Page 1 of 2

If You were....

Posted: October 16th, 2006, 4:04 am
by Rob
The commissioner of the ACC or the Sun Belt Conferences or the NCAA President, (wonder if Mr. Myles reads Jude2?) what punishment would you hand out to the players from Miami/Florida International for the brawl that they had Saturday in the Orange Bowl?

I know they have been suspended for their next game but do you feel like there needs to be more?

Any Takers?

Posted: October 16th, 2006, 4:38 am
by Paully_44
Yes, there does need to be more. Whether by the conference, NCAA or the school themselves. Pushing and shoving are always going to happen in sports. The players that used their helmets and crutches as weapons, or were seeing kicking and stomping on others laying on turf need more serious penalties. This fight was on a whole different level.

It seems that Coach Coaker is not in complete control of his program. Wasn't it his team that also stomped on the midfield logo at Louisville and then promptly got beat? Wasnt it also his team that fought with LSU in the tunnel at the Peach Bowl... and now this?

If I were the Chancellor of Miami, I would seriously look at staff changes. That is not how I would want my institution represented.

Posted: October 16th, 2006, 4:56 am
by dalebert
I think that those who use their helmets or cleats as weapons should recieve the highest charge of the law! The football field does not or should not exempt players from being above the law for that afternoon or evening just because its a game! Charges should be filed from the kids who were hit or cleated and the arrests should be made! When i was saw the replay on tv, i just could not believe my eyes! It looked like a street gang fight! Where does it go next?
I know we are only talking about this one fight and for the most part all of college football is clean but i sure hope its nipped in the bud! :( :( :( :cry: :cry: :? :? :?

Posted: October 16th, 2006, 5:07 am
by Rob
Paully_44 wrote:It seems that Coach Coaker is not in complete control of his program. Wasn't it his team that also stomped on the midfield logo at Louisville and then promptly got beat? Wasnt it also his team that fought with LSU in the tunnel at the Peach Bowl... and now this?

If I were the Chancellor of Miami, I would seriously look at staff changes. That is not how I would want my institution represented.


That is correct Paully, UL beat them and LSU embarrassed them. Sure seems like Coker not only is not in control but has lost all control of that team.

Posted: October 16th, 2006, 5:11 am
by Rob
Listening this morning to Mike & Mike in the morning on ESPN2 they played a sound bite of the UM announcers who were calling the game on the UM radio network and the color guy was a former UM player not sure who, and what he said on the radio was totally uncalled for. Saying things like no one comes into the OB (Orange Bowl) our house and disses us like this. That guy needs to be banned from calling another game.

Minutes later Dick Vitale, and I'm not sure how you feel about him, but his take was that all of the players on both sides should never be allowed to play a college football game again in their life. That's pretty bold, how do you feel about that?

I do know one thing, that if they only get a one game suspension that is a joke. Presidents of their schools should see to that or the President of the NCAA should see there is more than a one game suspension.

Posted: October 16th, 2006, 6:03 am
by EagerBeaver
What I would do if I were NCAA president would show the world that there is a no-tolerance policy for incidents of this sort...

I would suspend every single person who was involved in the fight for the remainder of the season. Anyone who used football apparel as a weapon would also face criminal assault charges.

I would also impose a ban on postseason competition for Miami and FIU in 2006. Maybe even look into revoking scholarships as well.

Violence is a lot of fun to watch at first but when it gets out of hand it sucks...even though it's interesting there is no place for violence in sports.

Posted: October 16th, 2006, 6:20 am
by EagerBeaver
Oh about the Miami commentator...

That would be Lamar Thomas, former wide receiver for the Tampa Bay Bucs and Miami Dolphins. He's not exactly the model citizen himself.

• Arrested and jailed for aggravated battery for attacking his pregnant fiancee with a deadly weapon.

• Arrested for violating probation.

• Detained for brandishing a handgun and threatening suicide, prompting authorities to check him in to a mental institution.

• Did jail time for again violating probation related to the battery charges, when he was arrested for choking
his fiancee. His six-month old son was present at the scene.

That puts a huge exclamation point on the sentence "The Hurricanes are a bunch of thugs!!!"

Posted: October 16th, 2006, 8:47 am
by dolfan
If Lou Holtz were coaching Miami and they did that, he'd quit.


I think Miami ought to fire Coker, kick off everyone who threw a punch for the year, then kick off forever the guy who swung a helmet and anyone who kicked anybody, and play their subs for the rest of the season then hire Tommy Tuberville after the season ends. 8)

Posted: October 16th, 2006, 10:11 am
by Rob
dolfan wrote:then hire Tommy Tuberville after the season ends. 8)


Why so Alabama would have a chance at beating Auburn? :lol:

Posted: October 16th, 2006, 3:42 pm
by TC
They all should be gone, and not allowed to play college ball again... AND it would be great it the NFL did something as well.

What happened at the Louisville game could have gotten that way as well, several players had thier helmets off and it was only a few coaches that really got things stopped before it got worst.

the problems is if they are kicked off the team they will land somewhere else. They need make examples of all of them... (coaches and players....) then others will think twice about fighting.

Posted: October 17th, 2006, 2:34 am
by dalebert
its funny we are talking about football like this but what about hockey? You cant tell me that fighting is part of the game when they take off their gloves and fist fight and also use hockey sticks as weapons! Come on , the level of fighting in sports has just about exceeded the level of the game for what its purpose is! I don't think sports of any kind should be used as a skirt to hide behind when it comes to breaking the law! Using sports gear or "the game" to increase ones way to win a fight or as weapons, is just plan criminal!

Posted: October 17th, 2006, 3:21 am
by Paully_44
dalebert wrote:its funny we are talking about football like this but what about hockey? You cant tell me that fighting is part of the game when they take off their gloves and fist fight and also use hockey sticks as weapons!


The only thing I know about hockey is the jokes and what I see on ESPN. That said, one glaring difference to me it that the entire teams are on not on the ice, fighting. Does this make it any better in hockey? no.

Posted: October 17th, 2006, 7:16 am
by dolfan
Pastor Rob wrote:
dolfan wrote:then hire Tommy Tuberville after the season ends. 8)


Why so Alabama would have a chance at beating Auburn? :lol:


Well, we're staring down the barrel at 5 straight losses to them if we can't pull out a win this season, so, yes. :oops: Either that or let 'em take Mike Shula, whom I've officially announced needs to go. I figure we'd be better off either way.

Tuberville coached at Miami before, too, and the money could be staggering if he finishes this season as well as he should. Plus, Auburn's program is a great program and all that, but it is not Miami. Tuberville could milk out 5-7 years at Miami with a team as good as UM has now; if he wins there like he's done at Auburn for three of the last four years, they'll like him fine (as long as he beats FSU and UF consistently enough). Then, the powers that be at Auburn are as bad as those at Alabama who can snatch defeat from the jaws of victory and will eventually do something to get them in NCAA trouble or just some great internal discord --- Tuberville knows this first hand, just ask Bobby Petrino. Tuberville, I think, would love nothing more than to finish strong at AU this season and ride off into the sunset with a fat contract at Miami (or another top tier school) and give Opelika, Alabama the shadowy view of his backside and a silhouette of his middle finger on the way out of town.

Just my .02.

Posted: October 17th, 2006, 9:18 am
by dalebert
Does this make it any better in hockey? no.


that i will agree with you......

Posted: October 17th, 2006, 1:12 pm
by Rob
TC wrote:They all should be gone, and not allowed to play college ball again... AND it would be great it the NFL did something as well.


Oh man Tony we again again. What is going on. I think instead of them landing somewhere else in college football, they should be banned from NCAA D-1, 1-AA, Division 2, Division 3. Let them go to NAIA or something and I agree the NFL, should stand for NOT FOR the LEAGUE