Page 1 of 2

Civil War....Marvel Comics style

Posted: March 24th, 2006, 9:51 am
by MrDanger
I don't know if any of you comic fans are following this or not. The ground work really began this week with Amazing Spiderman.

Spidey and Tony Stark/Iron Man went before a congressional committee about the proposed legislation that will require all super-powered beings (no word on if Benny Hinn qualifies) to register with the federal government, including revealing their identity.

Stark and Peter Parker (now working for Stark) are there to talk the committee out of this legislation before it is voted on. But, with their arguements, they actually end up making the federal government's case.

It is a great set up issue. It plays out very well. I don't like major crossovers, but this one has already gotten me hooked. There is supposed to be a major disaster where a group of good guys are fighting a bad guy. A major explosion takes place and levels a city. Tons of casualties, including super heroes. This is supposed to be the catalyst for the legislation passing. Good guys are going to be on different sides and a major civil war breaks out among all of the heroes of Marvel.

In the seven issue "Civil War" mini series, every Marvel character is supposed to make an appearance.

Posted: March 24th, 2006, 12:02 pm
by DeWayneTN
I bought the Planet Hullk part one the other night, just because I thought it might a crossover collector's item. I have Civil War on my pull and hold list but not the tie-ins or else I'd have to go find another part time job. :D I am looking forward to seeing how it plays out.

Posted: March 25th, 2006, 11:20 pm
by Gerald Creasy
While I am a Marvel Devotee, always considering their supeheroes infinitely more interesting than DCs, do you think this latest "idea" is VERY similar to what has been happening in the Justice League Animated Series??

I mean....Captain Atom starring Superman in the face under government orders and attempting to stop him, essentially, for just being Superman.
An American General so caught up with his idea that Superheroes are a danger that he takes some type of SUperSerum to stop them himself, only to find he himself causing major civilian damage and whaling the tar out of several NON_superpower beings like Green Arrow, Speedy, Kid COlt and The Question.

IN fact hasnt shades of it been evolving into being for years with DCs term for superheros--I forget what they call it but it was ALMOST the equivalent of Mutant. AN US vs THem mentality was definitely a "wind of idea" in the "Birds OF Prey TV" series.

Of course, An arguement could be made that it all began in the Xmen 25 years ago when they caught the glimpse of a future where all mutants where hunted down by Sentinels.

Posted: March 27th, 2006, 4:20 am
by DaJudge
Gerald Creasy wrote: IN fact hasnt shades of it been evolving into being for years with DCs term for superheros--I forget what they call it but it was ALMOST the equivalent of Mutant. AN US vs THem mentality was definitely a "wind of idea" in the "Birds OF Prey TV" series.
.


DC calls them "meta-humans" or "metas". Or at least that's what they called them 15 years ago when I stopped actively collecting comics.

As for Marvel characters being more interesting than DC characters, I'll grant you that they were more interesting 20 years ago, but not now. Have you read Identity Crisis or Kingdom Come? Definetly puts a new perspective on the heroes I knew and loved.

Full disclosure: I am and always will be a DC man. Ever since I watched reruns of George Reeves and Adam West and saw Linda Carter in star-spangled drawers, I've been hooked.

Posted: March 27th, 2006, 5:28 am
by Gerald Creasy
DaJudge wrote:
Gerald Creasy wrote: IN fact hasnt shades of it been evolving into being for years with DCs term for superheros--I forget what they call it but it was ALMOST the equivalent of Mutant. AN US vs THem mentality was definitely a "wind of idea" in the "Birds OF Prey TV" series.
.


DC calls them "meta-humans" or "metas". Or at least that's what they called them 15 years ago when I stopped actively collecting comics.

As for Marvel characters being more interesting than DC characters, I'll grant you that they were more interesting 20 years ago, but not now. Have you read Identity Crisis or Kingdom Come? Definetly puts a new perspective on the heroes I knew and loved.

Full disclosure: I am and always will be a DC man. Ever since I watched reruns of George Reeves and Adam West and saw Linda Carter in star-spangled drawers, I've been hooked.


Yes, I remembered Meta-humans this morning about 4am.

I agree that DC has began to "marvelize" and even now has some very good characters and stories.

I have always been a Batman fan since the Adam West Batman show I watched as a kid, George Reeves too but FACE IT DC always did BETTER TV shows than Marvel.

Posted: March 27th, 2006, 5:37 am
by MrDanger
Until the X-men movies and Spiderman movies, Marvel couldn't touch DC in movies.

And don't forget the Flash tv show of the 80's. That was pretty cool.

Posted: March 27th, 2006, 5:49 am
by DeWayneTN
It seems like each company has their own spurt of good media. DC 'owned' media for a while, putting out Superman with Chris Reeve and Batman with Michael Keaton and the closest Marvel could come to it was The Punisher (first one) with Dolph Lundgren and a nameless Captain America. Then you had Superman IV, Batman and Robin while Marvel prepared a satisfying Spider-Man movie.

Even now, it looks like DC is kinda back to a "renaissance" with Superman Returns, Batman Begins sequel and a Wonder Woman on the way, while Fantastic Four was kinda ho-hum and not sure what this new Spider-Man is going to do.

I have plenty of Marvel books in my collection but have always leaned more toward DC. It just seems there's much less back-story you have to know to be able to pick up an issue of Batman or Superman and enjoy it, rather than come in the middle of some X-Men saga.

Posted: March 27th, 2006, 5:58 am
by MrDanger
Let's see...Dewayne and Dajudge = DC
Gerald and I = Marvel

It seems to me that we have a Jude 2 Civil War "a brewin'" :D

I bet my Captain America can beat your Batman.
I bet my Quicksilver can beat your Flash.
:lol:

Posted: March 27th, 2006, 12:23 pm
by DaJudge
MrDanger wrote:
And don't forget the Flash tv show of the 80's. That was pretty cool.


That really was a good show. I think if it had been on a different network it would have been a huge hit. As it was, it was on the geriatric CBS network and couldn't attract a young audience. Plus, the used the Barry Allen Flash, not Wally West. Old school. I loved it.

As for this J2 Marvel vs. DC civil war: Watch out, I'm gonna slip on my GL power ring, whip up a big giant boxing glove and just maul the heck out of ya'll Mutant lovers.

Posted: May 4th, 2006, 7:24 am
by MrDanger
Dewayne-

So what did you think of issue number 1?

Posted: May 4th, 2006, 8:00 am
by DeWayneTN
I haven't been to the shop yet to pick it up. Should be in my folder tonight.

Posted: May 4th, 2006, 8:31 am
by MrDanger
Cool. Let me know what you think.

Posted: May 7th, 2006, 2:21 pm
by DeWayneTN
I got it Saturday (had to see what free comics were being offered too). It is a GREAT book - the best of the lot I picked up and that included Infinite Crisis #7 (which is just harder to follow IMHO). I love the artwork and the pacing, how it feels like an epic movie. It even manages to include so many various characters and still do them justice. I'm looking forward to the rest of the series.

I also picked up the Spider-Man tie in issues, including the one you mentioned before.

Posted: May 7th, 2006, 2:29 pm
by MrDanger
When I knew it was a good book was when I realized I had stopped reading because I was trying to figure out whose side I would be on. Both sides made really good arguements.

Posted: May 7th, 2006, 3:44 pm
by DeWayneTN
Well I know whose side I am on......Batman's!!!

jk. :-)