Mich. 397.
TW
You know, that was the first complete game I had watched that had either team, and I kept thinking the same thing... where is the D?
Either the offenses were so good at exploiting the other teams Defense, or the Defense on both sides of the ball was having a real bad day.
Posted: November 19th, 2006, 6:18 pm
by TC
After the UofL/WVU game all we heard was that neither team had a D... "just look at that score" YET the OSU/MI game had more points scored.
It just goes to show the double standard when it comes to some teams. Yes I thought is was a good game... but and "instant classic"? it was a game that got a ton of hype, and it was two teams that could not stop the other.
Posted: November 20th, 2006, 3:57 am
by dalebert
It just goes to show the double standard when it comes to some teams
I guess im not sure what u mean by this. But anyway, yes it was a high scoring game and yes it does look on paper that the "D" was missing on both sides but why cant a high power offense that both OSU & Michigan have over power each other "D"? After all UofM had the best "d" against the run in the country with an avg of 29 rushng yrds per game yet because of great coaching by OSU and game planning they rushed for almost 200 yrds. Cant u give the coaching staff and the players credit for coaching, game planning and executing plays well enough to out do the "D"? And Michigan had a well coached and player execution of plays that would made a great "D" look bad. I would say the same about the UofL/WVa game too! What if the score was 3-0? Would u say that the offense didnt show up?
it was a game that got a ton of hype, and it was two teams that could not stop the other.
Sure it got tons of type as would any other two teams that were #1& #2 from the same conf playing each other in the last game of the season with a NC riding on the line! Its all about sports and yes money! Its great to be in the USA!
Posted: November 20th, 2006, 4:17 am
by Rob
dalebert wrote:It just goes to show the double standard when it comes to some teams
I guess im not sure what u mean by this. But anyway, yes it was a high scoring game and yes it does look on paper that the "D" was missing on both sides but why cant a high power offense that both OSU & Michigan have over power each other "D"? After all UofM had the best "d" against the run in the country with an avg of 29 rushng yrds per game yet because of great coaching by OSU and game planning they rushed for almost 200 yrds. Cant u give the coaching staff and the players credit for coaching, game planning and executing plays well enough to out do the "D"? And Michigan had a well coached and player execution of plays that would made a great "D" look bad. I would say the same about the UofL/WVa game too! What if the score was 3-0? Would u say that the offense didnt show up?
it was a game that got a ton of hype, and it was two teams that could not stop the other.
Sure it got tons of type as would any other two teams that were #1& #2 from the same conf playing each other in the last game of the season with a NC riding on the line! Its all about sports and yes money! Its great to be in the USA!
Dalebert, I would never claim to speak for TC, but there has been a double standard all year long. That double standard being that the BE was a lesser conference than the Big 10, SEC and others.
However, UL offense which has a tremendous QB and a decent running game even without Bush was totally shut down by Rutgers in the last 3 quarters of that game. (Man talking about being on some serious drugs, I'm defending UL, take notice of this TC).
So yes, a good defense can stop a good offense. Beside, pray tell me who MI has played that has had a running game all year? I'll sit and wait on that answer.
If WVU had played MI, Slaton would have had a field day, and I dare say Slaton and White would run all over OSU after watching Hart run over them.
Was it a good game? If you like an offense showcase yes, but to decide a championship, no. One of the best championship games was a few years ago when OSU beat Miami when a kid by the name of Clarett was a freshman and the game went into overtime.
Posted: November 20th, 2006, 4:23 am
by Rob
Since I started this, let me give my $.02 worth on it. If there is a rematch then once again the BCS will turn into the B_!! Amazing how it has managed to do that the last few years.
How come no one has mentioned that OSU had 3 turnovers which resulted in 10 MI points. With those 10 points coming on a short field? In other words OSU kept MI in the game.
MI has not won their conference championship how in the world should they get to play for a NC?
If, USC wins out that is beating ND and UCLA it will be OSU/USC.
However, if Arkansas beats LSU, and Florida beats Arkansas in the SEC championship game, I would sure hate to see Florida no make the NC game. If Arkansas wins out, and USC wins out, then USC would have to be in the NC.
Either way, IMaPK we need a playoff!!! 8 teams and lets get it on.
My $.02
Posted: November 20th, 2006, 5:25 am
by dolfan
I was a little surprised to see Mich. at #2 on the BCS still. On Friday, I told a guy, "What if Michigan loses? They'll still be a one-loss team, and if they keep it close against OSU, will the BCS keep them at #2?" I answered my own question: "No way." Well, I was wrong. To me, you have to put Florida or USC at #2 by season's end, depending on which one of those teams wins out. If Florida wins out, they should be the #2 team. If USC wins out, they should be the #2 if UF loses. Arkansas should be #2 if it wins out and USC loses, but not otherwise since USC killed them in the opener, handing Ark. its only loss. Since the Big Ten has no championship game, I don't think Michigan should remain #2 at season's end. #2 has to be, in my opinion, Florida, S. Cal or Arkansas, in that order.
Posted: November 20th, 2006, 9:22 am
by dalebert
PR i had it all written out and was distracted and lost it all!!
So i will respond later......

Posted: November 23rd, 2006, 4:04 am
by ImaPK
Ok I'm going to say this nice and slooooooow so that if the most anti-playoff proponents can understand....LOOK....AT....THIS....MESS....OSU and Boise State undefeated and several teams with one loss...arguing over the BE being a weak conference...Boise State in the WAC with possible 3-4 teams from that conference going to a Bowl game being weak...should MI get a rematch...should USC get the chance...should Florida get the chance...should Arkansas get the chance...should ND get the chance...so many scenarios...let's see....USC has to win out to deserve a shot...Florida has to beat Arkansas in the SEC CG to get a shot...Arkansas has to beat Florida in the SEC CG and hope that USC loses to ND to have a shot...ND wins out and deserves a shot ....MI sits and waits for USC to beat ND and then lose to UCLA and hopes that FL-AR play a low scoring close game to deserve a rematch...just a few weeks ago several of you were clamoring about if UofL won out they deserved to play for the NC against OSU...people if you ain't gonna give Boise State the same support as an undefeated team from a "weak" conference(and yes the BE ain't in the same league with the Big 10, Pac 10, SEC, Big 12)then we might as well scrap the BCS and go back to the "old paths" and use the AP and UPI polls to determine the NC....THEY NEED A PLAYOFF
Posted: November 24th, 2006, 3:01 pm
by Rob
ImaPK wrote:Ok I'm going to say this nice and slooooooow so that if the most anti-playoff proponents can understand....LOOK....AT....THIS....MESS....OSU and Boise State undefeated and several teams with one loss...arguing over the BE being a weak conference...Boise State in the WAC with possible 3-4 teams from that conference going to a Bowl game being weak...should MI get a rematch...should USC get the chance...should Florida get the chance...should Arkansas get the chance...should ND get the chance...so many scenarios...let's see....USC has to win out to deserve a shot...Florida has to beat Arkansas in the SEC CG to get a shot...Arkansas has to beat Florida in the SEC CG and hope that USC loses to ND to have a shot...ND wins out and deserves a shot ....MI sits and waits for USC to beat ND and then lose to UCLA and hopes that FL-AR play a low scoring close game to deserve a rematch...just a few weeks ago several of you were clamoring about if UofL won out they deserved to play for the NC against OSU...people if you ain't gonna give Boise State the same support as an undefeated team from a "weak" conference(and yes the BE ain't in the same league with the Big 10, Pac 10, SEC, Big 12)then we might as well scrap the BCS and go back to the "old paths" and use the AP and UPI polls to determine the NC....THEY NEED A PLAYOFF
IMaPK, Are you off your marbles? Or has old-age really set in? I mean AP & UPI that is showing your age man.
While the BE may not be as strong as the SEC, Big Ten, I do believe we are as strong as the Big XII and Pac-10 but there is no way the WAC which Boise St. plays in is as strong as the MAC!!! Put the BE in the conference and even Syracuse goes undefeated!