Postby TC » March 12th, 2008, 1:21 pm
Chikezie- Last night was his best, I liked it but it was not a world beater and not the best of the night.
Jason Castro- I like him but all of his stuff is starting to sound alike, He needs to change it up some last night just OK
Amanda Overmyer- I LOVE Grace Slick and Janis... She has talent but she has to do something else. Even Grace and Janis did something alittle different every now and then. I thought she should have done Come together or elinor rigby but I know they were already used but she could have done Help, Twist and shout they would have been more her style.
Brooke White- Not sure why but I really like this girl, She is a Carly Simon makeover. Has a ton of talent not trying to be the next brittney or christina but just be herself and I think that could get her to the final four
Carly Smithson- One of the best of the night, To me that would have been more of an Amanda song, She is showing she not stuck in a box. Hard to do that song justice, She did.
David A.- To me he is more like american pop star, he is in the mold of a Clay Akin, no matter how bad he does the 12 year old girls will keep in it. Should go on to Disney and start his career there (that is where he belongs)
David Cook-IF he keeps picking out those songs he is the one to beat, He could be the first rocker to win it all. He has taken songs and made them his own without making them stink. I can not think of one song he did that he could not make a hit today.
David Hernandez- I have liked him most of the way thru, not sure if the mess that came out about him, is what bothered him but not good tonight. last few weeks I thought he was in the top 5 every night... bottom five last night. Pick it up or hes gone.
Kristy Cook- desperate, that is the only way i can describe that last night. Who ever helps her pick songs needs got go back to nashville, to me is sounded like she was on the show "gone Country" instead of AI.
Michael Johns- to me he is just boring, He can sing but he has not picked the best songs for his voice... I think his is out of sync with this group.
Ramiele- One of my fav songs of all time and it was too boring, that song is not for this type of show, She can sing alright but I doubt she makes final 8
Syesha- to me everything she does is a Whitney Houston / Celine verson. Last night boring....
I hate these kind of weeks, I like the Beatles and know alot of their music, some is so classic it is hard to redo them and do them justice. It would almost be better to find a "b side" and do it straight up.
Here are a few songs that could have been done very well with the talent on the show.
Yesterday, Hey Jude, I am the Walrus, Something, Penny lane, Lady Madonna... but the one that I can not believe was not used was With a little help from my friends.