Moderators: Pastor Gary, The J2 Mod Squad
ImaPK wrote:Simple solution for a playoff(and the bowl games $$$)there are what,like 30 bowl games now?...keep the top bowls the way it is now and use the minor bowls for playoff sites...rotate the NC like they do now with the big bowls(rotate NC game) and use the other big bowls for semi-finals each year...we have a playoff and the bowls still make money...but then that would be too simple
Pastor Rob wrote:ImaPK wrote:Simple solution for a playoff(and the bowl games $$$)there are what,like 30 bowl games now?...keep the top bowls the way it is now and use the minor bowls for playoff sites...rotate the NC like they do now with the big bowls(rotate NC game) and use the other big bowls for semi-finals each year...we have a playoff and the bowls still make money...but then that would be too simple
ImaPK what would happen to the teams not in the playoff who have had a good year? That is what the bowl's are for a reward for a good season.
Just a thought.
PR
Pastor Rob wrote:I listened to ESPN this morning and I am so fit to be tied I can't stand it.
They were talking that if Michigan played OSU close that it could be a rematch for the NC even if a Big East Team goes undefeated.
Right now in my opinion. The winner of the UL/WVU game is in the drivers seat. If they win out, how can you deny an undefeated team out of a BSC conference a shot at the NC?
I don't care if UT(both of them)/UF/ND ends up with one loss, if UL (who I think will win Thursday Night) or WVU goes undefeated they should play in the NC game in desert.
No doubt now, that it's time for a playoff in football, however, I have to admit I've not heard a good solution for a playoff either.
Either way, go Big East do us proud.
That's my $.02
PR
ImaPK wrote:Yeah let's take 6-5 Vanderbilt and 6-5 Illinois and "reward" them with a Bowl Game...they each won 2 games in their conference...Bowl Games are all about money...nothing more and nothing less...the Bowl Commitees try to figure out which teams to invite to draw the biggest crowd...hypo sit...SEC has a "tie-in" with the Music City Bowl...Kentucky and Tennessee both finish 7-3 for the year...now be honest, who do you think gets invited to the MCB?...who will draw the bigger crowd against say Clemson who is also 7-3?...a few years ago UT lost 2 games(one in the SEC championship) and "got stuck" going to the Citrus Bowl...Notre Dame also had two losses that year(one to UT) and because they are ND went to one of the "Big 4"...go read my post on the OREGON STATE thread to your post
I think that the OSU/UM thing will not happen...WHY because the other conferences will not like the fact that ONE conf has both the top spots.... This is just a something to fill time...
dalebert wrote:I think it would be awesome for any conf to have their top two teams to play for the NC! It speaks highly of the conf and it would draw big bucks!
ImaPK wrote:Ok here's your format..the following would be first round playoff games based on the current BCS rankings...
Game 1...Ohio State vs. Wisconsin in the Insight Bowl
Game 2...Boston College vs. Michigan in the Meineke Car Care Bowl
Game 3...Boise State vs. West Virginia in the Alamo Bowl
Game 4...Florida vs. Arkansas in the Chick-fil-A Bowl
Game 5...Louisville vs. Rutgers in the MPC Computers Bowl
Game 6...Auburn vs. Tennessee in the Outback Bowl
Game 7...Texas vs. California in the Sun Bowl
Game 8...USC vs. Notre Dame in the Liberty Bowl
Game 9...winner Game 1 vs. winner Game 8 in the Cotton Bowl
Game 10..winner Game 2 vs. winner Game 7 in the Gator Bowl
Game 11..winner Game 3 vs. winner Game 6 in the Capital One Bowl
Game 12..winner Game 4 vs. winner Game 5 in the Rose Bowl
Game 13..winner Game 9 vs. winner Game 12 in the Orange Bowl
Game 14..winner Game 10 vs. winner Game 11 in the Sugar Bowl
Game 15..winner Game 13 vs. winner Game14 for NC at the Fiesta Bowl
All the other Bowls can be "reward" Bowls for those who don't make the playoffs...no team can make the playoffs with more then one loss...no automatics for conferences...no "ties-ins" to Bowls with conferences...ND is not an "automatic"...sure there will still be gripes and complaints and sure some conferences might have multiple teams and sure some conferences will get left out...but if you "do it on the field" you make the playoffs...pretty simple if you ask me
CantBCoy wrote:Playoffs in college football are a wonderful thought, but don't work on paper. There's no way to get all the games in. Only perceivable playoff system would be between the top four teams.
Pastor Rob wrote:CantBCoy wrote:Playoffs in college football are a wonderful thought, but don't work on paper. There's no way to get all the games in. Only perceivable playoff system would be between the top four teams.
And I'm back to my same question how would it work?
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 27 guests