Page 1 of 1

OREGON STATE!!!

Posted: October 28th, 2006, 1:16 pm
by EagerBeaver
Congrats to the Beavs for ending USC's insane regular season winning streak. My girlfriend is an OSU student and went to the game....says everyone is going nuts on the field right now. Amazing.

Posted: October 29th, 2006, 3:50 am
by ImaPK
The only good thing to come out of USC losing is that my number 2 team(UT) will move up in the BCS...which brings up another point...the media keeps saying how weak the PAC10 is yet they have Cal ranked ahead of the Vols in the BCS...the Vols SMOKED the Bears in the first game of the season and the Vols barely got beat by the Gators...can someone say PLAYOFF?...I know it's all about money and the school's argument is that it hurts the players, but come on, Division I is the only one without a playoff...I guess the other Divisions don't get hurt with their playoffs :roll:

Re: OREGON STATE!!!

Posted: October 30th, 2006, 5:52 am
by Paully_44
EagerBeaver wrote:Congrats to the Beavs for ending USC's insane regular season winning streak. My girlfriend is an OSU student and went to the game....says everyone is going nuts on the field right now. Amazing.



The expected has happened. Having watched a few USC games this year, this was bound to happen. They have not played like a top team. They seem to have scraped by undefeated until this past weekend. It just so happened that OSU Beav's were the team to beat them.

Posted: October 30th, 2006, 9:38 am
by dolfan
I'm with you, IMAPK. We are on opposite ends of the Bama-UT spectrum :wink: but I can't figure out how Cal gets in front of Tennessee in the BCS poll. I guess it doesn't matter much yet. The rest of the season is yet to be played.

Posted: October 30th, 2006, 11:17 am
by Rob
ImaPK wrote:The only good thing to come out of USC losing is that my number 2 team(UT) will move up in the BCS...which brings up another point...the media keeps saying how weak the PAC10 is yet they have Cal ranked ahead of the Vols in the BCS...the Vols SMOKED the Bears in the first game of the season and the Vols barely got beat by the Gators...can someone say PLAYOFF?...I know it's all about money and the school's argument is that it hurts the players, but come on, Division I is the only one without a playoff...I guess the other Divisions don't get hurt with their playoffs :roll:


Wrong ImaPK, the only good thing about USC losing is that it simply shows again that the BCS is a joke. now you so many teams in line for the NC game. What will be a real shame is if UL/WVU winner wins out and does not get into the NC game and a one loss team does.

As for a Playoff, give me a good example of how a playoff format would work, without hurting the bowl system in place and those lower teams who get rewarded for making a bowl game.

PR

Posted: October 30th, 2006, 11:18 am
by Rob
ImaPK wrote:The only good thing to come out of USC losing is that my number 2 team(UT) will move up in the BCS...which brings up another point...the media keeps saying how weak the PAC10 is yet they have Cal ranked ahead of the Vols in the BCS...the Vols SMOKED the Bears in the first game of the season and the Vols barely got beat by the Gators...can someone say PLAYOFF?...I know it's all about money and the school's argument is that it hurts the players, but come on, Division I is the only one without a playoff...I guess the other Divisions don't get hurt with their playoffs :roll:


Wrong ImaPK, the only good thing about USC losing is that it simply shows again that the BCS is a joke. now you so many teams in line for the NC game. What will be a real shame is if UL/WVU winner wins out and does not get into the NC game and a one loss team does.

As for a Playoff, give me a good example of how a playoff format would work, without hurting the bowl system in place and those lower teams who get rewarded for making a bowl game.

PR

Posted: October 30th, 2006, 2:40 pm
by ImaPK
And what happens if Rutgers wins out?...or Boise State? :D ...go check out the BCS or B_ thread for my format...and what happens if ND finishes in the top 5 with two losses, they are automatically in one of the BIG BOWLS regardless of what everyone else does...I don't think ANY conference or team should get an automatic bid...and what about those conferences who don't have a playoff?...hypothetical situation...the Big 10 doesn't play eveyone within the conference...say one year that Ohio State and Northwestern don't play each other and they both go undefeated...say Louisville and Alabama and USC are also undefeated...who plays for the NC then...five strong teams...all undefeated...all from major conferences...lets say the BCS says that OU and NW are 1 and 2...the other three are left out...for that matter pick any two of those and see the "crap hit the fan" from the other three...Division I-AA has a playoff...Division II has a playoff...Division III has a playoff...NAIA has a playoff...heck even the Junior Colleges have a playoff...and "tie-ins" with a bowl are a joke...the Music City Bowl(Nashville) gets like the 5th-6th best team from the SEC and the ACC...wow let's go watch a couple of 6-5(won-lost record)play in freezing weather...every sport in Division I has a playoff of some sort except FOOTBALL...the PROS have playoffs...HIGH SCHOOLS have playoffs...MIDGET FOOTBALL has playoffs...everything except DIVISION I FOOTBALL has a playoff...and I don't even want to get into whats gonna happen the year that 5-10 teams have ONE loss and no one is undefeated :roll: ...IT'S TIME FOR A PLAYOFF IN DIVISION I COLLEGE FOOTBALL 8)

Posted: October 31st, 2006, 4:06 am
by Rob
ImaPK wrote:And what happens if Rutgers wins out?...or Boise State? :D ...go check out the BCS or B_ thread for my format...and what happens if ND finishes in the top 5 with two losses, they are automatically in one of the BIG BOWLS regardless of what everyone else does...I don't think ANY conference or team should get an automatic bid...and what about those conferences who don't have a playoff?...hypothetical situation...the Big 10 doesn't play eveyone within the conference...say one year that Ohio State and Northwestern don't play each other and they both go undefeated...say Louisville and Alabama and USC are also undefeated...who plays for the NC then...five strong teams...all undefeated...all from major conferences...lets say the BCS says that OU and NW are 1 and 2...the other three are left out...for that matter pick any two of those and see the "crap hit the fan" from the other three...Division I-AA has a playoff...Division II has a playoff...Division III has a playoff...NAIA has a playoff...heck even the Junior Colleges have a playoff...and "tie-ins" with a bowl are a joke...the Music City Bowl(Nashville) gets like the 5th-6th best team from the SEC and the ACC...wow let's go watch a couple of 6-5(won-lost record)play in freezing weather...every sport in Division I has a playoff of some sort except FOOTBALL...the PROS have playoffs...HIGH SCHOOLS have playoffs...MIDGET FOOTBALL has playoffs...everything except DIVISION I FOOTBALL has a playoff...and I don't even want to get into whats gonna happen the year that 5-10 teams have ONE loss and no one is undefeated :roll: ...IT'S TIME FOR A PLAYOFF IN DIVISION I COLLEGE FOOTBALL 8)


ImaPK, for starters, Rutgers is not going to win out. Either UL/WVU will beat them if not both. ND is not going to finish in the top 5 with two losses. Even if they finish with one loss they will not end up in the top 5. There SOS is terrible the rest of the way.

Personally I feel like the Big Ten needs to add one team that would make it possible for them to have a conference championship game. For BSC tie-in there should be a conference Championship Game. That would eliminate ND from being such a powerful independent.

While your right that all those other leagues have playoff, HS/Division 1-AA; 2;3 NAIA, the question I keep asking is give me a good format.

Posted: October 31st, 2006, 8:55 am
by dalebert
Personally I feel like the Big Ten needs to add one team that would make it possible for them to have a conference championship game. For BSC tie-in there should be a conference Championship Game. That would eliminate ND from being such a powerful independent.


Do i sense a hint that you would like ND to be part of the B10? Which if they were to become part of a conference , the B10 would make sense for them!