Bama mishandled the whole RR thing, without a doubt. Should I say Mal Moore did, instead? If he couldn't get a better read on the guy than to know that he would not be lured to stay by a competing offer, and he wasn't prepared to sweeten his own in the face of one, then he didn't get a good enough read on RR and he didn't think ahead. That much of the handling of the Rodriguez deal was inexcusably botched. It allowed, encouraged even, the folks at WVU to make a realistic pitch that they had to know was most likely enough to get him to stay. That would've been fine but for the fact that the Bama deal was already publicly reported. Usually, when things like this are done right, they are done so privately that only the parties involved know so that everyone saves face, no one gets embarrassed.
And, this isn't the raving of a lunatic fan base. This is the failure to close the deal by Mal Moore. He didn't just let RR use him, he practically laid himself out as a public door mat ... and with it, the whole Bama football program .... so that the WVU folks could walk right over him to get their guy to stay. And, I don't blame anyone at WVU or Rodriguez for doing it. It was irresistible, and they were both smart enough to do it.
As far as Saban goes .... I'm tired of the whole dance with him. I really don't want the guy to come to Alabama. He's the most self-absorbed human to ever coach anything, I believe. He'll be here 3-5 years and he'll be off to somewhere else to make himself greater. That'd be okay, too, if we hadn't already been down that road at this crucial period in the program's history (read: Dennis Franchione). Saban brings big time winning back here where it belongs, I think, but then the whole "coaching carousel" frenzy gets fed precisely because we hire the best guy out there??? I'd rather not, to be honest.
For my part, we're better off over the long haul to do a few things:
1. First, lower our expectations. It has finally dawned on me and hit home that Alabama football is not now nor ever will be close to what it was pre 1998.
2. Second, hire a good assistant and make this place his place where he can build a program his way. There are good ones out there, and if he wins here, and you pay him right, and you keep those expectations in check, he won't quit you. You're probably not going to win a lot, but hey ... this is the new Alabama football.
3. Become serious high school football fans and develop a love for college basketb .... I can't even make myself type it. Okay ... "develop ... a ... love ... for .... college .... basketball". There, I said it.

Human government bears the same relation to hell as the church bears to heaven. (David Lipscomb, On Civil Government, 72).