Paully_44 wrote:MacUser wrote:I don't think this could be farther from the truth imho.. I think the non American born people lost support and on top of that the Jesus Superstar song.. just didn't sit well in fly over country.
I liked Carly's energy and great singing ability.. but I felt the song was going to backfire on her.. and it did.
I dont think the song itself backfired, I think it was more of a result of a popularity vote as Randy stated. I loved Carly and thought she sang that song great. Neither her nor Syesha were the 2 worst performers Tuesday, but there they were standing in the bottom 2.
I am boycotting A.I
at least until next Tuesday.

I don't care for the song, or the whole musical for that matter, but she sang it, she didn't feel it or really seem to get what she was saying, she just sang it, and I think that hurt.
Brooke stayed on the sympathy vote, Simon said it correctly, she showed she was human, she sang OK.
Dreads needed to go, I thought Simon's "forced to sing at a wedding" described it well.
Syesha didn't deserve bottom 2, I've not been a fan of her, but she fits broadway, and that was her element.
"Why would God allow Hitler his chapter in history? Why would God send a whale to swallow Jonah or turn a woman into a pillar of salt? Surely there were other ways. But I'll leave the particular methods of God to God."
-Spoken by David Abraham, Showdown by Ted Dekker